[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

OK probably not the best example as hes kinda flopped (sorry matt fans) but matt even managed britney spears week with no problems

Another bad example (again, flopped) but I dont remember one week when Joe McElderry was bad.

So not all of them get screwed by themed weeks

Yes but they was still given songs that they could pull off, but they will use the themes as an excuse to give Lucy bad song choices imo.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Yes but they was still given songs that they could pull off, but they will use the themes as an excuse to give Lucy bad song choices imo.

Most other peoples songs would be bad choices for her.

The only things (besides her own music) I can see her pulling off are things like Kate Nash, Lily allen etc. I hope she proves me wrong though

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Most other peoples songs would be bad choices for her.

The only things (besides her own music) I can see her pulling off are things like Kate Nash, Lily allen etc. I hope she proves me wrong though

I think Lucy would be good at Coldplay aswell.

Also if she's good at Lily Allen and singers like that then I think she should sing them as The X Factor only ever favours what the Pop singers want to sing instead of anyone different.