[Jack_]

What the **** is this thread? Tonight's elimination felt really flat and kinda predictable after last week and so the last thing I was expecting was for someone to be up in arms about it...I mean really? Aren't we just clutching at straws now?

I hate to break it to you but, um...she's entitled to her opinion. Now personally I wouldn't have cared who had stayed (although perhaps District3 going would've been better for Union J, but meh) but I can see why she sided with the guys - at the end of the day even if Melanie's vocal ability far exceeds District3's, she's never going to win and she isn't particularly commercially viable either. That's not to say the boy band are going to win but clearly they're more marketable so I can see her train of thought.

Honestly though? If she hadn't have gone this week she'd have gone soon...is it really that important?

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Jack_

What the **** is this thread? Tonight's elimination felt really flat and kinda predictable after last week and so the last thing I was expecting was for someone to be up in arms about it...I mean really? Aren't we just clutching at straws now?

I hate to break it to you but, um...she's entitled to her opinion. Now personally I wouldn't have cared who had stayed (although perhaps District3 going would've been better for Union J, but meh) but I can see why she sided with the guys - at the end of the day even if Melanie's vocal ability far exceeds District3's, she's never going to win and she isn't particularly commercially viable either. That's not to say the boy band are going to win but clearly they're more marketable so I can see her train of thought.

Honestly though? If she hadn't have gone this week she'd have gone soon...is it really that important?

some people just want an oppurtunity to slag off tulisa

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Apple202

some people just want an oppurtunity to slag off tulisa

Well you can say the same for Louis last week.

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by Apple202

some people just want an oppurtunity to slag off tulisa

We were all slagging off Louis' wrong decision last week, so it's not really picking opportunities to target Tulisa.. she and Louis were both voting with their reproductive organs per respective week.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by reece(:

We were all slagging off Louis' wrong decision last week, so it's not really picking opportunities to target Tulisa.. she and Louis were both voting with their reproductive organs per respective week.

This.

[thesheriff443]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

This.

if my cock had a say ,i would still be a virgin.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by thesheriff443

if my cock had a say ,i would still be a virgin.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Jack_

What the **** is this thread? Tonight's elimination felt really flat and kinda predictable after last week and so the last thing I was expecting was for someone to be up in arms about it...I mean really? Aren't we just clutching at straws now?

I hate to break it to you but, um...she's entitled to her opinion. Now personally I wouldn't have cared who had stayed (although perhaps District3 going would've been better for Union J, but meh) but I can see why she sided with the guys - at the end of the day even if Melanie's vocal ability far exceeds District3's, she's never going to win and she isn't particularly commercially viable either. That's not to say the boy band are going to win but clearly they're more marketable so I can see her train of thought.

Honestly though? If she hadn't have gone this week she'd have gone soon...is it really that important?

Yes my ears can't take anymore of District3, Melanie just got lost in the crowd with a weird song choice which I thought she pulled off personally.