[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Jake.

What? The song itself, a live performance? I'd say the song is very much in her range

The song in general when sung live. Like when Katy Perry sings Firework live and can't reach the high notes of the studio version without auto tune.

[Jake.]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

The song in general when sung live. Like when Katy Perry sings Firework live and can't reach the high notes of the studio version without auto tune.

But I haven't seen the song sung where she's used autotune? The one Smithy posted seems pretty decent, vocally

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Jake.

But I haven't seen the song sung where she's used autotune?

On the record itself? Hence why her voice struggles when it's live.

[Jake.]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

On the record itself? Hence why her voice struggles when it's live.

No, during live performances.. you compared Perry and Gaga saying that Perry needs autotune for songs like Firework live as does Gaga for songs like You & I, even though she doesn't

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Jake.

No, during live performances.. you compared Perry and Gaga saying that Perry needs autotune for songs like Firework live as does Gaga for songs like You & I, even though she doesn't

No, I said that just like Katy Perry she only hits some notes on the studio version with auto tune, when live you see how the song is out of their range.

[Jake.]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

No, I said that just like Katy Perry she only hits some notes on the studio version with auto tune, when live you see how the song is out of their range.

But a video's been posted in which she seems pretty capable of hitting these so called 'auto tuned' notes

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Jake.

But a video's been posted in which she seems pretty capable of hitting these so called 'auto tuned' notes

Maybe to tone deaf gaga fans.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

The song in general when sung live. Like when Katy Perry sings Firework live and can't reach the high notes of the studio version without auto tune.

comparing those two is like comparing steak to an omelette

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

comparing those two is like comparing steak to an omelette

Or a pancake to a soggy flannel.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Or a pancake to a soggy flannel.

that was like 5 pages ago, either think of a good comeback then or don't bother

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

that was like 5 pages ago, either think of a good comeback then or don't bother

I only just came back online and caught up with the thread. I like to respond to all my fan mail. I'm thoughtful like that.

Bye.