[Billy]

Haley will go far, I know shes not an amazing singer, but she has an outstanding recording voice

[SiMoN!]

Originally posted by rice_square

Nah Kelly has tryed to hard to get away from american idol she went to the final this year since she won 5 years ago but she only really did that to boot her album up the charts as supposdly its not that great ever since carrie has won even though it was 2 years ago she keeps coming back to american idol twice this year and twice last year and her album is still in the charts after 2 years in america which is great and has sold over 6million and thats just her first album imagine her next one she will beat kelly for the most sucessful idol i think

but it is most lickey to happen is that she wont best her 1st album
but i do like carrie and clad she won and want her to come to england

but kelly is far better then her IMO

[CassetteFinger]

Well we all have different tastes innit kellys first album dident do that great but her second album did amazing as she came over to englad also so its world wide sales wheres carries is only in america alone imagine if she sold her album in england dont think she will do that well as she is a country artist and america has all different genres charts where we dont any way kellys voice sounds very hurt like on the final of american idol her voice was really going she sings to hard for her voice and puts to much on it with all the runs thats why i prefer carrie her voice is very powerful and natural weres kellys isent