[TomC]

Originally Posted by Greg!

The fact that it wasn't an easy situation isn't an excuse for leading someone on and lying about his relationship status

He didn't lead her on. Can't comment on the 'lie' as I don't know if it's true or not. Can it even be called a lie?

[Greg!]

Originally Posted by TomC

He didn't lead her on. Can't comment on the 'lie' as I don't know if it's true or not. Can it even be called a lie?

Well he didn't tell the truth, put it that way.

[Liam-]

Originally Posted by Greg!

Well he didn't tell the truth, put it that way.

If he has a new girlfriend, how do you think she would have reacted had he of told her about it? the scene over him giving Evelyn a shirt to sleep in provides some evidence that she would have gone bat **** crazy over it, causing more hassle than needed, if it's true, not telling her in there was probably thr best decision.

[TomC]

Originally Posted by Liam-

If he has a new girlfriend, how do you think she would have reacted had he of told her about it? the scene over him giving Evelyn a shirt to sleep in provides some evidence that she would have gone bat **** crazy over it, causing more hassle than needed, if it's true, not telling her in there was probably thr best decision.

Agreed.

[Greg!]

Originally Posted by Liam-

If he has a new girlfriend, how do you think she would have reacted had he of told her about it? the scene over him giving Evelyn a shirt to sleep in provides some evidence that she would have gone bat **** crazy over it, causing more hassle than needed, if it's true, not telling her in there was probably thr best decision.

Giving Evelyn the shirt upset Charlie because it's something Jason used to do to her when they were together. Obviously she'd be upset by it because it reminds her of the past. If Jason had been honest with her and made clear they have no future there's no doubt she'd be upset but at least it would give her closure. Hiding the truth from someone because it will make them upset is weak imo

[Liam-]

Originally Posted by Greg!

Giving Evelyn the shirt upset Charlie because it's something Jason used to do to her when they were together. Obviously she'd be upset by it because it reminds her of the past. If Jason had been honest with her and made clear they have no future there's no doubt she'd be upset but at least it would give her closure. Hiding the truth from someone because it will make them upset is weak imo

I'm pretty sure that Charlie got angry because, and I quote 'He's only doing that to piss me off'

Yes, of course being in love with someone who doesn't love you back anymore is tough and she's bound to be haunted by memories that they had, but to actively go out of your way to make out like everything he's doing, is being done to offend you or to upset you, is ludicrous.

[Lister of Smeg]

Originally Posted by Greg!

Giving Evelyn the shirt upset Charlie because it's something Jason used to do to her when they were together. Obviously she'd be upset by it because it reminds her of the past. If Jason had been honest with her and made clear they have no future there's no doubt she'd be upset but at least it would give her closure. Hiding the truth from someone because it will make them upset is weak imo

Charlie's response to that was pathetic she acted like Jason marched over ripped Evelyn clothes off and gave her a D'ing in front of her.

[kirklancaster]

Originally Posted by Liam-

If he has a new girlfriend, how do you think she would have reacted had he of told her about it? the scene over him giving Evelyn a shirt to sleep in provides some evidence that she would have gone bat **** crazy over it, causing more hassle than needed, if it's true, not telling her in there was probably thr best decision.

Bang On Liam, AND it was NOTHING to do with her.