[Red Moon]

Originally posted by farhad
I think you do understand.

I will try and work it out.

I don't think that Nikki is a celebrity, I don't think she should be a celebrity and I don't think at this stage of her life it would be good for her. I'm sure if I met her and got passed the act and really knew her I would find that she is deep down a lovely girl that is very troubled by the past. If I got to know her that well I would be counseling her to get help and sort out the past so she could move forward into the future. If she got that help, maybe if it was right for her, she could do all the things she is doing now. She would be strong enough to take everything the press said and walk away with her head held high. At the moment every negative comment about her will be eating away at her and doing her harm. She recently been worrying about her weight if press reports are to be believed. That is what she need to get sorted. Once that is done maybe we will see what talent she has.

Right, now for Chanelle and my take on her. I'm not a great fan. I didn't want her to win, but she has something that is special. Something that makes the press love her and not make fun of her. Yes she has her problems like Nikki. Yes she needs to stop the tantrums, but mainly these are in private and are not so public. She might need help with them, but she is not so self centered that she won't listen and find that help if she feels she needs it. She does have a great number of things going for her as have been mentioned in the thread already. Yes she needs to find herself and become Chenelle and drop the spice girl rubbish but she can do it.

This thread was about talent, but looking at in terms of celebrity Chanelle wins hands down too.