[MiuMiu]

[rquote=2534894&tid=145963&author=CaraRawr][rquote=2534658&tid=145963&author=MiuMiu]His sewing was very good.
[/rquote]

Rodrigo sew it apparently. xD[/rquote]

Oh christ!
Really?
Well feck that Charlie anyway!

[WAYNEEBRUM]

Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.

[MiuMiu]

[rquote=2534951&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.[/rquote]
Well fair play to him so.
I won't begrudge him this.

[Vicky.]

[rquote=2534951&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.[/rquote]

Im sure I saw Siavash say it first.

Oh well nevermind, and it was a nice idea, whoever thought of it.

Was still a bit cruel to say this is from me sophie and rodrigo though.

[Viper29]

[rquote=2534951&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.[/rquote]

Was he right to leave Siavash out for the the credit, not once but twice in quick succession???
Even though Siavash suggested the layout etc

[MiuMiu]

[rquote=2534959&tid=145963&author=Viper29][rquote=2534951&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.[/rquote]

Was he right to leave Siavash out for the the credit, not once but twice in quick succession???
Even though Siavash suggested the layout etc[/rquote]

Charlie ignored Siavash about the layout.
He said to make the heart bigger.
Charlie just said "No". and went about his own plan.
Which is fair enough.
If Siavash didn't actually have anything to do with the T-Shirt, Siavash shouln't have been mentioned.

[WAYNEEBRUM]

[rquote=2534959&tid=145963&author=Viper29][rquote=2534951&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.[/rquote]

Was he right to leave Siavash out for the the credit, not once but twice in quick succession???
Even though Siavash suggested the layout etc[/rquote]
i suppose if he thinks Siavash didnt do much in making the tshirt then he shouldnt get any credit.

[staceyxxx]

that was really sweet of charlie!,,
did anyone notice that siavash didnt help?

[Vicky.]

Miu, you dont think it would be kinder to say this is from all of us? Instead of deliberately leaving him out?

As I recall Sophie didnt do anything with it either...but she got a mention.

Siavash was trying to be involved, but charlie ignored him.

[Jackie]

I thought the T shirt was pretty good.

[Viper29]

[rquote=2534969&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM][rquote=2534959&tid=145963&author=Viper29][rquote=2534951&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.[/rquote]

Was he right to leave Siavash out for the the credit, not once but twice in quick succession???
Even though Siavash suggested the layout etc[/rquote]
i suppose if he thinks Siavash didnt do much in making the tshirt then he shouldnt get any credit.[/rquote]

Fair plays if that's right. but what did Sophie do again???

[Viper29]

[rquote=2534971&tid=145963&author=VickyJ]Miu, you dont think it would be kinder to say this is from all of us? Instead of deliberately leaving him out?

As I recall Sophie didnt do anything with it either...but she got a mention.

Siavash was trying to be involved, but charlie ignored him.[/rquote]

Didn't Charlie actually tell them all to go out and keep David busy???not letting them join in on the making of it

[WAYNEEBRUM]

[rquote=2534973&tid=145963&author=Viper29][rquote=2534969&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM][rquote=2534959&tid=145963&author=Viper29][rquote=2534951&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.[/rquote]

Was he right to leave Siavash out for the the credit, not once but twice in quick succession???
Even though Siavash suggested the layout etc[/rquote]
i suppose if he thinks Siavash didnt do much in making the tshirt then he shouldnt get any credit.[/rquote]

Fair plays if that's right. but what did Sophie do again???[/rquote]
not sure but maybe he forgot to mention his name,an innocent mistake

[Vicky.]

[rquote=2534982&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]
not sure but maybe he forgot to mention his name,an innocent mistake[/rquote]

LOL yes thats likely.

Could just as easily have said 'this is from all of us'

[MiuMiu]

[rquote=2534971&tid=145963&author=VickyJ]Miu, you dont think it would be kinder to say this is from all of us? Instead of deliberately leaving him out?

As I recall Sophie didnt do anything with it either...but she got a mention.

Siavash was trying to be involved, but charlie ignored him.[/rquote]

Like usual with all things this BB, we the viewers didn't get the whole picture of events.
But what we did see was Charlie coming up with the idea,
Charlie cutting up his towel and his T-shirt,
Roddy helped Charlie conceal the surprise in the bedroom by telling him that Dave was coming,
and Sophie helped keep Dave out of the bedroom (which she failed at, but still)
Somebody also said that Roddy helped Sew.
And we learned that Charlie sewed it.

We didn't see Siavash do anything during what was broadcast.

[Vicky.]

[rquote=2534985&tid=145963&author=MiuMiu]
Like usual with all things this BB, we the viewers didn't get the whole picture of events.
But what we did see was Charlie coming up with the idea,
Charlie cutting up his towel and his T-shirt,
Roddy helped Charlie conceal the surprise in the bedroom by telling him that Dave was coming,
and Sophie helped keep Dave out of the bedroom (which she failed at, but still)
Somebody also said that Roddy helped Sew.
And we learned that Charlie sewed it.

We didn't see Siavash do anything during what was broadcast.

[/rquote]

I despair of this place sometimes, I really do. Yes, sophie was trying to keep him out of the room...but the point is Siavash tried to have an input, charlie chose to ignore him. Then rudely mentioned everyone else, and left siavash's name out of it. Most likely deliberately if Im honest.

Had this been the other way around, and siavash had made the T-shirt and left someone out when giving it to david, the whole place would be up in arms. however, because it isnt, it doesnt matter.

[MiuMiu]

[rquote=2534991&tid=145963&author=VickyJ][rquote=2534985&tid=145963&author=MiuMiu]
Like usual with all things this BB, we the viewers didn't get the whole picture of events.
But what we did see was Charlie coming up with the idea,
Charlie cutting up his towel and his T-shirt,
Roddy helped Charlie conceal the surprise in the bedroom by telling him that Dave was coming,
and Sophie helped keep Dave out of the bedroom (which she failed at, but still)
Somebody also said that Roddy helped Sew.
And we learned that Charlie sewed it.

We didn't see Siavash do anything during what was broadcast.

[/rquote]

I despair of this place sometimes, I really do. Yes, sophie was trying to keep him out of the room...but the point is Siavash tried to have an input, charlie chose to ignore him. Then rudely mentioned everyone else, and left siavash's name out of it. Most likely deliberately if Im honest.

Had this been the other way around, and siavash had made the T-shirt and left someone out when giving it to david, the whole place would be up in arms. however, because it isnt, it doesnt matter.[/rquote]

The giving-of-the-gifts was just on there.
Siavash said "Oh wow. That is a good T-shirt". IIn a really surprised voice.
Thus he hadn't seen it before.
And they were making it for 7 hours.
This leads me to believe he had nothing to do with it.

But does it REALLY matter anyways?
It's a bit of a futile topic.

[Viper29]

[rquote=2534982&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM][rquote=2534973&tid=145963&author=Viper29][rquote=2534969&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM][rquote=2534959&tid=145963&author=Viper29][rquote=2534951&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.[/rquote]

Was he right to leave Siavash out for the the credit, not once but twice in quick succession???
Even though Siavash suggested the layout etc[/rquote]
i suppose if he thinks Siavash didnt do much in making the tshirt then he shouldnt get any credit.[/rquote]

Fair plays if that's right. but what did Sophie do again???[/rquote]
not sure but maybe he forgot to mention his name,an innocent mistake[/rquote]

He said it twice in quick succession so David got the messagw did he not??

[Kazanne]

[rquote=2533119&tid=145963&author=BIG-BRO-FAN]That was nice of Charlie to do that for David's birthday...[/rquote]

And wasn't it nice for Siavash to suggest it in the first place,for which Charlie gave him NO credit for at all,Nah,Charlie is as self centered as he's always been!!

[MiuMiu]

[rquote=2535327&tid=145963&author=kazanne][rquote=2533119&tid=145963&author=BIG-BRO-FAN]That was nice of Charlie to do that for David's birthday...[/rquote]

And wasn't it nice for Siavash to suggest it in the first place,for which Charlie gave him NO credit for at all,Nah,Charlie is as self centered as he's always been!![/rquote]

Please read above.

oh, I'll just tell you.
It was Charlies idea. I watched it today again.

[Kazanne]

[rquote=2534971&tid=145963&author=VickyJ]Miu, you dont think it would be kinder to say this is from all of us? Instead of deliberately leaving him out?

As I recall Sophie didnt do anything with it either...but she got a mention.

Siavash was trying to be involved, but charlie ignored him.[/rquote]

Exactly right,there is only a small group of them,anyone with anything about them would have said "This is from all of us"

[kisywisy]

i can't remember siavash coming up with the tshirt idea. i'll watch it again, but i'm sure it was charlie

[kisywisy]

[rquote=2534951&tid=145963&author=WAYNEEBRUM]Just watching hls again,it was Charlies idea!He suggested it so fair play to him.[/rquote]

ok, so i don't need to watch it again now

[WAYNEEBRUM]

[rquote=2535357&tid=145963&author=kisywisy]i can't remember siavash coming up with the tshirt idea. i'll watch it again, but i'm sure it was charlie[/rquote]
it was charlies idea

[Niamh.]

[rquote=2533188&tid=145963&author=headaball]Notice he didn't give Siavash any credit. Wasn't it partly Siavash' idea?[/rquote]

Yes, he completely snubbed him, "Sophie & Rodrigo helped me" gggrrrrr