[setanta]

Originally Posted by MiuMiu

Ya, you used the same excuse for her last week I recall too!

Nope, I said that she was given a horrendous song last weekend. This weekend she did well and was much better than the majority tonight.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by MiuMiu

We cannot ALL be wrong here Setanta.
You're the only one who thinks she was good.
Seriously.

Who's all? lol. She was much better than most of them. You should watch all the performances again. Not perfect but far better than some truly awful displays from the likes of Lloyd, Rikki and co.

[MiuMiu]

Originally Posted by setanta

Who's all? lol. She was much better than most of them. You should watch all the performances again. Not perfect but far better than some truly awful displays from the likes of Lloyd, Rikki and co.

Go to the **The X Factor** 2nd Live Show Discussion Show (17/10/09) thread and see all of the people who put her at the bottom of their preformace lists.

[setanta]

Yes, the same people who voted Leon ahead of Rhydian. That stuff doesn't bother me. She was nowhere near the bottom two this week. Should really watch all the performances again.

[MiuMiu]

Originally Posted by setanta

Yes, the same people who voted Leon ahead of Rhydian. That stuff doesn't bother me. She was nowhere near the bottom two this week. Should really watch all the performances again.

I don't need to. She was terrible the first time, she'll be terrible the second time.
She may have actually ruined "If I were a Boy" for me.
Lol, Beyonce certainly won't be doing any duets with her on the x factor anyways haha.

[setanta]

She really wasn't as bad as you think... just feel you have something against her at this stage because she hasn't fulfilled your expectations of her. Lucie and Stacey were rubbish tonight..... you talk about flat notes! So many others who were inferior to her.

[MiuMiu]

Originally Posted by setanta

She really wasn't as bad as you think... just feel you have something against her at this stage because she hasn't fulfilled your expectations of her. Lucie and Stacey were rubbish tonight..... you talk about flat notes! So many others who were inferior to her.

Lucie was Awful.
Rikki was awful.
Lloyd was awful.
John and Eward were awful.
And
yes, Rachael was awful too.

I personally though the other's were all ok. But still a shitty mess if you get me.

Here's MY order of worst to slightly less worse.
1. J and E
2. Rachael
3. Lloyd
4. Rikki
5. Lucie

[setanta]

There was alot of crap tonight but you're being very unkind to her when you place her below Lloyd, Rikki and Lucie.

Worst would go like this for me... 1.Lloyd - oh dear
2.Rikki - nothing
3.Miss Frank - didn't gel
4.Stacey - all over the place
5.Lucie - very uncomfortable
6.Jamie - can't stand him
7.J and E (enterained me again!)

[setanta]

But it's really a toin coss between them all for their placings, apart from Lloyd and Rikki who were absolutely shocking.

[Billy]

Originally Posted by setanta

There was alot of crap tonight but you're being very unkind to her when you place her below Lloyd, Rikki and Lucie.

Worst would go like this for me... 1.Lloyd - oh dear
2.Rikki - nothing
3.Miss Frank - didn't gel
4.Stacey - all over the place
5.Lucie - very uncomfortable
6.Jamie - can't stand him
7.J and E (enterained me again!)

Oh please. You're just rehashing what the judges said to make Rachel look better. "Miss Frank - didn't gel". Seriously.

[setanta]

Originally Posted by Billy

Oh please. You're just rehashing what the judges said to make Rachel look better. "Miss Frank - didn't gel". Seriously.

They didn't though and that's what a group is all about. The performance didn't ring true and felt so forced. It was very poor.

[Z]

I thought Miss Frank were good last week, and they were good this week. It's infinitely more difficult for a group to pull off a good performance, because just one person can bring it down. A solo singer relies completely on their own abilities - if just one of the members of a group is slightly off, then they can drag the whole performance down. I thought Graziella was to blame for the comments Simon gave them, but by no means did I think she was bad. The judges are so wacky; they give negative comments on good performances (Danyl Week 1), they give irrelevant comments (Kandy Rain Week 1) and they make comments like 'you didn't gel' to Miss Frank who were literally thrown together at the last minute.


I think if Miss Frank were to go tomorrow, it'd be a massive error on behalf of the judges/public. If they're lacking in votes, then it certainly isn't because girls watching dislike them; I think they're actually a really likable group, they don't show off their bodies or let sexuality come into their performances.

Oh and for what it's worth, I thought Rachel was good too...