[Captain.Remy]

Message original : XxShortyxX

That means I am a slut, I dressed like that once for a girls night out they are young, and most girls dress like that, if you think that's bad you should of been out last night in my town, the girls dress worse then that lol.

No that's different. I am clubbing a lot so I know exactly how the girls dress the night, I even enjoy it lol
But it's a talent show not a porn film, people will vote for them only because they are hot and fit. They should do something with more talent and less acting.

[Ann]

very well pointed out there Remy well done

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : Ann
very well pointed out there Remy well done

Thanks ! Now that I'm watching X Factor I'm going to be always there haha
I hope that next week, Hope will do something much better and more sensible. We have already seen that type of groups, that's not attractive.

[Red Moon]

Hope dressed like the people in the film. It was to get the mood of the film and song into the performance. I can't see anything wrong with that to be honest.

[beanny]

Hope Were The Best. Theyre Talented, Sexy and Theyre Going To Win!

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by beannyy2k7
Hope Were The Best. Theyre Talented, Sexy and Theyre Going To Win!

lol they are very sexy, but they shouldn't win just because they are 'sexy' tis a talent/singing show, not who's the best looking.

I hate it when Girls vote the 'fit' guy because they fancy them, most of them are just silly teenage girls that don't know talent.

[TopzTom]

Niki again.

I'm so pleased and actually quite surprised she's winning by such a large majority.

[Arneldo]

Niki by a mile, then Bev & Leon.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Niki by a mile, then Bev & Leon.

Leon McRubbish lived up to his name, he was rubbish. He was so nervous at the start of the song it was cringe TV. It made you just want to get one of those large hooks and pull him off the stage.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by TopzTom
Niki again.

I'm so pleased and actually quite surprised she's winning by such a large majority.

Me to, and she is fav 2 win

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Red Moon

Leon McRubbish lived up to his name, he was rubbish. He was so nervous at the start of the song it was cringe TV. It made you just want to get one of those large hooks and pull him off the stage.

IMO he is brilliant. His voice was superb, although not the best in the competition, I find it more endearing then Niki or Bevs and I just dont like Rydians type of music. He just needs to sort out his nerves and he could be a big competitor. He has a lot of supprt, and not just from Scottish and/or teenage vote as some people are trying to make out.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Arneldo
His voice was superb, although not the best in the competition, I find it more endearing then Niki or Bevs and I just dont like Rydians type of music. He just needs to sort out his nerves and he could be a big competitor. He has a lot of supprt, and not just from Scottish and/or teenage vote as some people are trying to make out.

It might be a superb voice in theory but in practice he hasn't performed well at all. You can't keep someone because they could do well. Like Simon said it's a talent show. It's not a show for losers that can't perform on the big show on the night. He should have gone last week but the stupid voting system allowed him to stay.

His got a lot of support for all the wrong reasons and not because he is any good on the show.

[XxShortyxX]

It might be a superb voice in theory but in practice he hasn't performed well at all. You can't keep someone because they could do well. Like Simon said it's a talent show. It's not a show for losers that can't perform on the big show on the night. He should have gone last week but the stupid voting system allowed him to stay.

His got a lot of support for all the wrong reasons and not because he is any good on the show. [/quote]


Yeah I agree, I also think he is getting the Teenage Girls vote as well, as they think he is 'fit'

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Red Moon

It might be a superb voice in theory but in practice he hasn't performed well at all. You can't keep someone because they could do well. Like Simon said it's a talent show. It's not a show for losers that can't perform on the big show on the night. He should have gone last week but the stupid voting system allowed him to stay.

His got a lot of support for all the wrong reasons and not because he is any good on the show.

I think, and many other would agree, that he has performed brilliantly. The dancing wasn't the best last weeks but he isn't a dancer, he is a singer, and a brilliant one at that. I think he just lets the nerves get the better of him. I mean look at him in front of the judges, he is a nervous wreck, nut if you look at Xtra Factor VT's or videos on OS he is fun, lively.

[XxShortyxX]

His got a lot of support for all the wrong reasons and not because he is any good on the show. [/quote]

I think, and many other would agree, that he has performed brilliantly. The dancing wasn't the best last weeks but he isn't a dancer, he is a singer, and a brilliant one at that. I think he just lets the nerves get the better of him. I mean look at him in front of the judges, he is a nervous wreck, nut if you look at Xtra Factor VT's or videos on OS he is fun, lively. [/quote]


But you can't be nerouv like that, if he went on stage in front a millions of people and performaed the way he has, people would ask for their money back. He has no stage present, and a dull personlaity, not that it matter's. He can sing, but his performances have been far from Brilliantly.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Arneldo
I think, and many other would agree, that he has performed brilliantly. The dancing wasn't the best last weeks but he isn't a dancer, he is a singer, and a brilliant one at that. I think he just lets the nerves get the better of him. I mean look at him in front of the judges, he is a nervous wreck, nut if you look at Xtra Factor VT's or videos on OS he is fun, lively.

Others might agree but the truth is that his singing is rubbish because of his nerves. If it going to be like this for him every week the he would be better off out of the show for his own health and state of mind. It's not realistic to keep him in because he won't be a star until he gains self confidence. At the moment he can't cut the mustard and it is as simple as that.

It's not what they do on the Xtra factor that is important it is what they do in front of the audience on the live show. That is what the show is about and what we are judging not the extra that they packaged with it.

What people seem to be saying is Leon McRubbish is a nice guy so keep him in. When what they should be doing is saying that can't perform so it's time to send him back to his mummy.

[dupin]

Originally posted by Arneldo
I think, and many other would agree, that he has performed brilliantly.

Wrong. Try and find someone who ISN'T a Leon fan to claim he was any good.

The dancing wasn't the best last weeks but he isn't a dancer, he is a singer,

So? None of them are dancers, and I don't think the main concern last week was with the dancing. Sure, it was awful, but so was the song choice, the arrangement, the backing music, and yes, the singing.

and a brilliant one at that.

Wrong. He's distinctly average. If he wasn't appealing to teenage girls, he would no way be in the live shows. Same with Andy, really.

I think he just lets the nerves get the better of him. I mean look at him in front of the judges, he is a nervous wreck, nut if you look at Xtra Factor VT's or videos on OS he is fun, lively.

Wrong again. I've yet to see any personality. All I can see is someone who goes on and on about having a single mum and feeling sorry for himself.

[Bells]

Niki was absolutely fantastic. She really put all her effort into the song, and I think there was an additional enormous amount of pressure for her since she had to sing with Celine Dion also there, and with some help from her as well. My vote goes to her.

I think, generally speaking, most of the contestants put a lot of effort into their songs. For effort as well as pulling it off though, I think Beverley, Hope and Rhydian were really good. People don't seem to like Futureproof much, although I think they were all right. I think the judges were spot on in what they said about Hope - despite their short time as a group, they did look as if they had been doing it for years and did a fantastic job.

[Coco4beam]

Hope indeed mabe another one like niki

[GiRTh]

I'm glad Niki is winning this poll. She was easily the best on Saturday. I think she slightly shouted the big money note first time in her song but she hit it spot on second time.

Rhydian cracked me up.

Hope were not as good as I thought they were going to be. I'd like them to stop dressing like sluts and sing a great song.

In fact I think Futureproof were much better.

Same difference were OK.

None of the other solo vocalists stood out.