[occasionalposter]

Originally posted by treacle
I thought we'de moved pass all this and decided to believe what we wanted and get on with being fans and just enjoy! what went wrong if she is with Neil or not or with Stu or not what does it matter its her own business and it looks like she wants it that way so lets respect that - please!

Treacle, i suspect you're wasting your breath.

Judging some of the posts on this thread it appears that not everyone believes Michelle is entitled to a private life.

[occasionalposter]

Originally posted by Philip

Well judging by the content of a couple of recent posts about Michelle and Neil you may assume nobody would think along those lines except me. If I have got it wrong I apologise.

Oh you mean you and Johnny.

Well apart from you both posting the same opinion on Michelle & Neil's (non)relationship, and both claiming to know this as fact, and despite this never acknowledging each other on the board, and Johnny's total of three posts all being posted within an hour of one of yours, i cannot see why i would believe you may be the same person.

I wonder if Johnny thinks i was referring to him?

[Philip]

Originally posted by occasionalposter

Oh you mean you and Johnny.

Well apart from you both posting the same opinion on Michelle & Neil's (non)relationship, and both claiming to know this as fact, and despite this never acknowledging each other on the board, and Johnny's total of three posts all being posted within an hour of one of yours, i cannot see why i would believe you may be the same person.

I wonder if Johnny thinks i was referring to him?

Well I was right then you were alluding to me. Is it you just can't accept the fact that there couldn't possibly be other people that know the same thing as me, without it being me. Well sorry to disappoint you, but you have wasted your time, which is a shame because you have obviously put a lot of effort into this.

If you want to check out who is using more than one username may I suggest you "investigate" other members or why don't you just ask Admin and save yourself a lot of time and trouble I am sure they will be only too happy to help you.

[Johnny]

First let me point out that my name is John and I only post under one name I have neither the time or the inclination to post under other assumed names and the fact that I have only posted a fews time is because I have only recently registered to this site and you can check that out as well but had been reading with interest. I know no one else who posts on here and judging by your comments occasionalposter I don't want too so if that is your inference and just because I happen to agree with Phillip who seems to be the only one posting any sense on here at the moment you assume I am that person as well I have absolutely no need to to do this. Treacle is right you should believe what you want to believe and I will leave you too it as I won't be posting again. Phillip good luck to you mate I fear you are a lone voice and I apologise if a few think you and me are one.

[Johnny]

Well said Phil mate, I'm letting them believe what they want I think you and I are a minority and I won't be posting again and this is not a forum I want to be on. Good luck.

[Jillian]

How sad is it that just because people post similar thoughts or are in the minority people on here don't seem to like it. I find it strange that if two people think alike they must be the same person is that possible? So all of you who think differently to John and Phillip how many of you are the same person come on own up. I have an open mind as to what I think the nature of Mich & Stu's on or off relationship is but I am aware that they may actually really be people out there who do know what is going on. Maybe if people stay polite it would not cause people to stop posting.

[occasionalposter]

Originally posted by Johnny
Well said Phil mate, I'm letting them believe what they want I think you and I are a minority and I won't be posting again and this is not a forum I want to be on. Good luck.

Well now that you've acknowledged each other i see you couldn't possibly be the same person, which i didn't actually infere, i asked a question, which Phillip presumed was referring to the two of you. I didn't mention any names, he jumped to the conclusion it was himself and another.

Johnny. Phillip has said that he regrets making posts alluding to Michelle's private life.

Don't you agree? You agree on everything else.

[chellefan]

Philip and Johnny, believe me you are far from alone with your train of thought, I enjoy your posts very much and hope you continue with them.
Gill you already know how I feel but agree it would be nice to have some politeness. If people don't agree with Philip or Johnny then that is fine, everybody should be entitled to their opinion without feeling like it is being ridiculed. On the other hand I tend to agree with treacle, in that it is obvious to me that whatever is happening, and lets not forget it is someone's personal life we are discussing, I am sure we will know at some point or another by the person herself when she is ready to do that, at least I hope so.

[occasionalposter]

Originally posted by chellefan
Philip and Johnny, believe me you are far from alone with your train of thought, I enjoy your posts very much and hope you continue with them.
Gill you already know how I feel but agree it would be nice to have some politeness. If people don't agree with Philip or Johnny then that is fine, everybody should be entitled to their opinion without feeling like it is being ridiculed. On the other hand I tend to agree with treacle, in that it is obvious to me that whatever is happening, and lets not forget it is someone's personal life we are discussing, I am sure we will know at some point or another by the person herself when she is ready to do that, at least I hope so.

Do you enjoy all their posts?

They (both) have claimed to know details of Michelle's private life which (they) have chosen to post on a internet board which anybody can read. Phillip says he regrets this, so i presume he won't be alluding to any more 'private' details about her on here at least. I don't know about Johnny.

[Jillian]

It seems to me Occasionalposter that you have a problem with Phillip and Johnny and I am not sure why that is and why should they answer to you. Others have posted views on here but your impolite remarks just seem to be aimed at these two. I hope they carry on posting as yes actually I do enjoy their posts and they are entitled to their opinions along with everyone else and shouldn't be asked to explain them. Whatever is going on if there is anything then I am sure we will find out whenever anyone wants us to know.

[occasionalposter]

Originally posted by Gill
It seems to me Occasionalposter that you have a problem with Phillip and Johnny and I am not sure why that is and why should they answer to you. Others have posted views on here but your impolite remarks just seem to be aimed at these two. I hope they carry on posting as yes actually I do enjoy their posts and they are entitled to their opinions along with everyone else and shouldn't be asked to explain them. Whatever is going on if there is anything then I am sure we will find out whenever anyone wants us to know.

If by anyone you mean Michelle, then that's fine.

My problem is that Phillip has stated that he know's something that would firstly make Michelle a liar, and secondly the reason this information isn't public knowledge is because Michelle dosen't wish it to be.

Therefore by even claiming that not all is what it seems with Michelle and Neil's relationship he has invaded her privacy.

Which of Phillip's post's do you enjoy?

Are they the ones he says he regrets posting in the first place?

And if Phillip (Johnny) or anybody else dosen't wish to answer my questions, then they don't have too. It's entirely upto them.

[Jillian]

I hope that no one stops posting everyone is entitled to their views no matter what they are most of us on here are interesting in reading what you have to say and you don't have to answer to anyone else.

[occasionalposter]

Originally posted by Gill
I hope that no one stops posting everyone is entitled to their views no matter what they are most of us on here are interesting in reading what you have to say and you don't have to answer to anyone else.

Who has asked anybody to stop posting their views? I know i haven't.

I stated that i didn't believe some of Phillip's posts were appropriate and he agreed and said he regretted posting them.

[Philip]

occasionalposter.

As you quite rightly have pointed out I do regret posting in the first place and realise it was an invasion of Michelle's privacy, but it doesn't alter my views.

However, obviously that isn't good enough for you, because you seem intent on reminding people of what I have said at every given opportunity. Why is that?

Not that it bothers me, because if people want to read my posts they are always there, I don't delete anything.

Can I ask you, do you think the posting of personal photographs of Michelle and Neil an invasion of privacy or is
that acceptable because it was supposed to prove a point? I don't think for one minute that those pictures weren't copied and will turn up elsewhere on the internet. At least I have only posted on here.

[occasionalposter]

Originally posted by Philip
occasionalposter.

As you quite rightly have pointed out I do regret posting in the first place and realise it was an invasion of Michelle's privacy, but it doesn't alter my views.

However, obviously that isn't good enough for you, because you seem intent on reminding people of what I have said at every given opportunity. Why is that?

Not that it bothers me, because if people want to read my posts they are always there, I don't delete anything.

Can I ask you, do you think the posting of personal photographs of Michelle and Neil an invasion of privacy or is
that acceptable because it was supposed to prove a point? I don't think for one minute that those pictures weren't copied and will turn up elsewhere on the internet. At least I have only posted on here.

If you are referring to sausage posting the pic of Michelle and Neil together then i don't believe she should of posted it if she didn't have their permission. As she deleted the pic after a couple of minutes i suspect she didn't.

We shall have to wait and see if anybody who copied it has enough integrity not to post it elsewhere.

I'm pleased to hear that you only post on here as i was beginning to suspect our paths had crossed previously.

Maybe it was Johnny who previously went by the username 'Jacko' instead?

He also claimed to know information about Michelle which although alluding to what that information was he wasn't at liberty to actually reveal it.

He also claimed regret at making said claims and shortly after disappeared from the forum. Although he does check in daily to read the board without posting.

[Bubs]

Here we go again, treacle you are very right in what you say let's try move on guys and support Michelle please, whatever we believe all this is getting petty now!!

[Philip]

Originally posted by occasionalposter

If you are referring to sausage posting the pic of Michelle and Neil together then i don't believe she should of posted it if she didn't have their permission. As she deleted the pic after a couple of minutes i suspect she didn't.

We shall have to wait and see if anybody who copied it has enough integrity not to post it elsewhere.

I'm pleased to hear that you only post on here as i was beginning to suspect our paths had crossed previously.

Maybe it was Johnny who previously went by the username 'Jacko' instead?

He also claimed to know information about Michelle which although alluding to what that information was he wasn't at liberty to actually reveal it.

He also claimed regret at making said claims and shortly after disappeared from the forum. Although he does check in daily to read the board without posting.

I take it that was on another forum then because I don't recognise the name on here.

[occasionalposter]

Originally posted by Philip

I take it that was on another forum then because I don't recognise the name on here.

Yes it was on another forum.

There are many names from there that i recognise on here and like myself some members who have chosen a different username.

If you are interested i'm sure that some of them could verify how similar your posts are to his, or maybe i could even post a link to them. I'm sure you'd find the similarity uncanny.

But as you said you don't recognise that username so it is obviously not you.

Maybe it was Johnny. I suppose we'll never know though as he stated this afternoon that he would no longer be posting on here, which is a shame I think we would all agree.

[pepper]

Hi

Think this is a cool site.

I do think michelle is FANTASTIC

[RubyRose]

Originally posted by pepper
Hi

Think this is a cool site.

I do think michelle is FANTASTIC

Hi pepper

,

[pepper]

hi ya i found the site.
Iam still feeling poorly with a nasty head cold but iam so pleased to find this site.

I love Michelle as you well know and ill defend her to any one.

so there lollllllllllllllllllll:bigsmi le:

[Princess]

Hiya pepper,its Laura

[No1MakosiFan]

Hiya Pepper it's Joyce

[chick]

OH god I forgot to log off last night .Can any body tell me if there are any pictures of Michelle in any of this weeks mags please .Thank you neela for the snaps the other day of Michelle at another jodie march .The one were mr Lipmanand Mr Ransomewere almost kissing was funny ,and the one were they are throwing the cigs in the air must have been great fun,did our lovely Michelle have a bit of red eye .You would not hire this person to take your wedding photos would you ,its like rent a crowd isn't it same old same old .I notice a lot of Michelle pictures are fromthe jodie march site ,do you think that they are good friends?or is there another reason ?

[Bubs]

It looks as though Michelle has become friendly with Jodie through Emma!!