[erinp5]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

but it's a dancing competition and i just don't think jeremy's dancing is up to standard. Same goes for Jamelia. The rest all have stepped up a lot.

My point is that Jeremy has better rhythmic timing... which makes him better dancer than Jamelia imho.So if they were both in a DO , Jeremy to be saved .

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by erinp5

My point is that Jeremy has better rhythmic timing... which makes him better dancer than Jamelia imho.So if they were both in a DO , Jeremy to be saved .

I wonder if the judges would save Jamelia again if she was in the bottom two again.

[erinp5]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

I wonder if the judges would save Jamelia again if she was in the bottom two again.

I honestly think it would be unfair to save her again if she is in the DO against a celeb who has never faced the DO before. The judges surely would give a second chance to whoever Jamelia was dancing against.

[Suze]

Carol was so gracious in defeat tonight I almost wished she had stayed.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by erinp5

I honestly think it would be unfair to save her again if she is in the DO against a celeb who has never faced the DO before. The judges surely would give a second chance to whoever Jamelia was dancing against.

Yes i agree.

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by erinp5

I honestly think it would be unfair to save her again if she is in the DO against a celeb who has never faced the DO before. The judges surely would give a second chance to whoever Jamelia was dancing against.

It's unlikely Jeremy is going to be in the bottom any time soon but if he is
then it would be a joke if he was saved over Jamelia if they're both in the bottom ! because i dont care what anyone say's Jeremy is the worst dancer !!! or has everyone slipped into the twilight zone if they'd rather Jeremy be saved

[Mystic Mock]

If Jamelia hits the bottom two for her 4th time then she has to go imo because she's clearly not connecting with the public.

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by Mystic Mock

If Jamelia hits the bottom two for her 4th time then she has to go imo because she's clearly not connecting with the public.

it's about who's the better dancer and who performs the best in the dance off regardless of they've been there 3times or 10 times it doesn't matter so why should the rules change just because the public aren't voting for jamelia as much
And it's not her fault she's been in the bottom 3 times

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by GoldHeart

it's about who's the better dancer and who performs the best in the dance off regardless of they've been there 3times or 10 times it doesn't matter so why should the rules change just because the public aren't voting for jamelia as much
And it's not her fault she's been in the bottom 3 times

I never said that it was Jamelia's fault that she's been in the bottom two 3 times, I just think that it's suppose to be a competition first and foremost and if someone goes in there for their 4th time and the other person has only been in there for their 1st time then the person that's hit for their 4th time should go home as it would be more entertaining for the other person to come back and rebound possibly.

However Jamelia hasn't been in there for her 4th time yet so good luck to her.

[Papillon]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

but it's a dancing competition and i just don't think jeremy's dancing is up to standard. Same goes for Jamelia. The rest all have stepped up a lot.

BiB: But it isn't

It's a popularity entertainment show based on dancing, where majority of the time the most popular Celeb wins and not necessarily the best dancer.

If it was a dance competition as you claim it is, then all the dancers would be on the same playing field and not a mixture of abilities there is now. Also there would be no public voting & the dancers would be scored by Professional Judges from the Ballroom/Latin world.

Even The BBC have said it has always been an Entertainment Show based on the show Come Dancing.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Papillon

BiB: But it isn't

It's an popularity entertainment show based on dancing, where majority of the time the most popular Celeb wins and not necessarily the best dancer.

If it was a dance competition as you claim it is, then all the dancers would be on the same playing field and not a mixture of abilities there is now. Also there would be no public voting & the dancers would be scored by Professional Judges from the Ballroom/Latin world.

Even The BBC have said it has always been an Entertainment Show based on the show Come Dancing.

You still need to be able to dance

[Papillon]

Originally Posted by GoldHeart

It's unlikely Jeremy is going to be in the bottom any time soon but if he is
then it would be a joke if he was saved over Jamelia if they're both in the bottom ! because i dont care what anyone say's Jeremy is the worst dancer !!! or has everyone slipped into the twilight zone if they'd rather Jeremy be saved

I want Jeremy to reach the final & win

[Papillon]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

You still need to be able to dance

well that's where the so called Professional Dancers comes in, they are paid to teach the Celebs to Dance.

Jeremy has improved weekly, he works just as hard as all the rest of the celebs. Jeremy has every right to be on the show along with the likes of Jay, Anita & Helen.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Papillon

well that's where the so called Professional Dancers comes in, they are paid to teach the Celebs to Dance.

Jeremy has improved weekly, he works just as hard as all the rest of the celebs. Jeremy has every right to be on the show along with the likes of Jay, Anita & Helen.

I agree Jeremy has the right to be there, but his dancing foes nothing for me. Even though he's a really nice guy.

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by Papillon

I want Jeremy to reach the final & win

If he get's to the final then it's another Christopher Parker all over again!! basically a crap dancer that never get's any better
and thank god Natasha Kaplinski won that year

[Suze]

Originally Posted by Papillon

I want Jeremy to reach the final & win

Jeremy might with luck reach the final, I love the guy but I can't see him winning, however, can you imagine forums and such if he did they would be going haywire Jeremy is by far my favourite Celeb on this years show without a doubt, with a fitting pro partnership. My favourite for the win though would be Helen or Georgia, but Jeremy in the final would be the icing on the cake And Jeremy maynot be the perfect dancer but he 'can' dance just not to the standard of some of the others and he is great entertainment on top of that, I don't watch through my finger as I did with some past contestants so Jeremy is doing something right

[Suze]

Originally Posted by erinp5

My point is that Jeremy has better rhythmic timing... which makes him better dancer than Jamelia imho.So if they were both in a DO , Jeremy to be saved .

Absolutely he does, you are so right Erin.

[GoldHeart]

This whole forum has gone crazy , and this is suppose to be a dancing competition but you all contradict yourselves by wanting Jeremy to get to the final when he's a wooden spoon . and his quickstep oh my god!!!
it was a disaster! he was like a stiff giraffe

It's never about who's the best dancer even though it should be and yes sometimes it is and it's sometimes about who's improved but
the john sergeant's and judy murrays of SCD history get voted for all the time

And people always vote for who they either feel sorry for or who they fancy or find funny to watch . So people like Anita & Peter get forgotten about even though they've been consistently good and they even get slagged off