[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by Blurryface

Well she was okay but I haven't missed her so I'm not bothered. She's also not really relevant anymore so I feel like if she returned it'd be a bit like having a civilian on the panel lmao

True

[Liam-]

Originally Posted by Tony Montana

What's everyone's opinions on Tulisa as a judge?

Loved her and her fag ash breath

[Ross.]

Originally Posted by Tony Montana

What's everyone's opinions on Tulisa as a judge?

She wasn’t bad in 2011, trash in 2012 and random (but lowkey iconic) in 2014

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by Ross.

She wasn’t bad in 2011, trash in 2012 and random (but lowkey iconic) in 2014

I agree, I only enjoyed her in 2011 and 14.

[Morgan.]

Originally Posted by Ross.

She wasn’t bad in 2011, trash in 2012 and random (but lowkey iconic) in 2014

She was on it in 2014

[Ross.]

Originally Posted by Blurryface

She was on it in 2014

She done the Saturday final when Mel B was ill

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by Blurryface

She was on it in 2014

during the judges house as Louis Walsh's guest

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Tony Montana

What's everyone's opinions on Tulisa as a judge?

Kelly was better

I felt Tulisa was unprofessional during the Misha B thing and Louis but Gary spilled some tea on that in his book

"About half an hour before the show goes live, the producers would come in and and they'd go, 'Oh my God. That Misha. She's a bully. Can't believe it. She is such a bully. In fact, you know what? You should say it. You should say it on air. She's bullied everyone all week'," he continued.

and she did treat Christopher like **** (i didn't like him) but her comments were way too harsh.

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by LukeB

Kelly was better

I felt Tulisa was unprofessional during the Misha B thing and Louis but Gary spilled some tea on that in his book



and she did treat Christopher like **** (i didn't like him) but her comments were way too harsh.

I think everyone was always gonna like Kelly more, but I enjoyed them equally.

[Tony Montana]

Anyone remember these two?

Youtube video

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Tony Montana

Anyone remember these two?

Youtube video

I was in the audience

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by LukeB

I was in the audience

Were you? Lucky you. Must've been a hilarious mess

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Tony Montana

Were you? Lucky you. Must've been a hilarious mess

Yeah, i was also there for Cher Lloyd too

yeah but they did get irritating because they kept talking longer than what was shown and then Lisa told the crowd to shut up before leaving the stage for 10 minutes came back and sang Don't Stop Believing and it was terrible which Simon had to stop. Lisa then begged to sing another song and she didn't take no as an answer so Simon gave in and let them sing another which was That's My Goal. The punch was hilarious though ngl.

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by LukeB

Yeah, i was also there for Cher Lloyd too

yeah but they did get irritating because they kept talking longer than what was shown and then Lisa told the crowd to shut up before leaving the stage for 10 minutes came back and sang Don't Stop Believing and it was terrible which Simon had to stop. Lisa then begged to sing another song and she didn't take no as an answer so Simon gave in and let them sing another which was That's My Goal. The punch was hilarious though ngl.

I would've loved to have seen all that chaos with my own eyes. Was their rendition of Don't stop believing worse than That's My Goal? I wish we got to see that

How was Cher Lloyd?

[LukeB]

it took them 10 minutes to come back

[Tony Montana]

All this talk of All Stars has actually got me excited for X Factor

That's a first

[T*]

It’s dead

[Denver]

Tulisa is the greatest ever judge

[Jack_]

He’s ****ing lost it this is overkill

I’m here for an All Stars series as a final send off, it’ll most likely be a “second chance” style run with acts who made the lives or whatever but not much else

[Oliver_W]

Gamu!!

[Strictly Jake]

I'm excited for both celeb and all stars I always wanted an all stars series!

As for those saying Gemma collins should do celeb x factor I think her and arg should do it as a duo he sang on this morning yesterday and he isn't too bad

This would be my all stars if they could get them all (which I doubt)

Girls

Alexandra Burke
Leona Lewis
Cher Lloyd

Boys

Shayne Ward
James Arthur
Joe mcelderry

Overs

Fleur East
Saara Alto
Wagner

Groups

Little Mix
One Direction(without Louis being on the panel and all 5 back together)
Jedward

But this list keeps changing because there are so many I'd like to see return

[Cal.]

They better get Roxanne for the celebrity version

[Owoaje1993]

I can see the line up being

Groups
Rak Su
Fourth Impact
Acacia and Aaliyah
Jedward

Overs
Danyl Johnson
Saara Alto
Fleur East
Giovanni Spano

Girls
Cher Lloyd
Louisa Johnson
Alexander Burke
Amelia Lily

Boys
Sam Black
Dalton Harris
Jermaine Douglas
Matt Cardle

[Nicky91]

good choice Simon, going for bit more fun and entertainment with x factor

[Lostie!]

I'm sure Simon said the first celebrity version was a mistake and wouldn't be done again