[Jack_]

She looks naturally thin though Ben.

[Shasown]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

Bulimia and anorexia are usually related to poor body image influenced by the media and images of extreme thinness in women being portrayed as attractive.

All of the girls in Girls Aloud, with the exception of Kimberley, who seems the only one with any sense and self-confidence, have at some time or other been far too thin. They can't all have thyroid problems. It is about fashion and image.

Yes they are indeed in most cases but not in all cases.

I wish I had your certainty that it is that in this particular case.

[supernoodles!]

I believe you,she is slim but she isn`t skinnier than Nadine.I think the point the majority of us are trying to make is that Nadine is not naturally this thin,your cousin obv is,like you say she has never had a problem with her weight.She was obv born petite.

[Loukas]

Originally Posted by MarkWaldorf

look at her hand

This. OH MY GOD at that hand! Personally i think she looked 10xs better with some weight on her.. too skinny? Yes she is.

[supernoodles!]

What`s wrong with her hand?

[King Gizzard]

Granny handdd

[30stone]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

you both looking good
shes very pretty btw.

Thanks
Im sure she would appreciate that.

Originally Posted by Jack_

She looks naturally thin though Ben.

Yes she is.
Just because nadine has lost weight doesnt mean she cant be healthy.

Originally Posted by supernoodles!

I believe you,she is slim but she isn`t skinnier than Nadine.I think the point the majority of us are trying to make is that Nadine is not naturally this thin,your cousin obv is,like you say she has never had a problem with her weight.She was obv born petite.

If you would have seen her in real life you would agree she is skinnier, although yes born small and always been skinny. she is smaller..

[Firewire]

Laura look at the second picture further down on the 1st page.

[supernoodles!]

lol oh yeh I see now,mine are a bit like that though lol.The thing is when your not naturally skinny and you loose quite a bit of weight certain areas loose more than others,so sometimes people don`t look in proportion.With naturally skinny people they are always in proportion.If that makes sense.

[WOMBAI]

Anyone with any sense can see Nadine is too thin - and being too thin is as big a health risk as being too fat. People with anorexia often die from heart problems and anyone trying to promote that type of image for women is totally irresponsible.

[Shasown]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

Anyone with any sense can see Nadine is too thin - and being too thin is as big a health risk as being too fat. People with anorexia often die from heart problems and anyone trying to promote that type of image for women is totally irresponsible.

This

[30stone]

Originally Posted by supernoodles!

lol oh yeh I see now,mine are a bit like that though lol.The thing is when your not naturally skinny and you loose quite a bit of weight certain areas loose more than others,so sometimes people don`t look in proportion.With naturally skinny people they are always in proportion.If that makes sense.

Yeah her legs look overly skiiny becuase of the weight loss..

Still believe it doesnt make you unhealthy, people are to quite to say others are unhealthy.

[supernoodles!]

Does noone else think her left leg particularly,looks dodgy??

[Princess]

Originally Posted by 30stone

Yeah her legs look overly skiiny becuase of the weight loss..

Still believe it doesnt make you unhealthy, people are to quite to say others are unhealthy.

No they're not! People say celebs look scarily skinny when they do look scarily skinny! Think Nicole Richie,Lindsay Lohan and such,they admitted to having eating disorders. And they both look much healthier now.

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by 30stone

Yeah her legs look overly skiiny becuase of the weight loss..

Still believe it doesnt make you unhealthy, people are to quite to say others are unhealthy.

Maybe you should read up about it then!

[supernoodles!]

Its either dieting gone too far,or an illness thats all there is too it.

[Princess]

Look at her here,she looks gorgeous but still slim. Healthy!

[WOMBAI]

She looks healthy there and much more attractive!

[setanta]

Yep, she's very cute in that pic Princess.

[Vicky.]

Good god she looks ill...

[Jords]

Wow didnt realise Nadine was so skinny!
Yepp she is too small, not that attractive, need some more meat on her.

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Princess

Look at her here,she looks gorgeous but still slim. Healthy!

Looks beautiful here Laura.

[BBitterLemons]

No she is not 'too' thin, if she was 'too' thin she would be ill. Some of you need to get into your heads that not everybody that is thin strives to be so, shes probably a naturally slim girl and can't help but remain that way. I know plenty of girls like it and I don't think theres anything wrong with it. You can all blab on about how curves are sexy and skinny is gross but we don't all share that view-point.

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by BBitterLemons

No she is not 'too' thin, if she was 'too' thin she would be ill. Some of you need to get into your heads that not everybody that is thin strives to be so, shes probably a naturally slim girl and can't help but remain that way. I know plenty of girls like it and I don't think theres anything wrong with it. You can all blab on about how curves are sexy and skinny is gross but we don't all share that view-point.

If you can't see the difference between healthy thin and unhealthy thin - you are the one with the problem! If it was natural - she wouldn't be so much thinner than she usually is - she would have always been that way!

[Vladimir]

She looks very unattractive.