[xDramatick]

^ Simon said last year he'd never do Disco week again

[Tom]

Originally posted by GiRTh

Kiz made a good point in that she'll struggle during the genre specific weeks. I'm already chucking at the thought of Diana doing Disco week.

Michael Jackson week first, I bet she murders whatever she gets with her nails down a blackboard voice.

[Wildcat!]

Diana can do Michael Jackson1

I dont think she will struggle this week! There are a lot of songs from her to choose from that will suit her!

But like I said, I dont see her as a contender, just a pretty good singer.
She will do better than most outside of Xfactor though! For sure!

[Emzy-!!]

I think she is good, but I do agree that she is overrated.
Her voice only suits those hippy songs, and I think she will struggle with alot of songs especially next week with Michael Jackson's songs.

I don't think any of his songs would suit her voice.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Tom

Michael Jackson week first, I bet she murders whatever she gets with her nails down a blackboard voice.

She'll probably pick something really slow like 'One day in your life' or 'Ben'. I want to see her do something up tempo - she'll murder it.

[~Kizwiz~]

She certainly has talent but can she really contend with the big voices?

[GiRTh]

Strange thing is - I'm sitting here taking the p*ss but I think she's going to do quite well. I dont think she'll make the final but I can see her being around during the last few weeks. I also dont think she'll deserve it but, judging by the response on here, its clear she has loyal fans who will vote for her every week. Once the show is done I dont see much of a future for her. She's too specific in style and her style doesn't sell the millions that other styles do.

[Tom4784]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Strange thing is - I'm sitting here taking the p*ss but I think she's going to do quite well. I dont think she'll make the final but I can see her being around during the last few weeks. I also dont think she'll deserve it but, judging by the response on here, its clear she has loyal fans who will vote for her every week. Once the show is done I dont see much of a future for her. She's too specific in style and her style doesn't sell the millions that other styles do.

I reckon she'll do well outside of X Factor. She's got a good relaxing sound. She could be a singer song writer like Katie Melua or Sarah Maclauchan (sp?).

[~Kizwiz~]

Originally posted by Dezzy

I reckon she'll do well outside of X Factor. She's got a good relaxing sound. She could be a singer song writer like Katie Melua or Sarah Maclauchan (sp?).

I was thinking the same thing, she has a very edgy voice but I still feel she will struggle and its when the singer dont feel comfortable with the songs that faults and cracks start to appear

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Dezzy

I reckon she'll do well outside of X Factor. She's got a good relaxing sound. She could be a singer song writer like Katie Melua or Sarah Maclauchan (sp?).

Can she write he own songs? My little summing up was based on the fact that she doesn't write her own songs. The way I see it, if she write her own songs she'll be OK she's slip into the genre you specified but if she doesn't then I see no future for her. I cant see professional songwriters writing songs for her as opposed to say Girls Aloud or Kylie.

[XxShortyxX]

I think Diana may struggle too, but I think most of the girls will, because MJ songs are more suited to boys.