[xcharleyx]

She hasn't done ANYTHING, people just wish to judge her, pretty lame really.

[James]

Originally posted by Ash
Haha, I think he meant the pink elephant with the 'I like her' was a joke... (read above )

Yeah, that's what I meant.

[Stu]

Originally posted by Amy
Again............ Excuse me! Hello The thread states... What Has Emily Done Wrong? not what has red moon done wrong.. please stick to the topic or it will end very shortly

The thread got two posts 'off topic' , I was merely answering Moses'es question for him , a question about something said IN the topic ABOUT the said topic. Just a bit of in-topic banter. We are not a million miles away from the Emily thing you know?

What about all the pink elephant talk?

To stick to 'the topic'.... she is possibly my favourite in it now. Its ironic that I love her for all the reasons everybody else hates her .

[Moses455]

Originally posted by Stu

The thread got two posts 'off topic' , I was merely answering Moses'es question for him , a question about something said IN the topic ABOUT the said topic. Just a bit of in-topic banter. We are not a million miles away from the Emily thing you know?

What about all the pink elephant talk?

To stick to 'the topic'.... she is possibly my favourite in it now. Its ironic that I love her for all the reasons everybody else hates her .

I must agree with Stuart. We can have some banter and fun in and around the topic. We are not in Primary school.

[Moses455]

Originally posted by xcharleyx
She hasn't done ANYTHING, people just wish to judge her, pretty lame really.

Everyone judges everyone. You just don't agree with their judgment. Doesn't make everybody's judgment automatically lame, as they are all judging for different reasons.

[Sunny_01]

No but you are members of this forum and are expected to follow the same forum rules as everyone else.

[Sophii3x]

I like Emily because she's an individual, different to anyone else we've seen on the show.

About the Lesley/age thing. I don't think she was being rude, she just asked. If she hadn't somebody else would have! I actually think that Lesley was being quite rude back towards her with her face expressions, but that's just my opinion.

[Stu]

Originally posted by Sunny_01
No but you are members of this forum and are expected to follow the same forum rules as everyone else.

And I have no problem speaking up for other members criticizing a rule I find a little harsh.

Im on this wrestling forum and if theirs a topic about wrestler A , and somebody leaves a comment , he could get a slaggin for it and they would have a joke around IN the topic and still remain on topic. Its so cool and laid back. Room for discussion.

Again what about all those posts a page back about the pink elephants? Are they different?

[Moses455]

Originally posted by Sunny_01
No but you are members of this forum and are expected to follow the same forum rules as everyone else.

Well yes, sir. I am so sorry, sir. I must not have independent thought and have to stay on topic all the time and even if I post the slightest dig at someone else, I will get banned and never allowed back.

'I must follow the rules like everybody else'. That sounds just like a fascist primary school.

Heck, I'm a school professor, and I am aware that rules are there for a purpose, but anyone who blindly follows rules, with NO ROOM FOR ARGUMENT, is leading a life of such stringent conformity, it is ludicrous.

I bet the comment now is 'you don't like it why are you here'? I will answer that. I was hoping there may be some room for a debate about it, rather than 'you don't follow the rules, you're expelled'.

[Moses455]

Originally posted by Stu

And I have no problem speaking up for other members criticizing a rule I find a little harsh.

Im on this wrestling forum and if theirs a topic about wrestler A , and somebody leaves a comment , he could get a slaggin for it and they would have a joke around IN the topic and still remain on topic. Its so cool and laid back. Room for discussion.

Again what about all those posts a page back about the pink elephants? Are they different?

You've got bad taste in housemates, but a good moral argument going there. Hope for you yet!

[facehead]

basically Emily hasn't done anything wrong and is just fine.

sums it up nicely IMO.

[Stu]

Originally posted by Moses455

You've got bad taste in housemates, but a good moral argument going there. Hope for you yet!

Ditto for you [please dont lock the topic because I said that].

basically Emily hasn't done anything wrong and is just fine.

My opinion too. And yes it does sum it up nicely . Indie queen image aside .

[Billy]

Yep I agree with the last two posts. Wow that went on for ages didnt it

[James]

Originally posted by Moses455

Well yes, sir. I am so sorry, sir. I must not have independent thought and have to stay on topic all the time and even if I post the slightest dig at someone else, I will get banned and never allowed back.

'I must follow the rules like everybody else'. That sounds just like a fascist primary school.

Heck, I'm a school professor, and I am aware that rules are there for a purpose, but anyone who blindly follows rules, with NO ROOM FOR ARGUMENT, is leading a life of such stringent conformity, it is ludicrous.

I bet the comment now is 'you don't like it why are you here'? I will answer that. I was hoping there may be some room for a debate about it, rather than 'you don't follow the rules, you're expelled'.

Locked

[James]

Oh and Moses455, maybe we should restore your previous warnings (Deep2 account) that you got rid of by registering your new account.