[lostalex]

If This past series of BBUK had the US format of the show, do you think Aaron would have won? If not, who do you think would have won, and which housemates do you think would have done better and lasted longer under BBUSA rules?? Would Jay's "wolfpack" be the BBUK version of the Brigade?

[lostalex]

I think Aaron would have been voted out fairly early. he seemed to piss everyone off, and got on everyone's nerves from the beginning, and i doubt he would have lasted long. I think Tom and Alex and Jay and Louise would make an awesome alliance. Also Anton would have made it much farther i think.

I think Faye and Aaron would have been the the Rachel and Brendon of BBUSA12 and would have been voted out just for being obnoxious, just like rachel and brenden were in their first season12.

I think eigther Jay or Anton would have won if it was BBUSA rules.

[reece(:]

I think Heaven would of made final 4

[Vicky.]

Anton

Edit. On second thoughts, possibly Rebeckah too

[Maia]

Originally Posted by lostalex

I think Aaron would have been voted out fairly early.

Also Anton would have made it much farther i think.

I think eigther Jay or Anton would have won if it was BBUSA rules.

3 reasons why BBUK should never even consider adopting BBUSA's format.

[Liberty4eva]

If BBUSA had BBUK rules, Jeff would without question win the game and Rachel would be the first one voted out. So that would suck.

[Brother Leon]

Anton...he pretty much had the house under control. It was just the viewers where his gameplan crashed.

[SoBig]

Ugh. Tough considering everyone was trying pretty hard to appear like they weren't playing a game and honestly no one on BBUK would be a good BBUS player. Maybe Jay?

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Anton

Edit. On second thoughts, possibly Rebeckah too

No way. She would have been evicted by week 3. Unless she was part of a strong alliance.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Jem and Faye final 2 with Faye winning

[Samm]

Originally Posted by Mollie.

3 reasons why BBUK should never even consider adopting BBUSA's format.

.

[Mystic Mock]

I think Jay would've won a BBUSA styled year out of that series.

[Mystic Mock]

My opinion on who would've won BBUK in a BBUSA styled format.

BB5 - Stuart
BB6 - Makosi
BB7 - Pete
BB8 - Liam
BB9 - Dale
BB10 - Siavash
BB11 - Josie
BB12 - Jay
BB13 - Adam
BB14 - Sophie

Out of the series that I've watched that's how I think it would go.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

My opinion on who would've won BBUK in a BBUSA styled format.

BB5 - Stuart
BB6 - Makosi
BB7 - Pete
BB8 - Liam
BB9 - Dale
BB10 - Siavash
BB11 - Josie
BB12 - Jay
BB13 - Adam
BB14 - Sophie

Out of the series that I've watched that's how I think it would go.

They would have not made it to big brother 10 at that rate of horrible winners

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Big Brother 12

Alex - ???
Louise - Jay
Tom - ???
Faye - Aaron
Harry - Aaron
Anton - Jay
Aden - Jay

[Samm]

imo Kate would of still won BB3

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by DrunkerThanMoses

They would have not made it to big brother 10 at that rate of horrible winners

Yeah Makosi is the only good one from the BB5-9 bracket.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Makosi winning though

[karl100589]

Just for fun I ran a BB12 simulator on brantsteele.com and saw what came up for fun:

WEEK 1:
HOH: Louise
Nominations: Mark and Aden
Veto: Aden (Uses veto on himself)
Nominations: Mark and Heaven
Heaven evicted 9-3

WEEK 2:
HOH: Harry
Nominations: Anton and Aden
Veto: Anton (Uses veto on himself)
Nominations: Aden and Jem
Aden evicted 7-4

WEEK 3:
HOH: Mark
Nominations: Rebekah and Louise
Veto: Mark (Uses veto on Louise)
Nominations: Rebekan and Jem
Rebekah evicted 6-4

WEEK 4:
HOH: Anton
Nominations: Harry and Aaron
Veto: Anton (Veto not used)
Harry evicted 7-2

WEEK 5:
HOH: Jay
Nominations: Aaron and Faye
Veto: Faye (Uses veto on herself)
Nominations: Jem and Aaron
Jem evicted 5-3

WEEK 6:
HOH: Anton
Nominations: Aaron and Faye
Veto: Aaron (Uses veto on himself)
Nominations: Faye and Alex
Faye evicted 4-3

WEEK 7:
HOH: Aaron
Nominations: Jay and Anton
Veto: Maisy (Nominations stay the same)
Anton evicted 4-2

WEEK 8:
HOH: Jay
Nominations: Aaron and Tashie
Veto: Tashie (Uses veto on herself)
Nominations: Aaron and Mark
Mark evicted 5-0

WEEK 9:
HOH: Alex
Nominations: Maisy and Tashie
Veto: Alex (Uses veto on Maisy)
Nominations: Louise and Tashie
Tashie evicted 3-1

WEEK 10:
HOH: Tom
Nominations: Jay and Maisy
Veto: Louise (Uses veto on Jay)
Nominations: Aaron and Maisy
Aaron evicted 2-1

WEEK 11:
HOH: Jay
Nominations: Maisy and Tom
Veto: Maisy (Uses veto on herself)
Nominations: Alex and Tom
Alex evicted 2-0

WEEK 12:
HOH: Maisy
Nomination: Jay and Tom
Veto: Tom (Uses veto on himself)
Nominations: Jay and Louise
Jay evicted by Tom's vote

WEEK 13:
Louise wins Part 1 (Endurance)
Tom wins Part 2 (Mental)
Louise wins Part 3 (Housemate knowledge)
Louise wins HOH
Louise evicts Maisy

FINAL 2: Louise vs Tom
Jay: Louise
Tashie: Tom
Aaron: Tom
Maisy: Tom
Alex: Tom
Mark: Louise
Anton: Louise
Tom wins Big Brother 12 by 4 votes to 3.
Aaron is voted Britain's favourite player.

Didn't turn out that unrealistic. Tom was well liked in the house and being a male that wasn't that strong wouldn't likely be seen as a physical threat. Aaron as a house underdog was quite fun and would probably still see him as an Allstar whilst I imagine Maisy as a Janelle type figure based on this playthrough.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by DrunkerThanMoses

Big Brother 12

Alex - ???
Louise - Jay
Tom - ???
Faye - Aaron
Harry - Aaron
Anton - Jay
Aden - Jay

Alex would vote for Jay, Tom for Aaron. Jay wins 4-3 IMO

[karl100589]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Alex would vote for Jay, Tom for Aaron. Jay wins 4-3 IMO

Them two are the swing votes big time, and a lot of it in my opinion would depend on whether Alex and Tom took the present situation in the final week to heart. If they did then Jay would get the votes and win 5-2 but if they didn't then I could imagine them voting for Aaron since more often then not they sided with Aaron's side of the house during nominations.

Then again though if this was a more strategic game I could imagine Aaron giving her a present to garner sympathy.

[Samm]

BB3: Kate (it would stay the same)
BB5: Jason
BB6: Makosi
BB7: Pete
BB8: Brian
BB9: Mikey
BB10: Siavash
BB11: Josie
BB12: Alex
BB13: Adam
BB14: Gina

That's how I think it will go if the housemates voted