[Cheryl-cole-hottie]

Simpliy hu is the best judge
i think u can guess hu i will vote for lol
She is fit, sexy and gorgeous and has gt a stupid husband in ashley cole. y would u cheat on cheryl as u cant get much beta than her

[Bright-Eyes]

Simon you get no BS with him.

[MrGaryy]

Simon is the only one who knows what he's talking about! Cheryl might be good though, I'll have to wait and see!

[xDramatick]

Simon.

I really hate how people recently seem to only support people because their hot. It's kinda.. shallow, in my opinion.

[jkp44]

Danni because she is totally commited she is there for the contestants and not just there to be the winning judge, like dermot said last year "Danni is the first one to arive to rehearsals and the last one to leave" and also she knows what she is talkin about. She's all about providing the best for her contestants.

[Callum]

As I haven't seen Cheryl judge before, I'm choosing Simon.

[Billy]

Simon.
Laughable that Cheryl got chosen considering she really cant sing

[GiRTh]

Simon until he loses patience with his acts like he did with Hope last year. Danii is a bit clueless but she was lucky to get the boys last year. Sharon should never have been hired in the first place and Louis comes across as quite snide at times.

[Arneldo]

I'm tempted to vote for Dannii. After all she was the first judge to get two of her acts into Top 2, on her first series. But, I'm going to vote for Simon. He has always done well and never afraid to criticize even his own acts (e.g. Conway Sisters).

Louis is my favorite though. I'm interested to see how Cheryl does.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Billy21
Simon.
Laughable that Cheryl got chosen considering she really cant sing

Simon can't sing, neither can Louis probably. It isn't about your vocal ability, they leave that for the contestants, it's about their contribution to the music industry.

Cheryl's part of one of the biggest girl bands ever in the UK, she's had numerous hits and she's taken part in a show like this, so she can relate to the contestants.

I don't think its laughable at all, it was a pretty fair decision.

[Billy]

Cheryl isn't setting a good example to her category is she? As if I remember rightly she was involved in something just as bad as Emily, if not worse as shes a grown woman

[MarkWaldorf]

Cheryl slapped a woman? Lol? She was a young woman defending herself in a club.

Saying the N word is much worse I'm afraid.

[GiRTh]

Wasn't Cheryl charged with assault effecting grevious bodily harm? Thats a bit more than a slap.

It just shows that celebs can get away with things.

[Billy]

I was talking about Emily from XF.
She done more than slap, did you see teh womans face?

[Spike]

Simon he is the honest and I always go by his opinion
How can anyone choose Cheryl, we haven't even seen her as a judge yet

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Billy21
I was talking about Emily from XF.
She done more than slap, did you see teh womans face?

Cheryl's victim was the same. Her face was all puffed up and swollen.

[poiuytrewq]

Originally posted by Billy21
Simon.
Laughable that Cheryl got chosen considering she really cant sing

talent doesnt equate to success hence cheryl being in the most successful girl band in uk chart history.

also success doesn't equate to being a good mentor otherwise simon would win each year. dannii guided two of her three acts into the final 2, one of which had a bad start with nerves and criticism, the other of which had a negative opinion from the public. she was very hands on whereas the other three just let their acts get on with it.

[Arneldo]

Dannii cannot sing either, but she is a decent judge. I dont think Cheryl was chosen because she is a amazing singer. She is a young woman working in the music business. She would know more about music today then the likes of Danni and Louis.

[MR.K!]

well my favourite WAS sharon but i wont bother wasting my time watching if she isnt on this year

[dbh-g]

This poll is way too early! How can we decide when we havent even seen how cheryl is on the panel?

Just thinking, is Brian still goin to be wondering around next series?

Plus, press shot of the new series on The Sun website (it looks like Dermot has curly hair?! He looks such a cutie lol)

[JadeLauren_x]

Cheryl!
My Reasons...
1. she likes to put her opinion across
2. Shes been through the process herself
3. She has an amazing personality!