[jkp44]

This yr the panel is awesome if u think about it Dannii has sort of replaced sharon and I think she is doin a fantastic job look how much more out there she can be without sharon osbourne breathing behind her back. I just want Cheryl to add somin next week although she was still great. probs just nerves.



SHARON OSBOURNE IS HISTORY, IF SHE THINKS SHE CAN JUST OUST DANNII THEN SHE'S GOT ANOTHER THING COMING!!! THE SHOW IS MUCH FRESHER WITHOUT HER. SHE AINT COMING BACK SO SHE SHOULD JUST GET OVER IT, DANNII HAS ALREADY SAID SHE IS RETURNING NEXT YR. THE X FACTOR DOEN'T NEED HER SHE NEEDS THE X FACTOR.

SORRY JUST HAD TO GET IT ALL OFF MY CHEST!!!

[supernoodles!]

yeah im glad sharon is gone and im actually warming to danni a bit

[XxShortyxX]

I still miss Sharon, she just made me laugh so much, and her laugh made me laugh lol.

I thought Cheryl was great, Dannii was very exictable.

[jkp44]

sharon was good for entertainment i'll give her that!!!

[xDramatick]

I miss Sharon.
I prefer her comments to Cheryl Cole's.
Last year was the best judging panel IMO, but I still think they should've kept it as Simon/Sharon/Louis.

[Tom]

I miss Sharon but I really like Dannii this year. Last year she was a bit like a spare part but this year shes really come out of her shell. Judging panel was better from series 1-3 but I think they've got the show spot on this year

[MrGaryy]

Not to rain on your parade but whether or not Dannii returns nest year, isn't up to her, just like it wasn't up to Louis or Kate.

[jkp44]

I know it's not up 2 her but she saying that she is not going to quit, I think and that louis is making it up. But they could still sack I know that!!!

[jkp44]

The show just doesn't need sharon anymore the show has moved on, the talent is higher and the judges are better. IMO

[Callum]

I do miss Sharon, she made me laugh and was my favorite judge. But I love Dannii as well, she's by far the best judge now, she doesn't just sit on the fence like Cheryl. I love her personality this season too, like she was up and clapping when Rachel was singing.

[LewiisTreleaven]

Sharon was great!

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by jkp44
The show just doesn't need sharon anymore the show has moved on, the talent is higher and the judges are better. IMO

Sharon isn't stupid, if she cam back she would be a good judge.

[jkp44]

she probs would be a good judge but is she a good mentor and for teens who look up 2 is she a good role model to girls. i dont think so she proved it last yr!!!

but then that's the reason people like sharon for her explosive ways.

but she is just not for me I guess!!!

[Z]

I actually thought Cheryl was great last night, she's got a great sense of humour. I'm pleased that Dannii Minogue was a bit more opinionated last night though. I miss Sharon, but I think the new line up works!

[Fom]

Originally posted by Callum
I do miss Sharon, she made me laugh and was my favorite judge. But I love Dannii as well, she's by far the best judge now, she doesn't just sit on the fence like Cheryl. I love her personality this season too, like she was up and clapping when Rachel was singing.

I disagree during the auditions Cheryl was no way on the fence and she said no to people that the other judges would chicken out of and just let them through. Cheryl was the only one with balls during auditions.