[Riz]

she was rude and a bit extra .. two keys at the beggining i smell a HATER. jealous that they will beat her acts.

what you guys think..

was it...?

[Billy]

LMAO She was telling the truth, being honest. If she had said it was perfect from start to finish shed be lying, she said it in a nice way so they could improve

[Captain.Remy]

I guess she was telling the truth ! She's here for that, you know, giving advices and making an opinion.

[Riz]

lol i suppose so.. but lol

[Matt]

Originally posted by Billy
LMAO She was telling the truth, being honest. If she had said it was perfect from start to finish shed be lying, she said it in a nice way so they could improve

Exactly.

Dannii has nothing to worry about anyway... she has the winning act

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : Matt

Exactly.

Dannii has nothing to worry about anyway... she has the winning act

Yes Rhydian and Leon !

[Riz]

yeah i suposee just seemed a bit Biatchy! lol

[Conor]

Originally posted by Matt

Exactly.

Dannii has nothing to worry about anyway... she has the winning act

Couldn't have said it better. Rydians going to clear this series no problem.

Its simply that Danii doesn't like Hope. Its a free world you know!

[XxShortyxX]

Rydian defo, Leon no! I can't stand him!

[Shaun]

The way she said it on her XFactor blog was a bit catty... something about "oh my god I thought they were going to break my glass har har".

I don't like Dannii anyway. And she's one to talk about singing flat notes.

[Bells]

Yes, she was telling the truth, but I still thought it was unnecessary. I didn’t really see any need for her to comment on the first two weeks… it wasn’t constructive criticism, because it wasn’t based on that particular performance by Hope. She did praise them for what they did on the night though, which was fair.

I hardly think she’s jealous they will beat her acts though. Sure, she’s got competition – but she’s got Rhydian who is someone everyone likes, and someone all the judges/mentors want to work with.

[CassetteFinger]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Rydian defo, Leon no! I can't stand him!

Yeah same Rhydian is in a class of his own Leon i dont get at all the most overrated contestant ever and he dances like someone has opened an umbrella up his bum not good at all

[Billy]

Originally posted by Ash
Yes, she was telling the truth, but I still thought it was unnecessary. I didn’t really see any need for her to comment on the first two weeks… it wasn’t constructive criticism, because it wasn’t based on that particular performance by Hope. She did praise them for what they did on the night though, which was fair.

I hardly think she’s jealous they will beat her acts though. Sure, she’s got competition – but she’s got Rhydian who is someone everyone likes, and someone all the judges/mentors want to work with.

Was it 2 weeks? I thought she said the first two keys

[Bells]

^ Oh PMSL you're probably right and I heard her wrong.

Well, it was still unnecessary...

[xDramatick]

She said the first two notes/keys.

Which was the 'oooooooohhh ahhhh'
which I personally think was pointless, and kinda stupid to add to the song.

I don't believe she was bitchy, it was criticism, and true criticism at that.
It's not like she said the performance was rubbish, that would be unnecessary.
Presumably the Hope girls will learn from it.

[Wasted]

She was probably right (I don't remember the first couple of notes) but it was unecessary... it's not like it spoils the performance altogether. She should've concentrated on telling Andy about the fact that he was out of tune almost 100% of the time rather than nit-picking on two notes from another act.

But I do like that she gives constrictive criticism and she is usually spot on, except when it comes to her acts, particularly Leon and Andy.

[Billy]

Andy was in tuen :S, It was the fact that his voice was not suited for the song, if anyone was out of tune it was Niki

[CassetteFinger]

^Yes she is also ver overrated just like her titanic song that was terrible her best was the first show nothing compairs 2 you nothing else will match that she has been getting worse each week.

[Wasted]

I agree on Niki, she ruined one of my favourite songs, and it's not even difficult to sing. The only challenging part bit is "the same damn THIIIING" but she broke it up instead of belting the long note. And she was smiling when she was singing it so she had no understanding of it.

Dannii was the only one to criticise the performance, the other judges said she was great.

[Dan_]

Simon should have swapped the comments for Niki and Bev and he'd have been correct.

[Billy]

I thought Niki and Bev were both rubbish tonight

[Billy]

last night even

[Billy]

Saturday night even lmao

[Shaun]

Silly Billy

[Callum]

Trust you Billy! lol

I thought Dannii was catty, the way she said it.