[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

Wait so you condemn Elliot for dragging Lewis fans but then drag Sian fans for his comment? Did you not consider the hypocrisy there?

There will always be good and bad in all fandoms.

This thread is supposedly only about Sian and Lewis isn't it.????

[Rustic bauble]

Sian would never have won...dull po faced and bitchy. It wouldn't have mattered what she had done in the last week..who she had been up against...the fact she did nothing in the first few weeks she deserved nothing more than 5th place.

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

Sian would never have won...dull po faced and bitchy. It wouldn't have mattered what she had done in the last week..who she had been up against...the fact she did nothing in the first few weeks she deserved nothing more than 5th place.

I am sure she would rather 5th over being an ejectee

[Rustic bauble]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

I am sure she would rather 5th over being an ejectee

Is that all you can ever come back with ..try debating for once in your life..you baiting is woeful and tiresome.

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

Is that all you can ever come back with ..try debating for once in your life..you baiting is woeful and tiresome.

It was a debate

I bet she was trilled with 5th she could have been ejected like Ellis

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

Is that all you can ever come back with ..try debating for once in your life..you baiting is woeful and tiresome.

Ain't that the truth rusti .

[Scoot]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

Sian would never have won...dull po faced and bitchy. It wouldn't have mattered what she had done in the last week..who she had been up against...the fact she did nothing in the first few weeks she deserved nothing more than 5th place.

As much as I loved her I don’t think either way she would have won, but we’ve seen in the past how much the edit in the final week can count and Lewis potentially attacking her character and her not rising to it could have given her a bigger base, is all.

So regardless of what you think of her as a housemate, do you think this potential tension would have helped her?

[Rustic bauble]

Originally Posted by Scoot

As much as I loved her I don’t think either way she would have won, but we’ve seen in the past how much the edit in the final week can count and Lewis potentially attacking her character and her not rising to it could have given her a bigger base, is all.

So regardless of what you think of her as a housemate, do you think this potential tension would have helped her?

No I don't because Lewis was consistant...he had a big fanbase. Sian took herself out of the equation for being in with a chance to win for not doing anything...suddenly picking up dutch courage and a personality in the final week would have just seen her as being fake.

[Jules82]

Originally Posted by Scoot

As much as I loved her I don’t think either way she would have won, but we’ve seen in the past how much the edit in the final week can count and Lewis potentially attacking her character and her not rising to it could have given her a bigger base, is all.

So regardless of what you think of her as a housemate, do you think this potential tension would have helped her?

and of course Sian didnt attack Lewis' character....the answer is no she wouldnt have won......end of......no one seemed to feel sorry for her other than a few...and...as she said she liked to sit and watch the fracus, bearing this in mind she possibly loaded other peoples guns and let them fire them....at Lewis!

[Rustic bauble]

Originally Posted by Jules82

and of course Sian didnt attack Lewis' character....the answer is no she wouldnt have won......end of......no one seemed to feel sorry for her other than a few...and...as she said she liked to sit and watch the fracus, bearing this in mind she possibly loaded other peoples guns and let them fire them....at Lewis!

You are spot on here...

[rph]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

Sian would never have won...dull po faced and bitchy. It wouldn't have mattered what she had done in the last week..who she had been up against...the fact she did nothing in the first few weeks she deserved nothing more than 5th place.

She should have gone sooner tho - glad how this series turned out tho