[KKBL]

They both won X-Factor and went on to release an album.both of these ar there debut single's.which do you prefer?this was a very hard desicion for me as i think both songs ar realy amazing. Leona obviously has the better vopice but Shane's song is better and the video stoyline is very sad.what do you think?

Shane Ward - No Promises

Youtube video

Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love

Youtube video

[Ross]

Leona.

[Sam]

OH please. Theres no comparison. Leona wins hands now. And actually, i think Leonas song is better by far.

[KKBL]

Originally posted by Ross
Leona.

i dont mean whos bnetter - Leona or Shane.i meant which song is better?

[Ross]

Yeah, Bleeding Love is a better song.

If you had said Breathless & Bleeding Love I might have struggled a bit

[Callum]

Omg. I love them both, No Promises is in imo Shayne Ward's best song. Argh both are awesome... but I'll have to say Leona as I like all of her music and I only like one or two of Shayne's.

[Simple_Plan]

Bleeding Love Gets My Vote
WOOP!
Go Leona

[xDramatick]

No promises.

like i said in another thread

Bleeding Love's is the sorta thing that'd be written in an emokid's birthday card.
&If I hear 'I keep bleeding' one more time I'll rip my head off >.>

The only reason I like it is because it wasnt bad at firsttt, and Jesse&Ryan wrote it.

[Ruth*Star]

Leona's song is tons better, its a better song really, i personally enjoyed listening to that more than the other.

[XxShortyxX]

Defo Leona's song. She is a way better singer then Shayne.

[Loukas]

Leona

[Wasted]

Both are brilliant singers, but I just prefer Leona's voice, and so I prefer Bleeding Love. I think it's a better song too.

[Spike]

Leona's song is much better

[beanny]

Bleeding Love got my vote... but i do like No Promises........ If thats ok with you is his best song!

[KKBL]

i thought there would be some competition because IMO there both VERY VERY VERY good songs.but i guess i was wrong.

[Sam]

I'm scared Leona will really start to get on loads of peoples nerves. Lots of people hated Umbrella after a while - and I don't want people to turn on Bleeding Love

[KKBL]

and the reason i picked No Promises is because its probobly in most peoples opinions his best song and both songs have a sad story within the song.

[CassetteFinger]

Leona of course it was much more succesful and got to number 1 no promises got to number 2 plus her song is better and she has a much better voice.