[MR.K!]

does anyone else think that Kady looks like such a spoiled brat ?

[Billy]

Not really, I feel sorry for her, she gets criticised for her personality every week, when Simon produced Leona, one of the most boring singers ever.

[Spike]

The boys were awful this week, didn't really like anyone’s performance. Simon seemed to be really annoyed and nasty when commenting on some of the performances.

[CassetteFinger]

I havent watched idol on tele for week's only on youtube. Im find it boring sitting through a whole show which is annoying. Im gonna start watching properly next week, top 12, big stage, woo Carly this week was my favorite.

[Dan_]

The top 12 is:

[spoil]
1.David Archuleta
2.Chikezie Eze
3.David Cook
4.David Hernandez
5.Carly Smithson
6.Ramiele Maluaby
7.Brooke White
8.Syesha Mercardo
9.Jason Castro
10.Michael Lee Johns
11.Amanda Overmyer
12.Kristy Lee Cook[/spoil]

[Billy]

Gutted that [spoil] kady and danny [/spoil] didn't get through

[Conzors]

Woooo sooo glad about

spoil]
1.David Archuleta
2.Chikezie Eze
3.David Cook
4.David Hernandez
5.Carly Smithson
6.Ramiele Maluaby
7.Brooke White
8.Syesha Mercardo
9.Jason Castro
10.Michael Lee Johns
11.Amanda Overmyer
12.Kristy Lee Cook[/spoil]

all of them getting through =]

[GiRTh]

I'd love to watch this season but my freeview is playing up. Does Randy Jackon still say the same things over and over?

[Legend]

Asia'h didn't go through? The season just gets worse.

[xDramatick]

DDDDDAAAAAAANNNNNNNNNNNNNYYYYYYY
<333
HOWTHEHELLDIDHENOTGETTHROUGH?
THAT'SEVIL.
HEWASAMAZING.
ANDENTERTAINING.
ANDOUTRAGEOUS.
ANDAGREEEATSINGER.
ANDI'VELOVEDHIMSINCEHISFIRSTAUDITION
ANDRAMIELESTARTEDCRYING
ANDIDONTCAREIFTHISISASPOILER.


the other three I'm kinda =|
went off kady. asia'h i'm sad to see go.

WHY COULDNT SYESHA GO?
OR CHIKEKIKICKIEZIKIEKCIKZIEKCIKE.

[Billy]

can you try n put spaces in please? thanks.

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Billy21
can you try n put spaces in please? thanks.

howboutno

[Conzors]

Originally posted by Darenn

howboutno

LaughingMyAssOff :P =]

[CassetteFinger]

Im gonna stick with Carly as she is irish and my mum is irish, plus she has a great voice, my favorite this week.

[Spike]

How didn't Danny get through, I thought he was great.

[TopzTom]

I'm furious right now.

Asia'h was my favourite of this year's bunch and thoroughly deserved a place in the top twelve.

Danny was greatly entertaining and kept me laughing at Simon throughout the competition.

Luke and Kady were the right two to go, but they should've been out with Amanda and Jason - two terribly bad "singers".

[Billy]

I loved Danny and Kady. Another two of my faves out now, mine are going week by week

[greggurski]

I was EXTREMELY sad to see Asiah go. But other than Amanda, I love all of the girls, and Amanda really did kick some ass this week with her performance.

[Tom4784]

Sad to see Asiah and Danny go, I'd rather have seen Chikeze leave over Danny.

I think my final choice of favourites now are: David Archuleta, Micheal John, Amanda Overmyer and Ramiele.

[xDramatick]

idk who i'll back now.

Probably stick with Ramiele+Michael.


LMFAO @ Billy.
Curse of Billy Returns?

[Dan_]

My ranking on the top 12 after last nights performances:

1.Chikezie Eze
2.David Cook
3.Brooke White
4.Ramiele Malubay
5.Carly Smithson
6.David Hernandez
7.Michael Johns
8.Jason Castro
9.David Archuleta
10.Amanda Overmeyer
11.Syesha Mercado
12Kristy Lee Cook

[xDramatick]

I thought David A and Jason were REALLY disappointing.
&Sorry, but I thought Brooke killed Let It Be =|
Kristy should have gone instead of Alaina/Kady, and David H should have gone instead of Danny. He has like. NO personality. I forget he's even there. I only know him as 'that gay stripper'.

David Cook is fast becoming a favourite in my eyes, though Ramiele+Michael are consistantly good IMO.

[Dan_]

Kristy really needs to go,has she given one good performance yet? She was particularly terrible last night.Amanda's really not my cup of tea and Syesha was back to being out of tune.

David Archuleta was incredibly disappointing after 3 very good weeks, guess that the nerves got to him.Jason's been pretty much the same other than last week, his style is just too laid back.Lol the whole gay stripper thing with David H is kinda off-putting when he sings but he does have a good voice.

David Cook's my 3rd favourite overall, he's been very good apart from week 1 but that was a crap song choice.

Ramiele was really good vocally but a bit boring.I'm not really a fan of Michael but he was good this week.

I'm glad Chikezie got good feedback from all the judges this week.

[Dan_]

1.David Archuleta-After last weeks mishap he was back to his best.If there was any beatles song I could have picked for him it would've been this.9/10
2.David Cook--I think he's the most consistent guy in the competition, yet another good performance.Not sure about the voicebox bit.8/10
3.Carly Smithson-Starting to come into her own as the best girl in the competition.8/10
4.Syesha Mercado-Most certainly one of her stronest performances.7/10
5.Chikezie-Started off really well but It went abit downhill from the middle onwards with the strange arrangement.6.5/10
6.Ramiele Malubay-Showed her potential in parts but also there were a fair few bum notes, inconsistent performance.6/10
7.Michael Johns-Yet again he was well and truly underwhelming for me, it's all becoming a bit samey for me.6/10
8.Amanda Overmyer-All of her performances are just starting to merge into one for me now.Not good.5/10
9.Kristy Lee Cook-Listen Kristy don't bother singing songs with low notes in them as you just cannot hit them.That said when she was in her upper register you sounded quite good.5/10
10.Jason Castro-I think we might have stumbled on a cure for insomnia.4/10
11.Brooke White-This was completly weak and awkward.She was like a wilting flower up there.4/10

[Billy]

i LOVEEEE kristy. eight days a week was REALLLLLY good