[30stone]

I don't understand why they always complain about celebs being that thin, shes alright size.

Before i started my weightlifting you could see my ribs more-so than hers, loads of peoples are there is no problem with her being skinny. Just constantly bringing out **** stories.


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz...s-ribcage.html

Cheryl Cole has sparked fears for her health after looking 'emaciated' and emotionally fragile during Saturday night's X Factor final.

The Girls Aloud singer and judge burst into tears several times as she saw her protege Alexandra Burke win the ITV show.

A source said Cheryl, 25, had been putting pressure on herself, worrying about Alexandra getting through.

And, after seeing her ribs through a cutaway Julien Macdonald dress during Saturday's final, fans expressed their concerns on online forums.

"Emotionally fragile" where do they get it from??

[Lauren]

She does have a genuinely slender build, so seeing her ribs doesn't necessarily mean she's emaciated. In those pics you can see she has body fat on her arms, so she can't have an eating disorder.

But; sometimes (not in those pictures provided) she has looked very very thin (unhealthily so).

[*mazedsalv**]

In the bit where she is standing with Dannii, she looks tiny compared to her, I know she has always been of that kind of build but if she can, should try and put some weight on, I remember her being curvey.

[30stone]

Much prefer her like this if she was to gain weight she would look just like all the other celebs that have a bit of meat nowadays.

She looks really good and the one next to danni she is leaning down and cheryls is standing straight makes danni look bigger than she is.

[GiRTh]

She's got no hips.

[30stone]

So??

She still looks good lol.

[Lauren]

Originally posted by 30stone
So??

She still looks good lol.

It's to do with personal preference.

Some people prefer some fat mass in order to mould to the body and muscles, some... such as yourself, prefer as little as possible.

I do think once it gets unhealthy it's not a case of preference, though. However, like I said before, I don't think she is necessarily unhealthy in those pics, just slender. There have been times when she looks unhealthy, though.

[30stone]

Yeh i suppose. Yeh she does look to skinny sometimes but why are they picking up on it when she deosnt look bad she has been worse when they havent commented, probably because shes more famous and more people want to listen..

[Lauren]

Originally posted by 30stone
Yeh i suppose. Yeh she does look to skinny sometimes but why are they picking up on it when she deosnt look bad she has been worse when they havent commented, probably because shes more famous and more people want to listen..

I agree she's healthy now.

There have been times when her collarbone has been protruding as well as so many ribs.

She has a slender body naturally, so has a low body fat mass, but sometimes it does look a bit low. Some people pick up on when she just looks a bit "skinny".

[M X]

It's bad when people say that as long as your skinny you look good (not saying that's what your doing) because she looks like she could put on a little weight. Jesus, what's so bad about being curvy to some girls (not saying that what Cheryl is doing) but she's nowhere near as bad as Amy Winehouse, Nicole Richie etc. got.

[GiRTh]

She's borderline. I remember when Cheryl had curves - hence why I noticed her hips had disappeared - Now she seems like she's going down the borderline too skinny road like so many celeb women.

[Saph]

i dont really care about cheryl if im honest. i have no intrest in her what so ever. most boring person on the earth

[supernoodles!]

shes obviously skinny but she doesn`t look ill and who is anyone to say she has an eating disorder etc.
She looks fantastic in those pics as per usual,apart from the upclose one which isn`t that flattering but I thought her dress was lovely on Saturday night and people should stop writing **** in newspapers about womens weight!

[Indierock&roll]

her dress was awful on saturday.. she doesnt have any hips so the dress just looked ridiculous on her ..
it was just a discusting tacky dress anyway

[bronaaaa]

I thought she looked nice in that dress lol

[30stone]

Originally posted by TheMichaelO
It's bad when people say that as long as your skinny you look good (not saying that's what your doing) because she looks like she could put on a little weight. Jesus, what's so bad about being curvy to some girls (not saying that what Cheryl is doing) but she's nowhere near as bad as Amy Winehouse, Nicole Richie etc. got.

Most women are nowadays even celebs are since all this stuff about having eating disorders and that, people like beth ditto just make it worse someone whos obease saying how its unhealthy to be skinny...

I think she looks gorgeous as she is, id prefer her to be skinny like she is than have a fat stomach/ arms n legs.

[lily.]

I think she looked better before. But it's the curse of the celebrity. All you have to do is look at Kate Winslet....

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/thed...inslet-an.html



I personally reckon Cheryl is too skinny now, and she does look tired a lot of the time, so maybe she's just over-doing it, but I'm sure her friends and family would step in if it were a real problem.

[MarkWaldorf]

She hardly looks unhealthy. If she came on stage looking scarily thin, pale, bag under eyes than I'd agree. She's obviously skinnier than most people but in no way does she look unhealthy.

[30stone]

Linda Kate winslet looks a lot better now she looked chubby before.

and yeh markus i agree, she is a petite girl and she is naturally slim shes going to look like that if she excercises and eats well..

[TheMac]

From those pictures she looks exactly the same width as Beyonce, Alex and Danni

[30stone]

Originally posted by mr_mitb
From those pictures she looks exactly the same width as Beyonce, Alex and Danni

she is slimmer alex and beyonce both have a bit of a belly like obviously nice but can see its there dannis smaller than them and cheryl is a little smaller than her...

I think its noticable that shes smaller but not unhealthy in any way.

[lily.]

Originally posted by 30stone
Linda Kate winslet looks a lot better now she looked chubby before.

I must admit Ben, I disagree with you, but it's a personal taste thing.

She looks good in both, but in my view, she looks better with curves. Maybe I just like ma women to be curvy..

[30stone]

Originally posted by Linda

I must admit Ben, I disagree with you, but it's a personal taste thing.

She looks good in both, but in my view, she looks better with curves. Maybe I just like ma women to be curvy..

lol yeh, imo i think it looks like she has a really big belly in the first pic the second she looks pretty good shape.

[lily.]

haha... Well, my body shape is more of the Kate-Winslet-Before type, than the Kate-Winslet-Now type... so maybe that's why I like her before.. cuz I gotta love my own curves.. haha

[Scarlett.]

Curvy women are much nicer