[30stone]

Premiership Player of the Year.

The Nominations are

Edwin Van Der Sar (Man Utd)
Christiano Ronaldo (Man Utd)
Ryan Giggs (Man Utd)
Rio Ferdinand (Man Utd)
Nemanja Vidic (Man Utd)
Steven Gerrard (Liverpool)

http://ezinearticles.com/?English-Pr...ons&id=2219792

Who do you think has been the best?
and who do you think should be there instead of players that are there?

I think some of them shouldnt really be there.

And Young Player of the Year.

Gabby Agbonlahor
Jonny Evans
Stephen Ireland
Aaron Lennon
Fabio Da Silva
Luke Young

Who do you think should be young player or the year?
And who do you think should be in there and who shouldnt?

[Lauren]

Player of the year is a bit of a farce this year. I'm gonna go with Gerrard.

Young player of the year has a lot more variation... torn between Ireland and Agbonlahor!

[Novo]

I don't know how anyone could put giggs over the Likes Of lampard and barry in that List

Young player I was Hoping Ashley young would be there he's Had an amazing season

Hopefully Lennon Wins

[30stone]

Yeh i was wondering why giggs is there?

I think Lampard should be in, and Possibly Kevin Davies hes had a great season.

Also the only reason van der sar is in is because of that run of clean sheets...
and hes covered by amazing Defence, Schwarzer should be in there hes had a amazing season.

And Joleon Lescott and Phil Jagielka both had an amazing seaon without mention.

Out of them id say Vidic or Gerrard.




As for young player of the year i think nasri should be in there hes had a great season scored twice against Man utd. And just generally puts in amazing performance each week works harder than pretty much everyone..

I think Ireland might as he has played some great football.
I think Young would be a good runner up or Agbonlahor.

Agbonlahor first half of the season was amazing.

[Novo]

Nasri should be there I agree And Ivanovic on the young players Nominee's

[30stone]

I think it will probably Steven Ireland and Ronaldo who get the awards.

Poor Nasri...

[TheMac]

Isn't Nasri 24? Under 23s only in Young Player. And it's Rafael not Fabio on the list. Thirdly Lampard shouldn't be on the list, I think Ronaldo should be replaced with either Carrick, Davies or Barry. Winners should be Vidic and Evans/Lennon.

[30stone]

Nasri wont be 23 until June 26th.
Hes not 24.
Hes only 22.
Samir Nasri Date Of Birth : June 26, 1987


And yes i forgot Rafael not fabio either way he wont get it he hasnt made a big enough impact.

Giggs should be replaced he has only started in 12 games 11 subs.

But Ronaldo is like Premiership top scorer i know he doesnt often track back but he is helping Man Utd Massively.

And Lampard has played Great this season.

[TheMac]

Originally posted by Robin-Van-Perfect
Nasri wont be 23 until June 26th.
Hes not 24.
Hes only 22.
Samir Nasri Date Of Birth : June 26, 1987


And yes i forgot Rafael not fabio either way he wont get it he hasnt made a big enough impact.

Giggs should be replaced he has only started in 12 games 11 subs.

But Ronaldo is like Premiership top scorer i know he doesnt often track back but he is helping Man Utd Massively.

And Lampard has played Great this season.

Alright, Nasri should definately be on the list then, I just thought he was older. Ronaldo is joint scorer with Anelka, where is he? And Lampard has been nothing special compared with other central midfielders, such as Carrick and Barry. Giggs may not have started often, but he has made a great impact in the matches he has played.

[30stone]

Yer Nasri and fabregas almost same age both great players. Still 21 /22 I think if Fabregas was fit most of the season he would be in it.

Yes Barry has had a great season.
But Lampard has better.
Carick has been great but i think his impact is shadowed by others.

[Locke.]

Gerrard and Evans should win.

Vidic has also had a good season apart from the game against us, so I wouldn't be surprised to see him win it. Haven't really rated Giggs this season.