[Linto99]

Originally posted by AhmedFan2004
I believe it is as simple as this and not as complicated as it seemed last night, because the HL show revealed the initial Noirin/Siavash talk.

Siavash told Noirin in confidence that he believes many people in the house think she's a bunny. He gave an example of Kris/Karly telling eachother about it (he means he overheard).

Noirin totally betrayed this by then bringing it up with Lisa's team, rather than trying to keep her mouth shut. When Siavash came in to try and resolve it, she 'fed him to the wolves'.

Basically, Noirin and Lisa's crew started demanding names and details. Siavash was reluctant and tried to dodge this, because:

1) He said it in privacy to Noirin, so why should he?
2) By doing so, he is digging his own grave, so to speak
3) Why should he, Noirin should say it if anything, she's the privacy-breaker

Anyway eventually it got out (can't remember who said it, not important) that Kris/Karly were involved.

Throughout this, Siavash was left to try and save himself, a little lying if needed, because he had been royally done by.

That's how I see it. Of course this assumes that Siavash was telling the truth about overhearing Kris/Karly, which the forum says is true; at the bus stop. So I'll assume that. As for the rest of them, it's just what he believes, fine.

To Note: Charlie realised Siavash's discomfort and how he had been played, and told Noirin to spill everything rather than Siavash, because she was the confidentiality breaker. So well done to him.

To Note: Freddie was lying or forgot, that HE WAS THERE when the names were mentioned. He was sat in the circle of four. Maybe it was another white lie, because the convo was confidential and he needed to save himself too.

So basically, I see Noirin as the confidentiality wrecker, and Siavash (and Freddie a little by the end) as the scramblers, who tried to dodge and lie a little, to save themselves. As most would.

Agree with most of your comments but don't think Freddie or Siavash tried to dodge and lie and I don't think any of the two of them care what the others think. I think they were both a bit pissed and getting muddled up. But Noirin definitely broke a promise to keep the info to herself! Wouldn't trust her as far as I could throw her. Siavash was only looking out for her!