[30stone]

Lucie and Stacy were amazing in bootcamp.

Rachel didnt stand out from the crowd, rachel doesnt offer anything more than a weaker not as talented version of stacys voice and not as good looking as lucie..

[setanta]

Stacey isn't as good as you think.... dud notes all over the place last night.
Lucie is technically good but very dull with nothing special or unique to her voice.
Rachel has the power in her lungs and the unique sound that producers love. It's no coincidence that Robbie, Alexandra and Whitney loved her.

[30stone]

No surprise to me that the public dont.
Your overating her.

[setanta]

I don't think I am at all. Think you're underrating her and overrating Stacey and Lucie who didn't perform too well either at the weekend. She has a few problems with pitch but that can be improved upon...raw talent and her voice is superior in tone and quality to theirs when its on the right track. It's something different.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by setanta

Stacey isn't as good as you think.... dud notes all over the place last night.

Agreed. Last week stacey was horrendous. Out of tune, badly the whole way through the song.

I really dont get the hype with her. Lucie I can understand, she IS good. But stacey...plainly, isnt. Her first audition gets brought up all the time when trying to prove how 'good' she is, and to be honest, I didnt think too much of that either. Her voice is not that good. And she struggles to hit a lot of notes, if she hits them at all.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by VickyJ

Agreed. Last week stacey was horrendous. Out of tune, badly the whole way through the song.

I really dont get the hype with her. Lucie I can understand, she IS good. But stacey...plainly, isnt. Her first audition gets brought up all the time when trying to prove how 'good' she is, and to be honest, I didnt think too much of that either. Her voice is not that good. And she struggles to hit a lot of notes, if she hits them at all.

The way I see it with Stacey is she isn't worlds best singer but she does connect quite well when she performs, plus shes a really nice person. Having 'it' doesn't necessarily mean brilliant voice. Great voices don't sell records. I think Stacey has 'it'.

[sweety_samy9]

Originally Posted by setanta

Stacey isn't as good as you think.... dud notes all over the place last night.
Lucie is technically good but very dull with nothing special or unique to her voice.
Rachel has the power in her lungs and the unique sound that producers love. It's no coincidence that Robbie, Alexandra and Whitney loved her.

exactly
rachel is AMAZING..<3

[Twilight]

Amazing? wtf She sounded like **** when she did if i were a boy.