[Arneldo]

Craig, Brian, Kate, Cameron, Nadia and Anthony!

Who deserved to Win and Who Didnt?


I think that Anthony is the most undeserved winner. When ya think about it he didnt do anything! Ever! nothin he done in the house is remotly rememrable!
Cameron is a close second - although he was a nice man he didnt do anything that speical either but i put Anthony before Cam because i think Cameron learned somthign out of his BB experience and Anthony just wanted to win for the fame of it really.

The most deserved winner --- Brian and Nadia! Cant choose between them. Brian n Nadia because tey was non-stop entertainment all the way through the series and provided some of the best bb moments ever.

[BigSister]

I think that Brian deserved to win most but I think alsao Kate and Nadia deserved to win as well. Cameron also did in a way because he was involved in the biggest thing in BB4 the trip to south africa, but Anthony maybe not I dont really know

[Babydoll456]

Anthony no way o zay , my husband shuda won yay : hello:

[m4++]

Anthony, definately should not have won!- Boring and loved himself too much!

[Mike]

Nadia would be my top choice for the most undeserved winner, she annoyed me throughout BB5.

[x-heather-x]

I think Kate is the most deserved winner

Cameron didnt deserve to win at all....although no one was really all that good in BB4.

i loved Anthony-Nadia and Brian aswell though

[BB-Rocks]

Anthony was my most undeserved winner

Nadia was the most deseved winner

[Pipergun]

My thoughts are the same, too!

Most deserving winner: Nadia
Least deserving winner: Anthony

It wasn't that Anthony was a particularly bad person, he just seemed the most forgettable to me.

[jrc]

You say that Anthony was the most undeserved winner, and I can see where you're coming from, but can you think of someone who deserved to win more in BB6? (And please don't say Makosi and give me all that rubbish about "entertaining").

[Pipergun]

You have a point! Not really, nope!

[Legend]

Originally posted by jrc
You say that Anthony was the most undeserved winner, and I can see where you're coming from, but can you think of someone who deserved to win more in BB6? (And please don't say Makosi and give me all that rubbish about "entertaining").

Yep, Makosi. She made BB6 what it was and that's what the winner should be.

If Makosi was not a housemate in BB6 then it would of been a lotttt more boring than it was. She was ENTERTAINMENT.

So how is Makosi (the most entertaining housemate IMO) a rubbish answer for a more deserving winner? Have your opinion but don't tell us what to say and what not to say.

So yeah, Makosi was a more deserving winner during BB6.

Also, Kemal. He entertained me more. Science, as much as he annoyed me, he entertained me a lot more than Anthony.

[xWee-Babezx]

Originally posted by jrc
You say that Anthony was the most undeserved winner, and I can see where you're coming from, but can you think of someone who deserved to win more in BB6? (And please don't say Makosi and give me all that rubbish about "entertaining").

Rubbsih about entertaining? Isnt that what BB is all about?

[Babydoll456]

yay ur rite legend i'm glad my husband entertained u more : hello:

[GabrielleisLove]

Kate was always in the poor section, so I think she earned her win. But most deserving would be Brian, for being so funny and witty.

Least deserving would be Anthony, he was boring. I don't anyone actually deserved the win in BB6.

[Romantic Old Bird]

Helen would have walked away with any other BB than BB2, I still think she deserved to win, Brian was a star, but he milked it on BB, played up to the cameras. Helen was COMPLETELY natural and sweet.

Cameron was a nice guy, but a winner????

Craig won by default, as did Kate.

Anthony really was and is a non event.

Doesn't really matter who wins in the long term though does it?

Nadia was OK, but where can she go with it?

Jack Dee got a new lease of showbiz life

Mark Owen got nothing really except the warm glow of approval, briefly. At least the Take That tour has given him and the others a few bob.
As for Chantelle - who knows?

[Ruth]

I would say the most deserving winner was Craig or Brian, although I agree with ROB that on any other BB, Helen would have won.

The least deserving was Anthony.

As for the celebrity ones - most deserving was Mark Owen and least deserving was Chantelle (in my humble opinion anyway).

[JakeyBoy]

My most undeserved winner would be Trever coz all he did was lounge around and flew under the rader....

I don't think we've had a really deserving winner

[cc100]

Most deserving winner: Helen desreved to win and as ROB says would have won any other series. Out of the official winners, Id say Craig from BB1. Ah, the good old days!

Least deserving winner: Nadia- apart from screaming, what did she do?

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Romantic Old Bird
Helen would have walked away with any other BB than BB2, I still think she deserved to win, Brian was a star, but he milked it on BB, played up to the cameras. Helen was COMPLETELY natural and sweet.

Cameron was a nice guy, but a winner????

Craig won by default, as did Kate.

Anthony really was and is a non event.

Doesn't really matter who wins in the long term though does it?

Nadia was OK, but where can she go with it?

Jack Dee got a new lease of showbiz life

Mark Owen got nothing really except the warm glow of approval, briefly. At least the Take That tour has given him and the others a few bob.
As for Chantelle - who knows?

I love Helen - But i dont she would have lasted a second in the BB6 house! I think she would have been the centre of bitching - By a jelous Makosi and By Craig who wud have thaught she was outting on a ditzy act.

[John72]

Personal opinion...

Most deserving: Craig or Brian.

Most underserving: Anthony.

[Ruth]

Originally posted by bb4eva
I love Helen - But i dont she would have lasted a second in the BB6 house! I think she would have been the centre of bitching - By a jelous Makosi and By Craig who would have thaught she was outting on a ditzy act.

I think she would have been in for ages, and had a good chance of winning. No doubt they would have bitched about her as you say, but it's the public who vote people out, and I don't think they would have got rid of Helen.

[tiptop4305]

Originally posted by JakeyBoy
My most undeserved winner would be Trever coz all he did was lounge around and flew under the rader....

I don't think we've had a really deserving winner

Ok for BBAU users here, lets give the opinion on who deserved to win Big Brother in Australia....

BB1: Ben - Only won because people felt sorry for him, "Cause he needed the money so he won't go blind...blah blah" Underserving Winner, it was clearly going to be Sara Marie.

BB2: Peter - Nice guy...but did he deserve it? Yet again, it was another Sympathetic win.

BB3: Regina: Totally deserved it!, first and only winner who won by popularity and did not have a sad story to tell.

BB4: Trevor, did not deserve to win, Token Black and under the radar wins it in the end, while Bree Should have won it, even Paul.

BB5: Twins winning....bit odd how the other twin was allowed out to help the other win!

Overall,

Most Deserving: Regina, BB3

Undeserving: All Other Male winners.

here is how it should have gone by popularity, cause if i am not mistaken these people got the loudest cheer over the winner and/or runner up.

BB1: Sara Marie, you can't say she didnt deserve it!
BB2: Jess or Sarah... Jess was funny and popular, but Marty should have won it.
BB3: --- Regina won it by far and only deserving winner.
BB4: Bree or Paul, only two who actually did something!
BB5: Vesna! She got the loudest cheer over EVERYONE on the finale, but for some weird reason....she got evicted in the final 3.

[JakeyBoy]

Yeah Vesna all the way! Did you SEE the finale? She got most cheers!

[Bb_Nutta]

Most deserved: Nadia!

Most undeserved: Propably Anthony but i can't think of anyone else who could have won except maybe Kinga if she'd been in since the start..

[Lauren]

Deserved - Brian & Cameron
Undeserved - Anthony