[Ammi]

Originally Posted by ElProximo

In some non-perve way I could like the style, attitude, I called it 'ferocious kitten' thing,
and,
Im may kinda like that talky rocky singing style. Oh don't get me wrong I'm not listening to it all afternoon or buying CDs but if I have to listen to 'tween' music then i could almost get into that in an almost paternal amusement sort of way,
but,
she can't sing. she physically has problems doing that actual singing. she doesn't even seem to be making the effort or show interest in anything but dancing about 'saying out the lines'.

I can't be the only one who realizes she is a really bad singer?? Okay.. i will say 'good singer for local plays',
but,
she is nowhere near the league of Cohen or Matt or Ferguson or Mary or even Aiden.

Totally agree, although she's not the best 'voice' I have tried to see her as the 'very current and now' performer Simon and Cheryl are telling us she is and I just can't see that she has anything to offer - she actually can't sing and we can't ignore that basic requirement in a singing contest. She had so much help from the backing singers to try and disguise that on Saturday but the fact you still heard her lack of abilities just showed how actually bad she is. Cheryl criticised another act (sorry can't remember who it was) for not standing there and singing, but relying on gimmick then out came Cher with that spectacle - I wish these judges would decide what they wanted and be consistant instead of changing their views to suit. And who was the hero!!!!!
Its amazing she didn't end up in the bottom three

[30stone]

.Its quality when they done the lady gaga song as a group cher sounded great.

[rosebay11]

Did you notice Louis' jaw drop when they announced she was through on the results show?

[Shasown]

I wouldnt worry about Cher too much, cant see her being around for much longer.

Our very own kiss of death Stacey.x is on the case.

Have a look at her signature, though read the pictures from right to left.

http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/foru...er.php?u=37795

[Tom4784]

I should hate her but I don't, I hate Annie so I wasn't keen on the performance but I thought she did it decently enough. When X Factor's said and done I'll despise her but I don't mind her for now.

[stewart64]

Originally Posted by GypsyGoth

Youtube video

I thought she was great.

I didn't think it was that bad, one of the better efforts. A lot of the contestants were showing off their vocal gymnastics and in many case the tune was completely ******ed up. Just wish Cardle would sing a bit straighter because he has the most talent, we know you can hit ******ing top C, stop showing off. Cher's version of the Annie song was one of the few performances that worked and was not over the top or all over the place.

I thought the overall show was bloody awful along with the song choices. ****** knows what Aiden was trying to do, I'm one of his fans too.

[GiRTh]

She's singing in her own key and certainly not the one everyone else was singing. To recite a rhyme from another song isnt rapping. Any idiot can do that. If she wrote her own verses then perhaps she'd have something . Her performances are nothing more than an average singer trying to widen her appeal by exploiting the commercial appeal of the 'urban' market.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

She's singing in her own key and certainly not the one everyone else was singing. To recite a rhyme from another song isnt rapping. Any idiot can do that. If she wrote her own verses then perhaps she'd have something . Her performances are nothing more than an average singer trying to widen her appeal by exploiting the commercial appeal of the 'urban' market.

your very kind for saying shes an average singer.

[ElProximo]

Originally Posted by rhino

...I just can't see that she has anything to offer - she actually can't sing and we can't ignore that basic requirement in a singing contest. She had so much help from the backing singers to try and disguise that on Saturday but the fact you still heard her lack of abilities just showed how actually bad she is...

Okay yeah.. so its not just me heh. I was confused because the judges seem to be discussing her 'as if' we all heard how great a little singer she was,
and,
I even remember the one (coach?) saying to her behind the stage "Just focus on your dancing". As if her voice was such a 'given' that dancing was the only weak spot to watch.
Instead I saw someone well focused on power walking and bouncing the dance steps but seems to be 'talk exhaling' in some really sad half-effort to 'sing'.

Oh well I forget she is just a teenager. I'm amazed any teenager can do that well,
but,
I think judges have to be honest and not inflate her singing talent to us in hopes of maxing up her soon-to-be studio engineered pop singles.

Yes - she is perfect for a studio creation. I just wish the judges could stop pretending she is good live on stage heh

[Mystic Mock]

there building her up which is very cruel.

[Vicky.]

The problem is, the judges are telling her time and time again how good she is, even when she is not. So she gets more arrogant with every performance, thus alienates the audience even more and it will CRUSH her when she is voted off, which I believe will happen. Her fail rapping cant carry her everyweek, and her singing voice is average at best.

I think she believes she will win. But I really cant see it happening.