[cub]

Originally Posted by Stevep

no way would he do it. You are practically Simons bitch when you're a judge, cant see Will putting himself in that position when he is still at the top of his game.

I think this is correct. Simon didn't seem very uncomfortable when he was on American Idol with Ellen Degeneres. There was zero chemistry - he seems far more relaxed on the British shows.

Can you imagine Will Smith getting the 'overs' - how would he cope with a Mary Byrne??