[AndyEssex1]

Oh dear.

Just when I thought X Factor 2011 would be a little different, they dress up their final 12 like little puppets again.
I know that Amelia wore far too much make-up for the judges houses (her lips looked awful) but have they not gone too far the other way now?


This is Agnetha from Abba, probably taken around the time of their split in 1981.

Any similarities?

Give the contestants a bit of a makeover but don't take it too far!

[Jordan.]

They've made her look dreadful, it doesnt even look like the same person. Same with Janet.



She was HOT before.

[Roy Mars III]

I thought they got a new stylist? Or did they get an even worse one?

[MusicXian]

She actually looks like she had a mask on before and they took it off. Luckily the style can come back.

[AndyEssex1]

This is one strong point that American Idol has over X factor. They let the contestants keep their identity. I'm sure Amelia is horrified at her "new look" and I'm sure that Kelly Rowland would be horrified if the same was done to her.

I bet that Kelly wouldn't look too clever with all that make-up removed.

[Callum]

The contestants should be allowed to style themselves, the stylists always get it wrong.

[AndyEssex1]

I think she looks best in her audition.

[Lee.]

I think they've made her look less like a two bit hooker.