[Kizzy]

Yawnage.

[Lostie!]

He first pissed me off when he threw a mini strop over the misunderstanding with Becky.

[arista]

Originally Posted by Scream

I'm sorry but why is he in there? Let's be honest, if he didn't have his story about being a female before he wouldn't be in there. I hardly ever see him, he's so boring..

What are your views on him?

Yes thats why Endemol picked him.

[chuff me dizzy]

Hes quite so not getting air time,but is a nice person

[sarakss]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

I can see him getting into future arguments relating to food being a cook n ting.

At some point, I thought so. But then he had that silent argument when Becky was hovering over him as he got food items out to cook. I say silent because he was annoyed but did not say a word - instead he just walked into the bedroom. It's a good thing Arron was there to translate for Becky and the viewers because we would not have known wtf just happened.

[flamingGalah!]

Originally Posted by sampvt

He hasnt had a phyc evaluation, he hasnt even lived as a man for that long. He decided some time ago to privately have his boobs removed and thats it. I personally see him as more feminine as masculine espcially after his tiff with beckie but I need to be carefull becasue the PC crew will east me up...

All the housemates have psychological evaluations before entering the house...

And how exactly do you know how long he lived as a man before having surgery??? Transgender people are born into the wrong body, so he has been living his whole life as a man, but one who was trapped in the body of a woman... And he has had a bit more than had his "boobs removed"

I suggest you look into things a bit more before you post, as you come across as someone who is at the very least ignorant & the worst is rather discriminatory

[sampvt]

Originally Posted by flamingGalah!

All the housemates have psychological evaluations before entering the house...

And how exactly do you know how long he lived as a man before having surgery??? Transgender people are born into the wrong body, so he has been living his whole life as a man, but one who was trapped in the body of a woman... And he has had a bit more than had his "boobs removed"

I suggest you look into things a bit more before you post, as you come across as someone who is at the very least ignorant & the worst is rather discriminatory

When I said he had not had an evaluation, I didnt mean with BB, I meant in the outer world. There are pics out there of him as a full woman and not that long ago either. He proclaims he has lived as a man for several yrs but his age doesent permit this. If anyone is to go for gender reasignment they need to go through loads of tests and evaluations. My opinions are ones derived from reports I have seen and not from any sence of nastiness. My own son is gay and I know what he goes through and even he thinks Luke is on there for fame and glory using his gender reasignment in the worst possible way.

GR is such a hot potato that the PC mob sit waiting to pounce on anything they can. My gripe is that it seems fair game to call people fat, scum, etc etc. In fact any number of really vile and inhuman things but the moment someone mentions Lukes name, we all walk on eggshells, surely this isnt right. HE KNEW WHAT HE WAS WALKING INTO.

I am questioning why he is in there. Did the producers throw him to the lions or do they want the hot debates and arguments, or are they just simply stupid. Luke has every right to go in the house but he dosent have the right, in my eyes, to manipulate the public or other housemates to treat him any differently from any other person. The likes of Nadia made for good viewing but lukes story is fraught with danger if it blows up the wrong way.

We are all used to seeing Male to female changes and know how to handle it but this is pretty new ground and I think CH5 have deliberately put this poor lad in the lions den hoping to get a result out of his suffering. Please dont call me a bigot or fool, that I am not, I am simply a voice that deserves to be heard as much as your voice needs to be heard.

I offer reasons and opinions not judgements. I have based my opinions on the extensive research I have done on luke which is probably more than your assumptions of my lack of evidence. We can only base our opinions based on the perponderance of the evidence and information available. My opinons are based on fact not assumptions. Your opinions seem to lack that credability, sorry but you sniped at me unfairly.