[Siouxsie]

ok everyone seemed to go on about the choreography eton road done(saying it was dated). But me well i think it went well with the song. Whats going on leave them alone
I thought they were cool whats your views >>>>

[Siouxsie]

come on what d ya think ????

[Z]

I don't think that choreography is all that important, too much dancing is annoying (Ray), no dancing is boring (Nikitta) and trying to strike a balance (Eton Road) just gets criticised. Basically, choreography shouldn't be something the judges are commenting on because I've only ever seen one pop act come out from any of the recent talent shows who have bothered with choreography, and that's Liberty X. Girls Aloud don't count, they just wear short skirts and prance around giggling.

[Siouxsie]

yep but they did go on about eton roads dancing tonight didnt they? That wasnt their fault. What im saying is the dancing fitted the song. Even though simpn said it was dated . So what ???

[x-heather-x]

I personally dont think choreography should come into it. Its a singing competition not a talent contest. Yes dancing can be good. But can be annoying. I agree with what you say Ziola. Ray's dancing is annoying and Nikitta sometimes tried to dance but mostly looked a little awkward.
I dont see anything wrong with trying to do a little dancing to make your performance look better. And Eton Road can do no wrong by me!

[Siouxsie]

yep thats what i am trying to say simon got it wrong tonight going on about the dancing style

[x-heather-x]

He hardly has/had the greatest dancers with his record company.

Acyually when you think about it, it really annoys me how the contestants just really want Simon's comments. Do they know the people he has managed? Zig & Zag?! WWF?!

Yes he may have Will Young etc under his wing NOW but that wasnt always the case was it?

[Siouxsie]

zig and zag lol omg !!! thats news to me

[x-heather-x]

yeah lol. I watched the Rise and Rise of Simon Cowell a while back on VH1 and he managed Zig and Zag and the WWF wrestlers when they released a single lol!!!!

[Siouxsie]

i really need to listen to that

[xGemmax]

They should be judging the singing, not the dancing anyway, the chreography went with the song. It wasnt 'dated' as they put it, many artists dance different style in their videos, many old

[Diablo]

I thought the choreography was stupid, I didn't like Eton Road tonight.. I agreed with Simon,, That bit in the middle was bizarre.. Disappointing as I thought they were excellent last week

[Dan_]

The song was old, they could hardly do modern dancing.

[Siouxsie]

yes thats exactly the point i was getting at