[Tom4784]

She was great, she made a better judge then Nicole at any rate.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

I thought she was a very good judge, perfect for the show

easy to say when you are not on the receiving end

[_Seth]

You can give the honest truth without being so cruel. =/

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by kazanne

easy to say when you are not on the receiving end

They signed up to a show that revolves around people's opinions. As Kelly said last year, "If you can't take the heat, you better get out of the kitchen."

[Vicky.]

I thought she was great. Sick of seeing the judges kiss ass tbh. The only one whos ever even slightly negative (except to the utter joke acts) is Gary usually...the show is not about compliments. I prefer them to be honest, even if it comes across as cruel

[Harry!]

I love Mel B, she told it as it is! People need to be more honest these days and she delivered exactly that!

[HBB1508]

I don't mind people being honest but I thought she came across as really nasty which is uncalled for imo - if she was the greatest singer on the planet then fair do's but sadly she isn't and the Spice Girls were chronic in the main so I think she should lay off a bit.

[the truth]

Originally Posted by Phlip

You can give the honest truth without being so cruel. =/

agreed. she is absoluteky grotesque always has been. loud mouthed, nasty , aggressive, verbally abusive and very sexist. she used to tell 10 year old girl fans to make fun of mens privates? weird woman, awful singer too, did they ever sing live? what a dreadful band. they refused to sing live most of their career which pretty uch saw the end of this manufactured nightmare