[Marcus.]

Originally Posted by Adele Wigglesworthit

I'd have Julie Goodyear as head judge

sorry it like me saying i what becky to be an judges

[King Gizzard]

..your boys have taken one hell of a beating

[EddyEagal]

I think it's unfair how the US version get's to have huge names judge. But since that series is failing, I hope Simon realises that his best hope in keeping a career lies in the UK.. with our X Factor. So I'd like to think we'd get better judges.. bigger names too.

When have we ever really had a big celebrity judge? The biggest person to judge would maybe be Katy Perry (when she guested)? I mean everyone loves Cheryl, but she wasn't HUGE when she judged.

I'd love a panel like this:

Simon, Louis, Katy Perry and I know it would never happen because of The Voice.. but Jessie J would be ideal. Two big popstar names - I don't care who they are, but that's what the show needs!

[Doogle]

Simon, Sharon, Mel B, Louis would be perfect.

I'd also be happy with any of these again:
Simon, Sharon, Louis
Simon, Sharon, Danni, Louis
Simon, Cheryl, Danni, Louis

[cheeky_monkey]

Simon, Sharon and Louis
Or Simon, Sharon, Louis, Mel B and Gary

[joeysteele]

I could tolerate Sharon again but anyone at all rather than Cheryl, cannot stand that woman as a singer or even as a person and yes I have met her but certainly would not want to repeat the experience.

[Z]

I thought Mel B was brilliant, but I'd rather not see her alongside Sharon Osbourne because they'd fulfill the same role and I don't think Sharon was very professional. I know that was part of the appeal, but I think the show's evolved beyond anything she'd have to offer as a judge now.