[Drew.]

Not sure if its been confirmed already but make from this what you want

Quite liked her but it'll be good for the show after a terrible series last year having some fresh new faces to the judging panel this year.

[GiRTh]

Its a mess. Cancel the show. Its done.

[Drew.]

A good replacement for her and with big Simon back it can only be better than last year.

[Firewire]

No

[GiRTh]

They haven had the same panel of judges for about 4 seasons.

[Raph]

Yes, yes, YES! I really disliked her as a judge with the whole "shamazing" nonsense. Bring back the wonderful Dannii, I say!

[Natalie.]

It will be nice to get a change

[Brother Leon]

Getting rid of the best Judge. Lol.

[Kate!]

Ah no, I really liked Sherzy.

Would love Dannii back though.

[Vicky.]

She was getting way too annoying really

[Black Dagger]

FFS. And she was easily the most dedicated judge (bar maybe Dannii, but then she only gave a **** about 1 or two of hers every series, happened this year with Dami, the rest were cast-offs for her).

Replacing her with Chavryl and Rita Ora lol ****ing dire.

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Black Dagger

FFS. And she was easily the most dedicated judge (bar maybe Dannii, but then she only gave a **** about 1 or two of hers every series, happened this year with Dami, the rest were cast-offs for her).

Replacing her with Chavryl and Rita Ora lol ****ing dire.

This. For all her faults Nicole was dedicated to her acts. Lets see how much time Simon and the new judge give each act.

[reece(:]

I'd have liked her to stay, at least for some female continuity

[AnnieK]

I liked how Nicole really invested in her acts but she was like a puppy on speed most of the time - far too excitable

[zakman440]

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

[Drew.]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

I liked how Nicole really invested in her acts but she was like a puppy on speed most of the time - far too excitable

Yeah she was one of the only ones that took time out to spend time with her own acts

[Brother Leon]

Would rather Nicole than Simon tbh.

[Mystic Mock]

The thing that would help TXF out a lot is we need more credible acts that are fun to watch, we only get 1 or 2 acts at most that are like that every series and sadly they never win which means that the haters of the show will never give the show a chance if all the voters and the producers will accept is the Sam Bailey's and Leon Jackson's of the show.

Of course the judges are important but what's also important is interesting acts and without them the show is dead.

[Marc]

She's terrible

[Gstar]

Series 10 was better than series 9

[alex_front2]

Nicole was never going to be on panel once Simon persuaded rival Cheryl to return. Read an interview where Cheryl said she'd only return if Danni was reconsidered ie Nicole dropped. Cheryl knows Nicole is one of the few women 10000 times prettier than her * and didn't want the competition.


* not to mention more charismatic and talented - remember how Nicole outsang Sam in final....

[Z]

This is the clearest sign yet that Cheryl Cole will be returning. Sad really. Cheryl's captivating to watch but so is Nicole and she's superior in every way. If Cheryl didn't have Simon's wallet in a vice grip, he could have gotten them both on the same panel and we'd have seen sparks fly no doubt, the press would have been in overdrive analysing their interactions.