[Shaun]

Originally Posted by Z

Yeah I really like her too but the fact her singles discography follows this pattern so religiously is a bit bizarre considering how other such one trick ponies like Avril Lavigne get ripped for it all the time, yet P!nk doesn't. She's good though, I think she's a bit underrated actually.

Well the difference is Avril Lavigne has stayed the same emotional depth and mentality for 15 years. 35 year olds writing about boys and Hot Topic and high school is just sad. Also she can't write a tune.

[Pete.]

Originally Posted by Germyle

love pink. her debut album "can't take me home" remains the best album i've ever listened to in my entire life

misunderstood

missundazstood >

but still good

[Z]

Originally Posted by Shaun

Well the difference is Avril Lavigne has stayed the same emotional depth and mentality for 15 years. 35 year olds writing about boys and Hot Topic and high school is just sad. Also she can't write a tune.

I agree, just find it a bit odd that P!nk doesn't get criticised for basically rewriting the same few ideas all the time when plenty of others do it and are justifiably ripped for it.

[Pete.]

Originally Posted by Z

I agree, just find it a bit odd that P!nk doesn't get criticised for basically rewriting the same few ideas all the time when plenty of others do it and are justifiably ripped for it.

pink writes about relevant topics and I don't think she has ever done this pattern in recent years

****ing Perfect >>

[Marsh.]

Yeah, I think the difference is that whilst Pink has a formula that you can see a trend through her work, it's not as obvious as Avril Lavigne.

Pink has still developed as an artist and moved with the times but you can't see an iota of progression from someone like Lavigne IMO. She's still an 18 year old who hasn't found herself.

[Z]

I'm not criticising P!nk, Pete, I'm just musing over the fact she gets away with talking about the same things, and as a few people have pointed out, it's because P!nk has evolved as an artist over the years whereas Avril Lavigne for example hasn't.

[reece(:]

Enough dragging the pop rock princess.

[Pete.]

Originally Posted by Z

I'm not criticising P!nk, Pete, I'm just musing over the fact she gets away with talking about the same things, and as a few people have pointed out, it's because P!nk has evolved as an artist over the years whereas Avril Lavigne for example hasn't.

Completely agree

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by reece(:

Enough dragging the pop rock princess.

The girl who never grew up more like.

[Jessica.]

I think she's fantastic, but like others have said, you have to be in the mood for her. So many of her songs are arguably 10/10 for me.

[lily.]

I have the biggest girl crush on P!nk and I adore her music <3

[King Gizzard]

That one she did with the guy from Fun (terrible guy) has made me hate her (ok, strongly dislike)

Awful song. Maybe it was just played too much