[Raph]

Yeah Mock I would disagree with Aryan, Mock. If anything she's overrated as some people supported her despite all the horrible things she said, probably because she was a pretty blonde girl which 'made up for it'.

But on topic, this would be my top 10 most underrated reality tv contestants (well Big Brother mainly) as I don't watch much else reality TV.

1) Hira Shah - Had all the qualities of a potential winner yet was boo'ed on launch, basically for just being a strong-willed asian woman. Then got evicted in one of the most convoluted channel 4-style evictions. Also people call her boring when she was everything but boring in my opinion.

2) Rachel Adedeji - Was one of the best singers the show ever had, yet fell in the bottom two three times. Probably because she was an "aggressive looking black woman" because god forbid she didn't have long straight hair.

3) Sam Kay - Arguably the nicest person in Channel 5 BB yet was evicted because of an unfair twist and because everyone basically didn't acknowledge her existence in the house.

4) Willow Macdonald - Mainly just going of TiBB here, but like notoriously hated for being what, a nice girl? The first girl to have a lesbian showmance? For wanting to become more politically progressive in the house and opening up her views? Also for basically being entirely edited out of the show despite probably having the most intricate game in BBCAN3.

5) Kenny Brain - Again going off here but the hate he receives is so unfair, especially given the fact that he was doing what the show asks of you, playing the game.

6) 4th Impact - Were arguably the best group vocally that the show has ever had, yet people 'couldn't remember their names' because shocker, they were from the Philippines so they 'aren't relatable'!!! Or as Rita Ora said "not marketable" because she doesn't understand Asian fashion when it comes to girl groups.

7) Kevin Campbell - Really glad Pete mentioned him as I would've forgotten him otherwise, but he really gets no credit when he was the best player in BB11 and was just an all-round decent guy. Also fun fact, he's the only Japanese person to ever be in BBUK, Canada or USA.

8) Kathreya Kasisopa - Incredibly underrated and kind of hated for no reason if you ask me. But one of the sweetest women to ever be on BBUK.

9) Callum Knell - Creepy callum, Gollum, all these names he got thrown at him when really he had such a good storyline in the house. He battled with the 'be a lad' desires of society when really he was just a lovely soppy guy -- and that's OK. But he's a straight white male so of course the forum wasn't going to warm to him. And the public wouldn't warm to him because he defied the stereotypes of what is expected of a 'straight white male lad'.

10) Sam Evans - The funniest winner ever in my opinion and the most genuine one. Yet he got the 'boring' accusation over and over again and people online and on TiBB really demerit his win.

[Dominic]

Originally Posted by Raph

Yeah Mock I would disagree with Aryan, Mock. If anything she's overrated as some people supported her despite all the horrible things she said, probably because she was a pretty blonde girl which 'made up for it'.

But on topic, this would be my top 10 most underrated reality tv contestants (well Big Brother mainly) as I don't watch much else reality TV.

1) Hira Shah - Had all the qualities of a potential winner yet was boo'ed on launch, basically for just being a strong-willed asian woman. Then got evicted in one of the most convoluted channel 4-style evictions. Also people call her boring when she was everything but boring in my opinion.

2) Rachel Adedeji - Was one of the best singers the show ever had, yet fell in the bottom two three times. Probably because she was an "aggressive looking black woman" because god forbid she didn't have long straight hair.

3) Sam Kay - Arguably the nicest person in Channel 5 BB yet was evicted because of an unfair twist and because everyone basically didn't acknowledge her existence in the house.

4) Willow Macdonald - Mainly just going of TiBB here, but like notoriously hated for being what, a nice girl? The first girl to have a lesbian showmance? For wanting to become more politically progressive in the house and opening up her views? Also for basically being entirely edited out of the show despite probably having the most intricate game in BBCAN3.

5) Kenny Brain - Again going off here but the hate he receives is so unfair, especially given the fact that he was doing what the show asks of you, playing the game.

6) 4th Impact - Were arguably the best group vocally that the show has ever had, yet people 'couldn't remember their names' because shocker, they were from the Philippines so they 'aren't relatable'!!! Or as Rita Ora said "not marketable" because she doesn't understand Asian fashion when it comes to girl groups.

7) Kevin Campbell - Really glad Pete mentioned him as I would've forgotten him otherwise, but he really gets no credit when he was the best player in BB11 and was just an all-round decent guy. Also fun fact, he's the only Japanese person to ever be in BBUK, Canada or USA.

8) Kathreya Kasisopa - Incredibly underrated and kind of hated for no reason if you ask me. But one of the sweetest women to ever be on BBUK.

9) Callum Knell - Creepy callum, Gollum, all these names he got thrown at him when really he had such a good storyline in the house. He battled with the 'be a lad' desires of society when really he was just a lovely soppy guy -- and that's OK. But he's a straight white male so of course the forum wasn't going to warm to him. And the public wouldn't warm to him because he defied the stereotypes of what is expected of a 'straight white male lad'.

10) Sam Evans - The funniest winner ever in my opinion and the most genuine one. Yet he got the 'boring' accusation over and over again and people online and on TiBB really demerit his win.

This isn't the top 10 most overrated

[Shaun]

Originally Posted by Brrrrrenda.

This isn't the top 10 most overrated

well no shit, since only really 4th Impact were considered 'overrated'. (which seems to be the by-word here for "only marketable, completely ready act in the list of finalists")

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Brrrrrenda.

This isn't the top 10 most overrated

You do know what overrated means right? none of those are really rated loads or even that popular well 4th Impact were topping the polls but not the votes.. just because you don't like the list doesn't mean they are overrated. Let others have opinions for god sakes.


Yes I know I say Brittnee is overrated etc but she's popular and was praised all season by loads, twitter/forums... yet people like Willow/Hira are praised by a few people like not a lot of people stan them.which makes them underrated for some people.


this is not me sticking up for anyone bla bla bla, you just need to take opinions better.