[MB.]

Episode 4 – "Let Chaos Reign"
Part 5

Tribal Council, Night 12
The Honifor tribe enter the Tribal Council area for the third time. Once they’re sat down, Judy mentions that the rain hasn’t stopped all day, “unless any of you bastards have just been pissing on my leg.” She then asks Theresa if the rain has hindered the strategic flow for her in any way, to which Theresa replies that it won’t be the last storm, literal or otherwise, that they’ll have to weather in this game. Judy then moves on to the subject of the challenge, and says that she wishes she had a husband as fit and strong as Kyle. Kyle blushes and says that he could have gone further in his efforts, and as a result takes responsibility for the tribe’s loss. Aubin then points out that at least everyone on the tribe managed to get past the ‘empty pole’ stage, unlike certain members of the other team. When Judy asks if challenge strength is a major factor moving forward, Alicia says that it’s “certainly something we should consider”, but also stresses that a swap could come at any time and that “I – I mean we should prepare for any and every eventuality.” With that, Judy tells the tribe that it’s time to vote.

---
Alicia (voting for Kyle): “It's only natural that brain beats brawn. It was nice getting to know you. xoxo”

Kyle (voting for Alicia): “Personal trainer my ass. I bet you’re something crazy, like an assassin. Or a Republican.”

Theresa (vote not shown): “I know that I look like I'm insane to do this. Well, it's because I am.”

Aubin (vote not shown): “…and so help me God.”

---

Judge Judy collects and tallies the votes. As the Honifor hidden immunity idol has been played and has not been rehidden, she goes straight to reading the votes…

“First vote… Kyle…”

“Second vote… Alicia…”

“Third vote… Kyle…”

“Fourth vote… Alicia…”

Alicia looks to Aubin for reassurance.

“Fifth vote… Alicia…”

“Fourth person voted out of Survivor: Judge Island… Alicia.”

“Alicia, that’s four,” Judy says as Alicia collects her torch. She is silent as it is snuffed and remains so on her way out of the Tribal Council area. Once she has left, she lets out a single, beautiful tear. Judy states that Honifor seemed to choose strength tonight, both in the physical sense and in strength in numbers, but reminds them that a tribe is only as strong as its weakest link. She then bids them goodnight and uses her umbrella to fly away like Mary Poppins as they begin to swim back to camp.

The votes in full:

Spoiler:

Alicia – Kyle
Aubin – Alicia
Chris – Alicia
Kyle – Alicia
Takondwa – Alicia
Theresa – Kyle