[Livia]

Originally Posted by Withano

Tbh Livia, the majority of the forum is getting on just fine - you kinda just brought the entire forum into yours and your squads ‘discontent’ as if it was relevant to anybody wishing to take part in this? Which is a bit self-centric tbh.

It was optional when the idea was made, and nobody is planning on making it compulsary.

Me and my squad?

What are you, 12?

We're not allowed to hold the Razzies because of bad feeling and here you are suggesting this. Don't you feel in the least bit silly? Because you should.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Withano

Livia commented that this was a bad idea cos the forum is in unrest
And you agreed

Im here to tell you - it isnt. You are wrong. The forum remain largely unbothered by the events you want to bring up constantly.

So why poke your nose in then when you weren't bothered or interested,leave us to it and get on with your great super 'ideas' the forum should remain unbothered as it's no one elses business,so I am happy for it to carry on,no need for it not to,private things that have happened should remain so. most of the forum is happy which is good,so what is your problem,the ones who have a problem will deal with it.You are making the snide remarks,no one here is a member of a squad,ffs ,but we do agree on certain things.

[Withano]

Originally Posted by Livia

Me and my squad?

What are you, 12?

We're not allowed to hold the Razzies because of bad feeling and here you are suggesting this. Don't you feel in the least bit silly? Because you should.

Idk, get a small group of people to constantly whine about one single thing, in multiple threads, even if its irrelevant to the thread topic, and then project your exact concerns as if it was relevant to people outside of the complainers.... kinda seems like a squad. Open to giving you a different collective name if you think of one though.

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Livia

Me and my squad?

What are you, 12?

We're not allowed to hold the Razzies because of bad feeling and here you are suggesting this. Don't you feel in the least bit silly? Because you should.

Especially with only 16 wanting to spew bile alongside him

[Withano]

Originally Posted by Kazanne

So why poke your nose in then when you weren't bothered or interested

Because you keep bringing it up on loads of threads, most recently this one. Nobody cares? Keep it to yourselves ffs haha.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Withano

Idk, get a small group of people to constantly whine about one single thing, in multiple threads, even if its irrelevant to the thread topic, and then project your exact concerns as if it was relevant to people outside of the complainers.... kinda seems like a squad. Open to giving you a different collective name if you think of one though.

I'de rather be in a 'squad' tbh than be a bully,how little you know the group is not that small,

[LukeB]

Why do people care so much about a game that won’t even have you invovled unless you sign up for it? Go outside and have some fresh air rather than moaning and starting arguments that goes on for pages and pages. This thread was going fine until now.

It’s just not that serious. Move on and get over it

[Withano]

Originally Posted by Kazanne

I'de rather be in a 'squad' tbh than be a bully,how little you know the group is not that small,

Cool. Go be a squad someplace else.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Withano

Because you keep bringing it up on loads of threads, most recently this one. Nobody cares? Keep it to yourselves ffs haha.

Well it's obvious you would like us to sit back so you can spill your bile everywhere,shame not everyone will do as you want,if I want to comment I will and until you KNOW what has gone on just ignore us all I am sure none of us will mind,and go and play your games.

[Morgan.]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

Especially with only 16 wanting to spew bile alongside him

Technically 21 want it to happen but okay

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Withano

Cool. Go be a squad someplace else.

As if

[Morgan.]

Originally Posted by LukeB

Why do people care so much about a game that won’t even have you invovled unless you sign up for it? Go outside and have some fresh air rather than moaning and starting arguments that goes on for pages and pages. This thread was going fine until now.

It’s just not that serious. Move on and get over it

This, just an excuse for an argument which is a shame because this thread was going well and there was a healthy discussion over the pros and cons but yet again it's ruined because people take offence to things not concerning them.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by LukeB

Why do people care so much about a game that won’t even have you invovled unless you sign up for it? Go outside and have some fresh air rather than moaning and starting arguments that goes on for pages and pages. This thread was going fine until now.

It’s just not that serious. Move on and get over it

I don't care about it LukeB you just have to question the motive behind it,and what would be the point surely something POSITIVE would be better

[RileyH]

Originally Posted by LukeB

Why do people care so much about a game that won’t even have you invovled unless you sign up for it? Go outside and have some fresh air rather than moaning and starting arguments that goes on for pages and pages. This thread was going fine until now.

It’s just not that serious. Move on and get over it

oh wow get them

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Blurryface

Technically 21 want it to happen but okay

16 voted for it ,don't try to twist it to make it look popular I would be embarrassed if I thought i had loads of mates on here and thought I was The Big I Am and only 16 people backed me to spread hatred #WhatAShowUp

[Withano]

Originally Posted by Kazanne

Well it's obvious you would like us to sit back so you can spill your bile everywhere,shame not everyone will do as you want,if I want to comment I will and until you KNOW what has gone on just ignore us all I am sure none of us will mind,and go and play your games.

Why comment with something you dont want people to respond to
Why comment with something not at all relevant to the thread
Why get aggy when people react to this, surely you was expecting it on some level

All rhetorical questions, I was just highhlighting what you were doing in the hope your squad would do it less often.

[Babayaro.]

Originally Posted by Jamie89

This tbh. I think those in favour of it would soon find it a lot less interesting than you're expecting I mean, I want to drag Ammi as much as the next person, but surely after a couple of pages of -insert generic insult about someone's faves- wouldn't it just get kinda boring? Forced arguments normally are so it'd probably just fizzle out anyway.

I do quite like Morgan's suggestion of some kind of roast though. If it's done well it could be really funny. Say if everyone sends their comments about whoever's being roasted to the person hosting it, they can moderate them beforehand, and obviously whoever's being roasted will have volunteered, and if it's all done tongue in cheek. Sometimes it can be good to laugh at yourself and be made fun of, whoever's doing it would just need to make sure it wasn't cruel or nasty, but in jest sort of thing.

I completely agree with this and would be here for a roasting

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Withano

Why comment with something you dont want people to respond to
Why comment with something not at all relevant to the thread
Why get aggy when people react to this, surely you was expecting it on some level

All rhetorical questions, I was just highhlighting what you were doing in the hope your squad would do it less often.

What if "The Squad " had chosen to join in your hate thread ?

[Withano]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

What if "The Squad " had chosen to join in your hate thread ?

Then they should expect to roast, and be roasted like everybody else!

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Kazanne

I don't care about it LukeB you just have to question the motive behind it,and what would be the point surely something POSITIVE would be better

Then why get worked up over it and moan? You don’t have to look at this thread if it’s a thing.you don’t have to be involved. I don’t want this but i don’t care that much and it won’t bother me if it does. They are load of positive thread and games so one not positive won’t hurt the forum. I guess withano is hoping for a creative way to roast people in a funny way not in a really nasty way, he doesn’t want people to go too far.

People make a living from roasting people and you choose to go there but it’s not that serious if you don’t

[Underscore]

I don't see the big deal if you're not going to be taking part in it.

Buzz off and allow other people to have fun.

[AnnieK]

To be fair...the opening line of the op is should this happen. If you didn't want people giving their opinion of why not, you shouldn't have asked the question. Don't ask a question if you don't want an answer that you don't want to hear.

There is plenty of light hearted banter and roasting goes on in the chat threads so if it is to be as light hearted as you say, why do we need it?

Personally I think its not a bad idea as only people who enter the thread can be targeted but I don't really see the difference between this and the chat threads anyway?

[Withano]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

To be fair...the opening line of the op is should this happen. If you didn't want people giving their opinion of why not, you shouldn't have asked the question. Don't ask a question if you don't want an answer that you don't want to hear.

There is plenty of light hearted banter and roasting goes on in the chat threads so if it is to be as light hearted as you say, why do we need it?

Personally I think its not a bad idea as only people who enter the thread can be targeted but I don't really see the difference between this and the chat threads anyway?

“It shouldnt happen because I’m not satisfied with the forum, therefore I presume the rest of the forum is dissatisfied with the forum” doesn’t qualify.

Maybe I’m just bored to death of them talking about it - but them talking about it as a forum-wide issue this time was way more irritating than the 2000 times before now. If people have a valid reason for why it shouldn’t happen, they can and should express them. Assuming it shouldn't happen because the rest of the forum must feel exactly like you is just egocentric and daft.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Withano

“It shouldnt happen because I’m not satisfied with the forum, therefore I presume the rest of the forum is dissatisfied with the forum” doesn’t qualify.

Maybe I’m just bored to death of them talking about it - but them talking about it as a forum-wide issue this time was way more irritating than the 2000 times before now. If people have a valid reason for why it shouldn’t happen, they can and should express them. Assuming it shouldn't happen because the rest of the forum must feel exactly like you is just egocentric and daft.

Well stop talking about 'it' then and move on, as I said ignore us.

[Withano]

Originally Posted by Kazanne

Well stop talking about 'it' then and move on, as I said ignore us.

Please pass that on to the people who regularly bring it up. I beg you.