[andybigbro]

The X Factor or Big Brother?

Both used to be really good, but both have went downhill imo.

Which do you feel has went downhill more?

[Jack.]

X factor died years ago big brother still has a chance if they make changes this year

[Amy Jade]

X Factor.

Their ways of reinventing the format have all been dire apart from the Slsix chair challenge and that's a farce now. Arena auditions are terrible, the judges do not care (Nicole did tbf but she's now out) and Sharon is horrific she's actually embarrassing to watch.

Bring back Dannii and Tulisa.

[Jack.]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

X Factor.

Their ways of reinventing the format have all been dire apart from the Slsix chair challenge and that's a farce now. Arena auditions are terrible, the judges do not care (Nicole did tbf but she's now out) and Sharon is horrific she's actually embarrassing to watch.

Bring back Dannii and Tulisa.

Tbh Simon is not the same person he was years ago. And I agree about Sharon she is a **** judge

[RileyH]

X Factor

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by Jack.

Tbh Simon is not the same person he was years ago. And I agree about Sharon she is a **** judge

No I agree Simon doesn't even seem to enjoy the show anymore. All the current judges want is the money from the contract they couldn't give a **** who wins, that was the only reason I liked Nicole over the other 3 - she did seem to at least be a good mentor and genuinely care about her acts. Yes, she is a bit of an attention seeker but she did always seem invested.

If Cheryl comes back all 4 judges will just be in it for what they can get rather than to help others.

[Jordan.]

X Factor is worse, not only is it garbage to watch but it hasn't created a popstar with a lasting career since 2012, which is the whole point of the show.

[reece(:]

X Factor is worse, BB is on it's last legs though

[montblanc]

i meant to vote x factor disregard mine

[Jack.]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

No I agree Simon doesn't even seem to enjoy the show anymore. All the current judges want is the money from the contract they couldn't give a **** who wins, that was the only reason I liked Nicole over the other 3 - she did seem to at least be a good mentor and genuinely care about her acts. Yes, she is a bit of an attention seeker but she did always seem invested.

If Cheryl comes back all 4 judges will just be in it for what they can get rather than to help others.

I really can’t see Cheryl and Sharon working together. But I bet she’ll come back. Can just see the headlines Sharon and Cheryl in X factor bust up

[LukeB]

Both went downhill and there’s no saving any of it no matter what they do.

[Cal.]

XF

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

BB is still somewhat entertaining despite how tacky/messy it’s become so her

[andybigbro]

I think X factor but BB is going downhill with all the outside contact and lack of live feed. Plus it was so good on C4 :and C5 have just never did it justice imo

[Gstar]

Both went downhill but BB ruined itself more. The problem with XF is that people are bored with it