[Legend killer]

Buble what a legend

[Shaun]

Well he was, so no harm done.

[setanta]

He wasn't miming. Very obvious to be honest with you just by how he moves the mic and it effects the volume of his voice.

[Vicky.]

Sorry but singing live>>>>>>>>>>>>>.miming.

Even if the singing is quite crap...

Otherwise, whats the point in them being known as singers?

The only time miming is acceptable I think, is if there is a very energetic dance routine. Which is why I didnt have a problem with cheryl miming...as noone could sing and dance like that and sound good...

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Sorry but singing live>>>>>>>>>>>>>.miming.

Even if the singing is quite crap...

Otherwise, whats the point in them being known as singers?

The only time miming is acceptable I think, is if there is a very energetic dance routine. Which is why I didnt have a problem with cheryl miming...as noone could sing and dance like that and sound good...

Well exactly. Nobody watches Cheryl for a vocal masterclass. But like other popstars (Britney, Madonna etc) she puts on a show.

But with artists like Buble its supposed to be all about the voice. So if you can't deliver that then you FAIL. Just like Britney failed when she didnt put on a show..just walked around the stage like a dozey bint.

Again, I don't see why he should get a free pass when popstars like Cheryl always get slaughtered.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Well exactly. Nobody watches Cheryl for a vocal masterclass. But like other popstars (Britney, Madonna etc) she puts on a show.

But with artists like Buble its supposed to be all about the voice. So if you can't deliver that then you FAIL. Just like Britney failed when she didnt put on a show..just walked around the stage like a dozey bint.

Again, I don't see why he should get a free pass when popstars like Cheryl always get slaughtered.

So should he have just cancelled then? because he was ill and his voice wouldnt be up to scratch?

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

So should he have just cancelled then? because he was ill and his voice wouldnt be up to scratch?

Yes, if he cares about his rep and feels strongly about giving his best.

Otherwise just suck up the criticism! Like Britney had too and many others have even when they have their reasons.

And he didnt sound very ill in the interview imo.

[Jords]

I didnt think he was that bad at all, ill or not. Michael has a great voice, though not too keen on his new single if Im honest.

[Livia]

If that's what he sounds like when he's not well, what does that say about the sucky bunch of amateurs on the show? Cheryl wasn't ill, she mimed. It's okay not to like Michael Buble, but be adult enough to give him the credit he's due.

[fruit_cake]

Matt's already better than Michael Buble...and Rebecca will be too and maybe Aiden IMO

[ElProximo]

Originally Posted by fruit_cake

Matt's already better than Michael Buble...and Rebecca will be too and maybe Aiden IMO

again, I'm not some Buble fanatic and wouldn't rush out to buy his next single either,
but,
saying Aiden may eventually be a better singer than Buble is like saying 'in theory anything can happen'.

Let's all come back to reality a little now.

[fruit_cake]

well I just don't think Michael Buble has the x-factor.. I don't think he'd win the competition if he were in it.. hes too boring IMO

[ElProximo]

Originally Posted by fruit_cake

well I just don't think Michael Buble has the x-factor.. I don't think he'd win the competition if he were in it.. hes too boring IMO

To me I see him as about as interesting (charisma-wise) as Matt - which is not very much.

Having said that, women go mental for Buble. I mean he obviously has some kind of x-factor because he fills stadiums with 22-36 year old women with some freaky 'cult like infatuation' following.
He can go on Oprah and the women just lose their minds over Buble Day.

I don't see it but there it is.

[Kaaarenn!]

Michael Buble didn't mime. You can tell when someone is miming and he didn't this time and he didn't last year he was on either. Cheryl on the other hand, did.