[Macie Lightfoot]

This isn't even a matter of opinions though. You keep talking about how dumb it was to send Willow home, but the person who ultimately sent Willow home was Sarah. If she voted to keep Willow, then she would have stayed. She didn't, so Willow was evicted.

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

This isn't even a matter of opinions though. You keep talking about how dumb it was to send Willow home, but the person who ultimately sent Willow home was Sarah. If she voted to keep Willow, then she would have stayed. She didn't, so Willow was evicted.

Well Brittnee had the choice to put Ashleigh up after her plan to get Zach out failed because Bruno saved Zach ()

just having an opinion deal with it tbh

[Mokka]

Originally Posted by LukeB

Well Brittnee had the choice to put Ashleigh up after her plan to get Zach out failed because Bruno saved Zach ()

just having an opinion deal with it tbh

But her choice to put up Willow was not a bad one or a wrong one... It was theright move for her game tbh, which makes her an astute game player.

Just because you like Willow, doesn't make it bad game play

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Mokka

But her choice to put up Willow was not a bad one or a wrong one... It was theright move for her game tbh, which makes her an astute game player.

Just because you like Willow, doesn't make it bad game play

I just said it's not about loving Willow more..... It's only my opinion

[Mokka]

Originally Posted by LukeB

I just said it's not about loving Willow more..... It's only my opinion

You say that... But that isn't the truth being shown

[Macie Lightfoot]

If you're bringing up Bruno saving Zach then it's definitely worth noting that Brittnee wasn't even allowed to play in that POV Comp even though she was HOH.

[EspeonBB]

It was Sarah's fault that Willow was evicted tbh. She could have just voted to save Willow, therefore sending Pilar home and two members of the diaper alliance out. Plus Brittnee was worried Sarah was going to be more loyal to Willow than her (which was probably true).

[Firewire]

Originally Posted by EspeonBB

It was Sarah's fault that Willow was evicted tbh. She could have just voted to save Willow, therefore sending Pilar home and two members of the diaper alliance out. Plus Brittnee was worried Sarah was going to be more loyal to Willow than her (which was probably true).

Exactly, it's not hard to understand

[Macie Lightfoot]

Originally Posted by EspeonBB

It was Sarah's fault that Willow was evicted tbh. She could have just voted to save Willow, therefore sending Pilar home and two members of the diaper alliance out. Plus Brittnee was worried Sarah was going to be more loyal to Willow than her (which was probably true).

Ashleigh was also acknowledging by that point that she would have no chance of beating Zach in the end IIRC. I could see how that would make it seem like she was less of a danger to have around than Willow. It kinda reminds me of the Shelli/Vanessa noms this year where regardless of what the "correct" decision was, Shelli didn't give the people in control anything to work with and kinda screwed herself over the process.

[MB.]

-jumps off a building-

[Macie Lightfoot]

Another thing is that Ashleigh winning the F4 POV and evicting Brittnee literally has nothing to do with the triple eviction, those are two completely isolated events. Just because Brittnee was evicted by Ashleigh doesn't mean that it was the dumbest move ever to not nominate her. It's literally impossible to say how things would have played out if Ashleigh was nominated in the triple eviction because the events that happened afterwards would have been completely different. Brittnee could have been evicted before the F4 even, we just don't know.

[Marsh.]

Willow is a queen.

[Mokka]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Willow is a queen.

Deathlook.gif

[LukeB]

I'm not sorry for hating on "Queen Brittnee" who can't do anything wrong because she's perfect apparently. Just giving my opinion on the situation which i know Macie doesn't like

[Macie Lightfoot]

Originally Posted by LukeB

I'm not sorry for hating on "Queen Brittnee" who can't do anything wrong because she's perfect apparently. Just giving my opinion on the situation which i know Macie doesn't like

lmfao I don't know why you keep making this about me not liking your opinions when, again, I'm not even the most vocal person in this situation. And this isn't about Brittnee not being capable of doing anything wrong. It's about how you and Raph literally give her no credit for anything she did and have spent months slagging her off as dumb and one of the worst players ever, literally only because she's a recruit and because she took out your precious Willow (who I don't think you even cared about that much until she was evicted???)

I really don't give a **** if you don't like Brittnee, but stop trying to spin **** around about how dumb she is and this and that just because she did some things that YOU don't like. It's just like how you refuse to give Jon any credit for anything (like his social game, which you don't care about unless it's about how Brittnee's social game sucked) just because he took out your precious Neda, like how you think Maggie only won by luck because she beat your precious Janelle, etc. It's possible to evaluate how well someone plays the game independently of how much you like them as a HG.

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

lmfao I don't know why you keep making this about me not liking your opinions when, again, I'm not even the most vocal person in this situation. And this isn't about Brittnee not being capable of doing anything wrong. It's about how you and Raph literally give her no credit for anything she did and have spent months slagging her off as dumb and one of the worst players ever, literally only because she's a recruit and because she took out your precious Willow (who I don't think you even cared about that much until she was evicted???) I really don't give a **** if you don't like Brittnee, but stop trying to spin **** around about how dumb she is and this and that just because she did some things that YOU don't like. It's just like how you refuse to give Jon any credit for anything (like his social game, which you don't care about unless it's about how Brittnee's social game sucked) just because he took out your precious Neda, like how you think Maggie only won by luck because she beat your precious Janelle, etc. It's possible to evaluate how well someone plays the game independently of how much you like them as a HG.

funny because you slag off people you don't like as well, People see things differently to others that's the reason of a debate because people have different views. We are giving her no credit for a reason, you can't make us give her credit. Credit has to be earned.. Willow wasn't a good player but atleast I can say bad stuff about my favourites and not flip out and make out it's a crime hating her, I don't like Brittnee.. she sucks, she made a silly move (most people do) and her social game sucked.

[Macie Lightfoot]

Twitter was annoyed when Julia was saying that John is a different person in the DR bc she heard him screaming from the living room Twitter doesn't mean ****

[Pete.]

Maggie only won because Ivette was stupid!

[EspeonBB]

Originally Posted by Petemitch

Maggie only won because Ivette was stupid!

Lol Ivette was so close to the $500k, all she had to do was throw the final HOH competition to Janelle and then she would be in the final 2 without being responsible for Maggie's eviction (Janelle was never going to take Maggie to the final 2). She'd have all the Nerd Herd votes which would have been enough to win.

Even then she was only one vote away but she left that ***** goodbye message to Rachel which made her vote for Maggie instead

[Pete.]

It's still a miracle how Janelle got so far in Season 6 (not that that's a bad thing at all)

[Firewire]

Legend B did not suck

[EspeonBB]

Why did Queen B suck? Because she was a recruit?

[Macie Lightfoot]

I mean, I ****ing hate people like Andy Herren and Derrick Levasseur but I'm still able to acknowledge that they played good games. You slag Brittnee off because you think that recruits are fundamentally undeserving to play BB or whatever the **** and you're not willing to give her any credit for anything she did even though she probably has the best resume of her season? We're in an era of reality TV where you're supposed to make big moves or else you're not seen as a good player; padding your resume is very important. Look at what Natalie did in Survivor, etc.

[Pete.]

She sucked? Anyone that reaches the Final 4 must be doing something right...

[LukeB]

It's just my opinion


Top 5 worst players

1.Pilar
2.Aneal
3.Peter
4.Paul
5.Graig