[lewys]

people really considering people who were there for 1/2 weeks legends lmao

IMO the only ones who I'd consider legends are Chanelle n Helen Wood. They are the only 2 housemates who have slightly stayed in the press (purely off their stint in big brother, and not off of other things like Lateysha) and controlled their series highlights show, having countless quotes n iconic moments and that everyone is talking about while the series is on.

Issy is close and don't get me wrong my fav C5 housemate ever, but IMO she isn't a legend, she had a legendary take down but her actual time in the house wasn't that crazy, or eventful other than the takedown. The rest of her moments were either selfless or funny but not in a legendary way, more in a this girl is understated and funny without even knowing it. The type u want as a friend.

Jayne was a fad, I think people thought she was a legend and I guess she is the closet after Chanelle n Helen and then Gina after Jayne but they didn't have that something about them which made everyone watching talk about them and either love or hate them.

Natalie, Arthur, Sukhvinder n possibly Sallie, Bianca n Jemima were on route to become legends but IMO if they aren't coming out of the series being the most popular / talked about they can't really be considered legends. The term legends is thrown around way too much.

Thank u for coming to my Ted Talk x x x

(B.i.B is really what a legend is before people call someone who was in there 3 days a fookin legend)

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by JoshBB

maybe it's because I've only seen a lot of BB18 through YT clips, but I don't really see what Isabelle has done to earn the stanning she gets on here? maybe I need to watch the whole series to get it

Nothing, she was good and the best of the finalists but has to be one of the most overrated housemates of all time

Originally Posted by Daniel-X

People not including Helen because they don’t like her I see!

Literally the only C5 HM I’d say was worthy of legend status. (Dexter, Marc O’Neill and Chanelle being the only ones who come close I’d say)

I liked Helen, I just didn't include ha cause I presumed by recent the OP meant the last couple of years

[lewys]

wtf has hughie done to become legendary other than shout to the extent of not understanding and cum all over an x factor reject ?? i never got the hype around him

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by lewys

wtf has hughie done to become legendary other than shout to the extent of not understanding and cum all over an x factor reject ?? i never got the hype around him

I sense shade

Hughie was hysterical and one of the biggest parts of BB17, I included him cause he's recent, if we're doing the whole of the C5 era it would be Aaron, Deana, Gina, Dexter, Helen, Marc, Hughie, Chanelle

[Epic.]

Originally Posted by Daniel-X

Woo Woo IS C5 BB.

In that case, axe as soon as possible

[lewys]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Hughie was hysterical and one of the biggest parts of BB17, I included him cause he's recent, if we're doing the whole of the C5 era it would be Aaron, Deana, Gina, Dexter, Helen, Marc, Hughie, Chanelle

i think i would like him more if people didn't like him so much, if that makes any sense ?? like i found him quite funny n liked him but then when people were praising him like he was the second coming it made him seem less funny to me IMO jayne was wayyyyy more funny than hughie

but if we are putting hughie n dexter on the list jayne n isabelle are on par with them

[Mitchell]

Jayne... a fad...

ARE YOU ON FACKING DRUGS

[Epic.]

Originally Posted by lewys

i think i would like him more if people didn't like him so much, if that makes any sense ?? like i found him quite funny n liked him but then when people were praising him like he was the second coming it made him seem less funny to me IMO jayne was wayyyyy more funny than hughie

but if we are putting hughie n dexter on the list jayne n isabelle are on par with them

He's not even popular on this forum I dunno what you're talking about, he's actually quite (unfairly) hated here

And I don't know why people's opinions on someone change just because "too many like them". What does that have to do with someone's actual merit as a housemate?

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by Jack_

I sense shade

Hughie was hysterical and one of the biggest parts of BB17, I included him cause he's recent, if we're doing the whole of the C5 era it would be Aaron, Deana, Gina, Dexter, Helen, Marc, Hughie, Chanelle

Wow my list and yours are soo close

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by lewys

i think i would like him more if people didn't like him so much, if that makes any sense ?? like i found him quite funny n liked him but then when people were praising him like he was the second coming it made him seem less funny to me IMO jayne was wayyyyy more funny than hughie

but if we are putting hughie n dexter on the list jayne n isabelle are on par with them

No I get that, the thing for me is I LOVED Jayne but she was way too inconsistent. She'd have a ****ing brilliant rant, and then disappear for about two weeks before having another, whereas Hughie was literally in almost EVERY episode starting for no reason

[Matthew.]

Originally Posted by lewys

wtf has hughie done to become legendary other than shout to the extent of not understanding and cum all over an x factor reject ?? i never got the hype around him

and lowkey tea as well

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by scarface95

Wow my list and yours are soo close

We love taste

[lewys]

Originally Posted by Epic.

He's not even popular on this forum I dunno what you're talking about, he's actually quite (unfairly) hated here

And I don't know why people's opinions on someone change just because "too many like them". What does that have to do with someone's actual merit as a housemate?

i didn't say on this forum ?? i just said people, as in general

n it's just a personal thing, like if i feel someone is overrated it makes me feel as if they aren't as good as they may actually be, it happens most of the time particularly on shows like x factor / bgt, in hughie's situation i think it made me deep it too much n think why people liked him so much making me not like him as much, in conclusion it's hard to fookin explain n it's just a personal thing so shut it x

[Matthew.]

i liked hughie but he wasn’t a legend
i also liked jayne but i wouldn’t quite call her a legend.

[Matthew.]

and we love the woo woo!

[lewys]

Originally Posted by Jack_

No I get that, the thing for me is I LOVED Jayne but she was way too inconsistent. She'd have a ****ing brilliant rant, and then disappear for about two weeks before having another, whereas Hughie was literally in almost EVERY episode starting for no reason

ah u see for me even when jayne wasn't doing anything i found her fookin hilarious, like just the way she tottered about in ha heels HAHAHAHA, but yeah i agree with u that because of that she shouldn't be considered an icon, which is why in my first post i explained IMO a legend is someone who dominates their series highlights show (helen n chanelle)

[lewys]

Originally Posted by Matthew.

i liked hughie but he wasn’t a legend
i also liked jayne but i wouldn’t quite call her a legend.

mayb she snapped ! a lady with BRAINS

[Epic.]

Originally Posted by Matthew.

and we love the woo woo!

'we' sorry if I don't support someone telling someone they look like a murderer/rapist while their victim is visibly shaking on the verge of tears. How anyone still supports her after BB16 completely baffles me, an utter ******

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by lewys

ah u see for me even when jayne wasn't doing anything i found her fookin hilarious, like just the way she tottered about in ha heels HAHAHAHA, but yeah i agree with u that because of that she shouldn't be considered an icon, which is why in my first post i explained IMO a legend is someone who dominates their series highlights show (helen n chanelle)

I agreed with most of your post really, but wouldn't you say that applies to Hughie too? BB17 had a great cast but he WAS that series

My list used basically the same logic - the people who when you look back on their series, they played the biggest and most prominent/consistent part in it

[lewys]

Originally Posted by Epic.

'we' sorry if I don't support someone telling someone they look like a murderer/rapist while their victim is visibly shaking on the verge of tears. How anyone still supports her after BB16 completely baffles me, an utter ******

get a fookin wash n an 'airbrush u fat betch

[Daniel-X]

Originally Posted by Epic.

'we' sorry if I don't support someone telling someone they look like a murderer/rapist while their victim is visibly shaking on the verge of tears. How anyone still supports her after BB16 completely baffles me, an utter ******

Cos she’s a witty, dry humoured scream.

Brian was a prick and Woo Woo put him in his place!

[lewys]

Originally Posted by Jack_

I agreed with most of your post really, but wouldn't you say that applies to Hughie too? BB17 had a great cast but he WAS that series

My list used basically the same logic - the people who when you look back on their series, they played the biggest and most prominent/consistent part in it

i just feel like helen n chanelle dominated their series on their own, like ashleigh did play a part in BB15 n Issy n Hannah in BB18 but the vast majority were those 2 and on their own, with no supporting 'cast'.

Gina n Dexter for example were great and some of the closest after them but they always had to be involved in something else to get the airtime (the love triangle, gina vs hazel, gina vs sallie, gina n dexter together) so i'd consider them iconic and fantastic housemates but not the legends

[lewys]

Originally Posted by Jack_

I agreed with most of your post really, but wouldn't you say that applies to Hughie too? BB17 had a great cast but he WAS that series

My list used basically the same logic - the people who when you look back on their series, they played the biggest and most prominent/consistent part in it

a think it was cuz legend is such a strong word i was being really harsh and what are some of the best housemates from C5, i wouldn't put them on par with charley / nikki /makosi, like from C4 only few are considered 'legends'

[Jøsh]

[BB18]
Raph
Imran
Chanelle
Suhkvinder
Sue

[BB17]
Hughie
Jayne

[Epic.]

Originally Posted by Daniel-X

Cos she’s a witty, dry humoured scream.

Brian was a prick and Woo Woo put him in his place!

Witty =/= insulting, belittling and antagonising people for not being on the same wavelength as her while disguising it as "the truth"

Put him in what place? By telling him "his lips looked scary' and that he looked like a murderer/rapist to be put in a straightjacket? Regardless of opinion on her as a housemate, a complete disgraceful bullying scumbag