[Kate!]

Agree with Noel. Sam's a knob.

[Crimson Dynamo]

the day the blimp does this

he might get taken seriously

Youtube video

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

the day the blimp does this

he might get taken seriously

Youtube video

Noel looks good when he's singing someone else song.

Youtube video

Butterfly collector is better. Again, someone else song

I stick by the scrub guitarist. In both those clips Weller is playing the hard parts

Noel needs to realise that he isnt in direct competition with these artists that he's criticising so to them they dont give a sh*t that Noel doesn't like them

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

Noel looks good when he's singing someone else song.

Youtube video

Butterfly collector is better. Again, someone else song

I stick by the scrub guitarist. In both those clips Weller is playing the hard parts

Noel needs to realise that he isnt in direct competition with these artists that he's criticising so to them they dont give a sh*t that Noel doesn't like them

weller is superior i agree girth

[Alf]

Sam Smith is a singer, there's billions of them. Noel Gallagher is a successful artist that made a lasting impression on a generation and influenced many who came after.

Youtube video

[Oliver_W]

Noel is the Morrisey of Oasis.

Liam is the Johnny Marr

[Glenn.]

He isn’t even the most successful performer in his own family.

[AnnieK]

Originally Posted by Glenn.

He isn’t even the most successful performer in his own family.

Well he is since he wrote the majority of Oasis songs.....he is the most credited of the brothers. He owns the rights to most of the Oasis back catalogue so without him Liam can't perform tje songs

He's a bit of a nob but he was the driving force behind Oasis, Liam was the "face" but without Noel they wouldn't have had the success initially as Liam was a **** songwriter in the early days

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Oliver_W

Noel is the Morrisey of Oasis.

Liam is the Johnny Marr

This is true.

[Zizu]

Originally Posted by Glenn.

He isn’t even the most successful performer in his own family.

Noel has written some damn good songs
Supersonic being my personal favourite ..
but I really don’t like his voice and wish Liam had sung on ALL the Oasis songs.

I love Liam’s voice


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Zizu

Noel has written some damn good songs
Supersonic being my personal favourite ..
but I really don’t like his voice and wish Liam had sung on ALL the Oasis songs.

I love Liam’s voice


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

I prefer Liam's new stuff. All the NGHFB songs I hear I wish Liam was singing them

[AnnieK]

The best song Liam has ever wrote was Songbird....an Oasis song. I love Liam and his new stuff is ok....but at any of his solo gigs he relies.on Oasis songs to get the crowds going.

Noels HFBs songs have been pretty blah but the nlast 2 have been better. He is playing my lical park this summer and I can't not be there. I've been at every local gig of oasis and Liam since 1996 so got to see Noel now

[Beso]

Good to see nobody trying to refute Noel's appraisal of the ****ing uncool idiot.

[Alf]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

The best song Liam has ever wrote was Songbird....an Oasis song. I love Liam and his new stuff is ok....but at any of his solo gigs he relies.on Oasis songs to get the crowds going.

Noels HFBs songs have been pretty blah but the nlast 2 have been better. He is playing my lical park this summer and I can't not be there. I've been at every local gig of oasis and Liam since 1996 so got to see Noel now

Primal Scream are supporting him and his band this Summer. I saw an advertisement yesterday for him performing in Dublin

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by parmnion

Good to see nobody trying to refute Noel's appraisal of the ****ing uncool idiot.

that would be madness


hence nooone has

[AnnieK]

Originally Posted by Alf

Primal Scream are supporting him and his band this Summer. I saw an advertisement yesterday for him performing in Dublin

I've seen Primal Scream a few times (because Mani obvs)
Its the first time Wythenshawe Park has had such a big gig....I could sit in my garden and hear it but I got tickets anyway

[Alf]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

I've seen Primal Scream a few times (because Mani obvs)
Its the first time Wythenshawe Park has had such a big gig....I could sit in my garden and hear it but I got tickets anyway

Can we all sit in your garden while you go to the gig?

[AnnieK]

Originally Posted by Alf

Can we all sit in your garden while you go to the gig?

Of course......come on over....we'll have a big aftwr party

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

Britpop was what the media dubbed them.....

Oasis weren't arsed what they were labelled as long as they were called a band.....due to them playing instruments, they didn't want to be called a group

Imo there is nothing wrong with being a group who doesn't play instruments, as long as there is talent coming elsewhere.

But I get that the Music that Oasis were making would be weird to not call them a band.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

what about Islam?

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

Well he is since he wrote the majority of Oasis songs.....he is the most credited of the brothers. He owns the rights to most of the Oasis back catalogue so without him Liam can't perform tje songs

He's a bit of a nob but he was the driving force behind Oasis, Liam was the "face" but without Noel they wouldn't have had the success initially as Liam was a **** songwriter in the early days

This is another reason to think what the hell is his problem?

I remember him saying on Seth Myers show, his back catalogue was coming back to him in about 2025. He can then sell to the highest bidder or keep control. Either way he's gonna become even more wealthy than he is now.

He's written all time classic songs, is incredibly wealthy, revered by his peers and loved by fans so what's the problem with new and young artists? Why is he so angry? I don't get it

[Zizu]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

This is another reason to think what the hell is his problem?

I remember him saying on Seth Myers show, his back catalogue was coming back to him in about 2025. He can then sell to the highest bidder or keep control. Either way he's gonna become even more wealthy than he is now.

He's written all time classic songs, is incredibly wealthy, revered by his peers and loved by fans so what's the problem with new and young artists? Why is he so angry? I don't get it

Maybe he’s just ‘on’ something that clouds his judgement


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Zizu

Maybe he’s just ‘on’ something that clouds his judgement


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[thesheriff443]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

Of course......come on over....we'll have a big aftwr party

I can see your taxi home being a shopping trolley

[Oliver_W]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

the problem with new and young artists? Why is he so angry? I don't get it

Someone upthread said he was positive toward Harry Styles and Stormzy, so it's not just newbies he doesn't like.

edit: retracted as it was Liam ... and "someone" was you