[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
Ill agree to that Wasted. Nadine can sing, and they have ahd some good songs, but looking at Hope and Girls Aloud (remembering GA was in teh same position as them), Hope are individually so muhc better vocalists

Obviously not. They were not good enough to make it past Boot Camp. Where as Girls Aloud each won public voe to make it into a band.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
The defo work together! You can see that when they sing, they defo have charisma. Dan, Leon, And are all boring, and they way they sing is boring. Maybe it's the song they sung, but it bored me, and they don't have a personality between them. leon was the worst singer last night, it was like watching a robot, yet he got through, only because he was a guy.

And FP, are just sooooooo rubbish and annoying, I hope they go next week!

I think Niki is with out any doubt the best singer.

They are together because it was a second chance. They are good singers. If they were good enough they would have got through Boot Camp. Rochelle is the only one to have shown some personality, the rest are just a pretty face. Dan and Leon may not have personality for you, tut they have rue natural talent. I don't think Leon got through because he was male. i voted for him because his vocal was one of the best last night and I have seen him at Boot Camp and Danni's house and he was amazing.

[Billy]

Erm Aaron, Tabby was given a second chance on XF1 and look where he got to.

[Arneldo]

For people intrested. Here is Girls Alous first performace as a group..

Youtube video

[XxShortyxX]

They are together because it was a second chance. They are good singers. If they were good enough they would have got through Boot Camp. Rochelle is the only one to have shown some personality, the rest are just a pretty face. Dan and Leon may not have personality for you, tut they have rue natural talent. I don't think Leon got through because he was male. i voted for him because his vocal was one of the best last night and I have seen him at Boot Camp and Danni's house and he was amazing. [/quote]


Leon vocal was one of the best??? You are kinding lol, each to their own and all but come on he was he worst singer last night! He couldn't dance, he was all over the place! He couldn't even hold his micro-phone thing properly. He was a mess last night, and the worst vocal and perfarance wise. DS were better then him, and there song was cheesy.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
Erm Aaron, Tabby was given a second chance on XF1 and look where he got to.

Tabby auditioned in a group where he was the only one with talent. It was the other way around.

[Billy]

Yeah but he was still given a second chance. They obviously have talent, if they didnt they wouldnt have bene through to the live shows

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
They are together because it was a second chance. They are good singers. If they were good enough they would have got through Boot Camp. Rochelle is the only one to have shown some personality, the rest are just a pretty face. Dan and Leon may not have personality for you, tut they have rue natural talent. I don't think Leon got through because he was male. i voted for him because his vocal was one of the best last night and I have seen him at Boot Camp and Danni's house and he was amazing.

Leon vocal was one of the best??? You are kinding lol, each to their own and all but come on he was he worst singer last night! He couldn't dance, he was all over the place! He couldn't even hold his micro-phone thing properly. He was a mess last night, and the worst vocal and perfarance wise. DS were better then him, and there song was cheesy. [/quote]

Since when is i t a dancing competition?

Leon had one of the best vocals last night and his talent is natural. His song wasn't the best but he did the best h could with it and he was the only act of the 12 to take a risk. I mean Hope sung a song they had already sung in the competition.

[Billy]

Leona sung Somewhere Over THe Rainbow when she did that in her audition, nobody moaned then did they? And I think Kimberley also took a risk tbh

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
Yeah but he was still given a second chance. They obviously have talent, if they didnt they wouldnt have bene through to the live shows

Both Hope & FP were put together because the groups were woeful this year so Simon & Louis had ot make some.

If they had natural talent they would have got past Boot Camp as solo singers.

They are over-rated at this point in the composition I feel.

Tabby wasn't actually given a second chance. He was never rejected. His band mates were

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
Leona sung Somewhere Over THe Rainbow when she did that in her audition, nobody moaned then did they? And I think Kimberley also took a risk tbh

I believe they did, I know I did anyway.

[Billy]

Ok so because they didnt make the final 6 girls of teh competiton that means tehy have no natural talent? They were good individually, obviously not as good as others but it doenst mean they had no talent

[XxShortyxX]

Since when is i t a dancing competition?

Leon had one of the best vocals last night and his talent is natural. His song wasn't the best but he did the best h could with it and he was the only act of the 12 to take a risk. I mean Hope sung a song they had already sung in the competition. [/quote]


I like the guy, he is nice. But last night he was terrible, maybe it was the song. But he wasn't teh best, he looked like a robot.

[Wasted]

I think Leon could have been better if it wasn't for the stupid choreography. It was over the top and it must be very difficult to sing and execute tedious choreography, especially if it's your first time performing in front of millions like that. He was awful last night, but I think the choreography and Brian Friedman are to blame, I also think it's why a lot of the others were terrible.

[Billy]

The reason Kimberley was so bad is cos of that Brian. DId anyone notice she sounded so much better the second time, when seh didnt have to sit on the piano.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
Ok so because they didnt make the final 6 girls of teh competiton that means tehy have no natural talent? They were good individually, obviously not as good as others but it doenst mean they had no talent

They are good singers but I don't think they have any natural talent. It's all pretty forced to me.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Billy
The reason Kimberley was so bad is cos of that Brian. DId anyone notice she sounded so much better the second time, when seh didnt have to sit on the piano.

yeah she did. She put the fun into X Factor. She didn't desever to go.

[Shaun]

There's many things I could say, but I shan't because I'd get banned

Aaron, for you to say my friend has "no natural talent" - that's just nasty. I KNOW she has natural talent, they ARE good singers, and not every one of the hundreds of thousands can make it through to the final 6 of a category.

As a group, Hope blend well, their voices harmonise well, and they look the part.

Please don't say they're talentless rejects, it's not a nice thing to read about a friend.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Shaun
There's many things I could say, but I shan't because I'd get banned

Aaron, for you to say my friend has "no natural talent" - that's just nasty. I KNOW she has natural talent, they ARE good singers, and not every one of the hundreds of thousands can make it through to the final 6 of a category.

As a group, Hope blend well, their voices harmonise well, and they look the part.

Please don't say they're talentless rejects, it's not a nice thing to read about a friend.

I have watched them for the past however weeks and thatmy opinion. If you dont want to hear my opinion then don't read it.

[Gemmer-x]

I Like Them.

[Billy]

Shaun i wouldnt read to mych into it, he thought Leon was good

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Arneldo

I have watched them for the past however weeks and thatmy opinion. If you dont want to hear my opinion then don't read it.

Oh yes, I forgot that I could temporarily turn blind.

It's a forum, Aaron, people read things.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Shaun

Oh yes, I forgot that I could temporarily turn blind.

It's a forum, Aaron, people read things.

If youre going to read it then respect my opinion.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
Shaun i wouldnt read to mych into it, he thought Leon was good

So did many other who voted him into next weeks show

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Arneldo

If youre going to read it then respect my opinion.

Then respect the opinions of the other members of this forum; many have said that Hope have talent, are good singers, blend well as a group, etc., but you keep claiming this to be rubbish.

Respect our opinions, and I shall respect yours