[Callum]

Originally posted by Matt
She doesn't deserve to be there and she's not the most talented of the finalists. It's no loss to the show.

Eck Hum! It's a huge loss to me

[Billy]

Alisha would have and still willprobably

[Matt]

Originally posted by Callum
IT IS A HUGE LOSS FOR ME, SAM. The papers have done it again, the bastards, they always have to pick on people, they did it to heather mills and they've done it to emily.

And I'm glad they did. Anybody that behaves like she did in those videos does not deserve that kind of exposure.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
Alisha would have and still willprobably

It is/would have been a double eliminations, and bookies had Alisha & Emily as faves to go.

[Callum]

Originally posted by Matt

And I'm glad they did. Anybody that behaves like she did in those videos does not deserve that kind of exposure.

She's only 15 for gods sake, and she's been the only one who the papers have bullied.

[Billy]

Bookies also had EMily as fave to go last week, and well seh didnt

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Matt

And I'm glad they did. Anybody that behaves like she did in those videos does not deserve that kind of exposure.

That last video is horrible, that poor girl saying "please stop" and she didn't.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Callum

She's only 15 for gods sake, and she's been the only one who the papers have bullied.

What about Rydian then? They ent been nice about him either.

[Callum]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX

What about Rydian then? They ent been nice about him either.

Compared to what they've said about Emily, he's like a angel.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Callum

She's only 15 for gods sake, and she's been the only one who the papers have bullied.

And what about the girl she was bullying in that video? How do you think she feels?

Emily got as good as she gave.

[Billy]

BULLYING? Matt how do you know she bullied her? for all you know the girl could have done somethign really nasty to her before hand but noo you've written Emily off as being a bully, when that video shows her fighting, not bullyin

[Callum]

Originally posted by Matt

And what about the girl she was bullying in that video? How do you think she feels?

Emily got as good as she gave.

Well it's all in the past now, the papers have done that on purpose, I bet they had those videos since the start and they've just decided to make them public now because they obviously hate emily and want her to go.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Callum

Compared to what they've said about Emily, he's like a angel.

Rhydian didnt attack a girl, hitting her and pulling her hair. Rhydian didnt hold a knife up to a helpless boy and say "I'm gonna cut your eyes out!".

[Callum]

Originally posted by Billy
BULLYING? Matt how do you know she bullied her? for all you know the girl could have done somethign really nasty to her before hand but noo you've written Emily off as being a bully, when that video shows her fighting, not bullyin

Exactly. I think some people here are judging much too quickly, like Billy said how do you know that Emily was bullying?!

[supernoodles!]

i diddnt think she was very good anyway and not that likeable

[Matt]

Originally posted by Billy
BULLYING? Matt how do you know she bullied her? for all you know the girl could have done somethign really nasty to her before hand but noo you've written Emily off as being a bully, when that video shows her fighting, not bullyin

And what about the "I'm gonna stab you" incident? Not exactly the actions of a well-behaved young girl is it?

[Matt]

Originally posted by Arneldo

Rhydian didnt attack a girl, hitting her and pulling her hair. Rhydian didnt hold a knife up to a helpless boy and say "I'm going to cut your eyes out!".

Rhydian is a saint compared to her.

Emily got her come-uppance and she deserved it.

[Billy]

Actually, both the "terrified teenager" and Emily were laughing on the video. They were teenagers playing around, which shouldnt have happened but it did

[Redmond]

It looked like a premeditated attack to me, with others filming it, more bullying than just a regular fight (in my opinion). Emily wasn't that good of a singer anyway.

[Callum]

Originally posted by Matt

Rhydian is a saint compared to her.

Emily got her come-uppance and she deserved it.

How did she deserve it? How do you know it wasn't even a joke? I bet you wouldn't say all of this to her face

[XxShortyxX]

There are two sides to every story, we must remember that, but both videos do show her being nasty.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Callum

How did she deserve it? How do you know it wasn't even a joke? I bet you wouldn't say all of this to her face

Oh, that's some joke isn't it... yeah, that's what I'll do, the next person I meet I'm gonna start punching them and I'll also threaten to cut their eyes out...

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Callum

How did she deserve it? How do you know it wasn't even a joke? I bet you wouldn't say all of this to her face

Yes, a joke. Kicking, hitting, scraping, pulling her hair, pushing her to the ground. Very funny, ha ha.

[dupin]

Ding dong the witch is dead, the wicked witch is dead!

I'm glad she's gone, I hope they replace her.

Not a good year for Emily's on reality tv shows, is it? Watch out, Emily from Hope!

[Matt]

Originally posted by dupin
Ding dong the witch is dead, the wicked witch is dead!