About Us ThisisBigBrother.com

Wasted · 10-11-2007, 07:57 PM

Rhydian can't just change his voice to suit other genres in a week. And if you expect him to do that over the course of these weeks, then the other contestants should be able to change their voices to suit opera. But they can't. So in that case you can't just criticise one act alone for being limited, so it doesn't make Rhydian any better or worse than the other contestants.

Red Moon · 10-11-2007, 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_
That's his voice though, he's not suddenly going to become a rock singer is he? He's done different types of song but his voice isn't going to change, it's not the versatility factor.He should be judged by his voice.

Niki's mainly a ballad singer, so is Beverley but they don't get anything aimed at them.

Well it's boring. It's Classic FM dose Rock. He should be on a classical singing show not the X Factor. Classical voices sound rubbish singing contemporary rock and pop songs. His voice is all wrong for what he is singing.

It sounds rubbish and he lied to the judges in the auditions.

Red Moon · 10-11-2007, 08:01 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Wasted
So in that case you can't just criticise one act alone for being limited, so it doesn't make Rhydian any better or worse than the other contestants.

Yes I can. I just did.

Legend · 10-11-2007, 09:18 PM

Loved
1. Same Difference; their performance's are always faultless, a lot of effort goes in and it always pays off.
2. Rydian
Liked
3. Alisha
4. Hope
Meh
5. Beverley
Didn't like
6. Niki
7. Andy
8. Leon; constantly bores me. The whole ''performing'' aspect seems so forced and not natural atall, and I think the whole ''I'm enjoying it, it's so much fun'' is all an act now too, I still think he dreads getting up their each week.

Ross · 10-11-2007, 09:21 PM

1. Same Difference
2. Beverely
3. Alisha
4. Andy
5. Rhydian
6. Hope
7. Niki
8. Leon

CassetteFinger · 10-11-2007, 09:49 PM

1.Alisha
2.Rhydian
3.Same difference
4.Beverley
5.Hope
6.Niki
7.Leon
8.Andy

Dan_ · 11-11-2007, 12:10 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Red Moon

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_
That's his voice though, he's not suddenly going to become a rock singer is he? He's done different types of song but his voice isn't going to change, it's not the versatility factor.He should be judged by his voice.

Niki's mainly a ballad singer, so is Beverley but they don't get anything aimed at them.

Well it's boring. It's Classic FM dose Rock. He should be on a classical singing show not the X Factor. Classical voices sound rubbish singing contemporary rock and pop songs. His voice is all wrong for what he is singing.

It sounds rubbish and he lied to the judges in the auditions.

He's not struggled at all so far in my view, he's been about the best week in week out and all the judges seem in agreement.

He's not having trouble with the songs he's being given so he should be on the show,no need to just restrict the X Factor to a couple of genre's.

By saying at his audition that he doesn't just sing opera he meant he can take on songs from different genre's and adapt his voice to them, which he has done so far.