[rayheartbliss]

Originally posted by Billy21

It has nothing to do with the fact the performance wasn't good.

ok

but..you see she wouldnt even be allowed to perform if she wasnt healthy enough!

and she was fine!
she was quite ill and still was able to put on a good performance! *although her weakest*

[Billy]

Originally posted by rayheartbliss

ok

but..you see she wouldnt even be allowed to perform if she wasnt healthy enough!

and she was fine!
she was quite ill and still was able to put on a good performance! *although her weakest*

Diana was going to perform regardless, even Simon said tonight that she wasn't well enough.

She wasn't fine at all, anyone saying that is kidding themselves.

[Lauren]

If singing last week could've damaged her vocal tract last week, then I think the producers were playing a dangerous game by letting her perform this week too.

I'm not a Diana fan, and I still have my reservations about it being severe laryngitis, but I'd hate to see the girl risk her voice for the rest of her life?

[*mazedsalv**]

All contestants have had bad days and songs. This was Diana's time, and it was okay imo considering she was ill.

[rayheartbliss]

Originally posted by Billy21

Diana was going to perform regardless, even Simon said tonight that she wasn't well enough.

She wasn't fine at all, anyone saying that is kidding themselves.

oh god....was she dying then!

but thats up to you! if you want her to go home because "she is not well enough"

this is what she wants to do, otherwise she wouldnt be fighting to be on that stage!

[Billy]

Originally posted by *mazedsalv**
All contestants have had bad days and songs. This was Diana's time, and it was okay imo considering she was ill.

Lmao, it wasn't about the performance, for the eightieth time. She didn't have a bad day, she had sever laryngitis.

[rayheartbliss]

Originally posted by *mazedsalv**
All contestants have had bad days and songs. This was Diana's time, and it was okay imo considering she was ill.

yerh, she was always going to have a bad week and im glad it was at this stage, because if she hasnt, then people will just be looking forward for a bad week for her.

[rayheartbliss]

Originally posted by Billy21



she had sever laryngitis.

yerh, it was severe last week!

if it was still severe, then wouldnt be last week's free pass be a complete robbery because tonight she showed she could still perform even with illness.


tonight it wasnt a SEVERE ILNESS!

because they let her perform!

[Billy]

Originally posted by rayheartbliss

yerh, it was severe last week!

if it was still severe, then wouldnt be last week's free pass be a complete robbery because tonight she showed she could still perform even with illness.


tonight it wasnt a SEVERE ILNESS!

because they let her perform!

Are you being serious? Sever laryngitis doesnt just go away, either way she still had laryngitis tonight, jesus.

[AngRemembered]

Originally posted by officialleafan

You wouldn't know talent if came up behind you dressed in drag and slapped you on the face

which therefore makes him a good judge for the X factor, just ask Louis Walsh

[*mazedsalv**]

Originally posted by Billy21

Lmao, it wasn't about the performance, for the eightieth time. She didn't have a bad day, she had sever laryngitis.

I know, but it was her decision to perform, she didnt want to leave the competition, she said in her VT, "Im going to perform, voice or no voice"

[Billy]

Originally posted by *mazedsalv**

I know, but it was her decision to perform, she didnt want to leave the competition, she said in her VT, "Im going to perform, voice or no voice"

Right I'm not even going to continue, because that is my whole bloody point :\

[Lauren]

Originally posted by *mazedsalv**

I know, but it was her decision to perform, she didnt want to leave the competition, she said in her VT, "Im going to perform, voice or no voice"

I appreciate that, but last week their decision not to let her perform was because of the longterm effects of it. Since they since confirmed it was severe laryngitis, means she'd have had it this week too - and again it could cause severe longterm effects.
They shouldn't have let her take that risk.

[rayheartbliss]

Originally posted by Billy21

Are you being serious? Sever laryngitis doesnt just go away, either way she still had laryngitis tonight, jesus.

so , last week she would have been able to perform then!

because she did this week, even though as you say, shes ill!

[rayheartbliss]

lets just hope shes better next week!

[XxShortyxX]

We all heard what that doctor man said, oh and me best mate has just got over Laryngitis, she had it for 2 weeks.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Lauren
I appreciate that, but last week their decision not to let her perform was because of the longterm effects of it. Since they since confirmed it was severe laryngitis, means she'd have had it this week too - and again it could cause severe longterm effects.
They shouldn't have let her take that risk.

I know what you are saying..... I think it's more that if she didn't sing she was going go so she had to sing.... and that is how it was put to her.

I don't think she really had any choice but to sing tonight, even if she shouldn't have for her own health.

[Lauren]

Originally posted by Red Moon

I don't think she really had any choice but to sing tonight, even if she shouldn't have for her own health.

I'm saying this as unbiased as possible, cos I'm not a fan of hers.

I think if she sings the next few weeks, she will get far in the competition but she's hindering her chances of a career post-xfactor, because it will no doubt do damage to her vocal tract.

If she quits now (which I don't want to say I want her to do, because it will sound like I'm just being bitter LOL) she won't be damaging her voice and I think she has a good chance of a bright career afterwards because she has an existing and loyal fanbase.

[Indierock&roll]

i just watched her performance then and i actually loved it! aha

[Wildcat!]

By the way, Billy is obviously a fan of Diana's. He is probably just concerned about her long term career! Some people obviously didt quite get that!

[Lauren]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
By the way, Billy is obviously a fan of Diana's. He is probably just concerned about her long term career! Some people obviously didt quite get that!

Yeah I agree. I'd say he's more of a fan than most people, the fact he's considering her future career rather than getting further on TXF.

[Adamw92]

Originally posted by Billy21

Did you see her up there? It wasn't the fact it was a poor performance, it was the fact that she looked as though she could collapse at any moment, it was so uncomfortable to watch.

So you'd rather her give up on her dream than fight for what she wants, if she wants to be there than she should

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Lauren
I'm saying this as unbiased as possible, cos I'm not a fan of hers.

I think if she sings the next few weeks, she will get far in the competition but she's hindering her chances of a career post-xfactor, because it will no doubt do damage to her vocal tract.

If she quits now (which I don't want to say I want her to do, because it will sound like I'm just being bitter LOL) she won't be damaging her voice and I think she has a good chance of a bright career afterwards because she has an existing and loyal fanbase.

I do wonder how long she will a last as a big seller of albums. I can see her doing well for the first album and then a lot of the loyal fans will find something else that's fashionable to like and desert her.

Of course the fan base she is left with will keep buying her stuff and go to see her, but she won't ever equal the success of her first album.

The problem with being contemporary is you can soon become out of date.

[mizzy25]

she sounded exaclty like she always sounds

[Billy]

Originally posted by Adamw92

So you'd rather her give up on her dream than fight for what she wants, if she wants to be there than she should

Yes I would, if it means she isn't going to damage her voice.