[LemonJam]

Dannii took care of all of her acts really well and gave them great songs that suited them. You can tell that she actually cared for all three of them.

[Adamw92]

Cheryl, she was close to all her acts and gave them quite a few good song choices but had bad luck with Laura going so early

[Scotboy88]

100 % Cheryl, because she respect and care to her act.

[rayheartbliss]

Originally posted by Zee
Dannii because the Over 25s category is traditionally a difficult one to succeed in, and she was the last judge with 3 acts in the competition!

yerh..
the over 25s are usually the ones who gets eliminated early!

[Emilee]

Cheryl, just coz shes awesome!

[Matt08]

Originally posted by LemonJam
Dannii took care of all of her acts really well and gave them great songs that suited them. You can tell that she actually cared for all three of them.

I wouldn't say With Every Heartbeat was a great song choice, same goes for most of Rachel's other song choices by Dannii. She also had Daniel who was a complete flop and was rubbish every week.

Only act I thought Dannii did well with was Ruth.

[Matt08]

Originally posted by Emilee
Cheryl, just coz shes awesome!

Welcome back Emilee! How are you?

[rayheartbliss]

Originally posted by Matt08

I wouldn't say With Every Heartbeat was a great song choice, same goes for most of Rachel's other song choices by Dannii. She also had Daniel who was a complete flop and was rubbish every week.

Only act I thought Dannii did well with was Ruth.

if you think about it, if the over 25s were that bad, then they would defenatly have gone over the likes of austin/laura
but the votes obviously prefered the oldies!
and danni did seem to have worked realy hard, with all the pressure put on her shoulders, of the whole "cherly being the new girl" and she had to work with rachel (who didnt want her as a mentor)

[Billy]

Originally posted by Matt08

I wouldn't say With Every Heartbeat was a great song choice, same goes for most of Rachel's other song choices by Dannii. She also had Daniel who was a complete flop and was rubbish every week.

Only act I thought Dannii did well with was Ruth.

Dirty Diana - Rachels choice
Feeling Good - Good choice
Lost in Music - Good choice (Rachel was crap)
Against all Odds - same as above
You Know I'm No Good - Good choice
Rule the World - Good choice

It wasn't Dannis fault about Rachel, and Daniels song choices were all great, Daniel just wasn't.

[Emilee]

Originally posted by Matt08

Welcome back Emilee! How are you?

Hiyaa, Im great thanks.
Thought id pop back for a while.
Merry Christmas
How are you?

[dupin]

I didn't think Cheryl was very good - I think for instance, if Dannii had the girls, Diana, Laura & Alexandra could have been the final 3. Cheryl was ultimately responsible for early favourite Laura's unpredicted elimination, and Diana was a dead cert for the final initially...if Simon was their mentor, I'm convinced they would have been the final 3.