[arsenalforever]

[rquote=2628083&tid=148512&author=setanta]Ethan can't sing and he's American. Wouldn't garner as many votes as a little Welsh boy who actually has a better voice than him - that's not saying much though.[/rquote]

who's got the best group of talent?

[setanta]

Danni by a country mile.

[Niamh.]

Ethan is lovely and he can sing!!

[setanta]

Don't you start again. ha ha

[Niamh.]

hehehehehe

[arsenalforever]

[rquote=2628104&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo]Ethan is lovely and he can sing!![/rquote]

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?

[Niamh.]

[rquote=2628128&tid=148512&author=arsenalforever][rquote=2628104&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo]Ethan is lovely and he can sing!![/rquote]

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?[/rquote]

No, the Yank that Cheryl didn't pick

[arsenalforever]

[rquote=2628142&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo][rquote=2628128&tid=148512&author=arsenalforever][rquote=2628104&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo]Ethan is lovely and he can sing!![/rquote]

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?[/rquote]

No, the Yank that Cheryl didn't pick[/rquote]

the yank wouldn't have won

[Niamh.]

[rquote=2628313&tid=148512&author=arsenalforever][rquote=2628142&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo][rquote=2628128&tid=148512&author=arsenalforever][rquote=2628104&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo]Ethan is lovely and he can sing!![/rquote]

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?[/rquote]

No, the Yank that Cheryl didn't pick[/rquote]

the yank wouldn't have won[/rquote]

probably not but he was nice to look at and I liked his voice

[arsenalforever]

[rquote=2628319&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo][rquote=2628313&tid=148512&author=arsenalforever][rquote=2628142&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo][rquote=2628128&tid=148512&author=arsenalforever][rquote=2628104&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo]Ethan is lovely and he can sing!![/rquote]

is that the welsh kid who was given ten chances to sing?[/rquote]

No, the Yank that Cheryl didn't pick[/rquote]

the yank wouldn't have won[/rquote]

probably not but he was nice to look at and I liked his voice [/rquote]

i would have won i have a fair pair of lungs on me Niamh

[Niamh.]

You should have entered so Steve!!

[arsenalforever]

[rquote=2628351&tid=148512&author=Niamhxo]You should have entered so Steve!![/rquote]

i wouldn't be able to handle the female attention

i would have been ripped to shreds

[Shaun]

I only really liked Dannii's decisions, so I'm on her team this year :\

Ethan, Duane and my dead grandmother > Joe and Rikki.

[NettoSuperstar!]

[rquote=2628083&tid=148512&author=setanta]Ethan can't sing and he's American. Wouldn't garner as many votes as a little Welsh boy who actually has a better voice than him - that's not saying much though.[/rquote]

are you kidding? The Welsh boy cant sing, he'll be shown up big time when it comes to the live shows, hes like bloody eggy from last year! Ethan could sing...and could have been top 5 at the very least. Blondie going nowhere trust meh

[setanta]

No I agree, they're both terrible. But at least Blondie could actually get some votes so I understand the reasoning behind it, even if I don't agree with the decision.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Oh cmon now, he can sing and hes cuter

[Fom]

I swear I am the only one who likes Joe? I reckon he will shock people.

[setanta]

[rquote=2628606&tid=148512&author=Fom]I swear I am the only one who likes Joe? I reckon he will shock people.[/rquote]

I like Joe too.

[setanta]

[rquote=2628604&tid=148512&author=NettoSuperstar!]Oh cmon now, he can sing and hes cuter[/rquote]

Honestly, he can't. Has no range and people wont warm to him like the other chap.

[Arneldo]

I disagree. I think she chose the right 3. Daniel was never gonna win, and I don't think Duane had the personality. The only other option was maybe Ethan over Joseph, but neither would have one anyway.

[setanta]

The three of them are just far too similar in style, that's my prob. And I'm not mad keen on Rikki or Lloyd's voice.

[Niamh.]

[rquote=2628604&tid=148512&author=NettoSuperstar!]Oh cmon now, he can sing and hes cuter[/rquote]

I'll second that Netto

[Tom4784]

I'm not a huge fan of the 3 she chose, I fully believe there was a winner in Ethan as he was quite contemporary and I think he would have clicked with the audience. I don't think Lloyd or Rikki would have got through with any of the other judges (except perhaps with Louis).

[Tom]

[rquote=2628606&tid=148512&author=Fom]I swear I am the only one who likes Joe? I reckon he will shock people.[/rquote]

He's too cheesy to be a pop star imo

[MarkWaldorf]

Joe<3